Gene expression was compared by microarray between control and 10 μM ritonavir-treated 3T3-L1 cells at 2, 6, 10, 14, and 21 days after initiation of differentiation. show fold changes in gene expression throughout the 21 days of ritonavir exposure. There was no effect of ritonavir treatment on genes required for the adipocyte phenotype that are expressed early in differentiation, confirming previously reported findings (
7). While there was a small but significant decrease in C/EBPα expression at 6 and 10 days (p<0.01, p<0.05), respectively, by 14 and 21 days the expression was equivalent to vehicle (). PPARγ gene expression was unchanged at all time points () which agrees with previous reports (
8). None of the other adipocyte-specific differentiation genes examined were significantly altered by ritonavir treatment (). There were no significant differences in expression of genes relevant for insulin signaling ().
| Table 1Effects of 10μM ritonavir on gene expression over time in 3T3-L1 adipocytes |
Cellular stress in adipocytes is often accompanied by the onset of inflammation, endoplasmic reticulum and oxidative stress, which is then followed by physical damage to adipocytes and surrounding endothelial cells (
9,
10). We observed an expression pattern of inflammation induced by ritonavir different from that found in obesity (
11). Typically, in obesity, inflammation is characterized by increased secretion of TNFα and leptin as well as decreased secretion of adiponectin by adipocytes leading to infiltration of macrophages (
11). While we were not able to examine changes in TNFα by real time PCR due to low expression in these 3T3-L1 adipocytes, leptin gene expression was unchanged (). Adiponectin gene expression was significantly reduced with short term (2d) and chronic (14 and 21d) exposure to ritonavir (p<0.02, ), a finding consistent with increased oxidative stress (
12). Our results agree with Lagathu, et al who demonstrated that acute treatment of fully differentiated human adipocytes with 10 μM ritonavir resulted in increased ROS production and decreased adiponectin protein expression (
13). Further, ritonavir treatment significantly increased expression of interleukin 9 (p<0.0007) but not interleukin 6 (p=0.22), chemokine ligand 9 (p<0.0002), and tumor necrosis factor receptor family, member 1b (p75; p<0.02) with the largest increases at 14 and 21 days (, ). Our results differ from those of Vernochet, et al., who reported significant inductions from 5 days’ exposure to 10 μM ritonavir in TNFα and IL-6 expression in cultured human adipocytes (
14) and from Grigem, et al. who reported that short-term ritonavir exposure increased TNFα receptor expression in a dose dependent manner (
8), probably because of the different cells and time course examined.
Endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress has been implicated as a response to metabolic stress (
15). One metabolic stress reported in protease inhibitor treated adipocytes is excess basal free fatty acid release (
16-
18). We observed a trend towards an increase (p=0.073) in activating transcription factor 3 (Atf 3), a significant increase in Atf4 (p<0.0008) expression, and a significant decrease (p<0.0003) in phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (Pck1) expression (). Reverse transcriptase real time PCR (RT-PCR) for Atf3 and Pck1 showed the largest increase (p<0.01) in Atf3 expression at 14 days () and the largest decrease (p<0.01) in Pck1 expression at 10 days (). Parker, et al. also showed a significant increase in Atf3 gene expression by RT-PCR in 3T3-L1 adipocytes treated with ritonavir for 16-24 hours, and a significant decrease in Pck1 gene expression with 24 hour exposure to 30 μM lopinavir or 10 μM nelfinavir (
6). Atf3 activation has been suggested to be a cellular response to stress through which cells attempt to prevent JNK-induced apoptosis, because it induces the anti-apoptotic factor, heat shock protein 27 (
19). Pck1 is believed to be a key enzyme for glyceroneogenesis. Decreased Pck1 expression has also been observed in metabolic syndrome and correlated with excess free fatty acid release (
20). Further, flavin containing monooxygenase (FMO1) expression was significantly decreased (p<0.0001, ). This decrease is another ER insult, in that yeast FMO1 activity is important in maintaining the ER oxidative state necessary for folding proteins containing disulfide bonds (
21). Interestingly, in rat primary hepatocytes, ritonavir treatment induced apoptosis through activating the unfolded protein response in ER (
22) where FMO1 is localized. Other genes induced in expression during ER stress include CHOP and an active splice variant of XBP-1 (
23,
24). There were no differences in CHOP-10 expression or total XBP-1 expression by microarray analysis during ritonavir treatment (). We examined the splicing pattern of XBP-1 at 14 and 21 days, which were the time points where other stress markers were significantly changed (Figures and ). There were no significant differences (14 day: p<0.82, 21 day: p<0.69) in the ratio of spliced XBP-1 transcript to unspliced XBP-1 transcript in ritonavir- vs. vehicle-treated cells at 14 days (0.163±0.014 vs. 0.173±0.015
) and 21 days (0.124±0.041 vs. 0.149±0.047), respectively. Therefore, in 3T3-L1 adipocytes, ritonavir treatment did not induce expression of genes known to initiate the unfolded protein response in ER (
24,
25).
Microarray analysis suggested that ritonavir treated adipocytes may have oxidative stress, because cytochrome C oxidase, subunit VIa, polypeptide 2 (Cox6a2) expression was significantly increased (p<0.0005; ). These data are consistent with the observed increase in MAP kinase-interacting serine/threonine kinase 2 (Mknk2; p<0.013) and Bcl2-associated X protein (Bax) expression (p<0.0315; ). Cox6a2, Mknk2, and Bax expression were confirmed by RT-PCR, with Mknk2 showing increases at 2, 6, and 21 days, preceding increased Cox6a2 expression at 14 and 21 days, and Bax induction at 21 days ( and ). These changes, collectively, suggest a cytokine induced stress response (
26,
27) which could lead to apoptosis or necrosis (
28). Indeed, endothelial cells treated with 15 μM ritonavir produced 32% more superoxide anion and had increased permeability when compared to controls (
29). In addition, ritonavir treatment of human endothelial cells induced cytotoxicity and subsequent necrosis through mitochondrial damage (
30). Further, treatment of human adipocytes with 20 μM ritonavir induced apoptosis (
31).
Changes in the extracellular matrix may also contribute to the susceptibility of adipocytes to invasion/apoptosis (
32,
33). Microarray analysis revealed decreased expression of many genes involved in cell adhesion such as: latent transforming growth factor beta binding protein 1 (Ltbp1, p<0.028) which was confirmed by RT-PCR (p<0.01 at 21 days, ), transforming growth factor, beta induced (p<0.019), microfibrillar associated protein 5 (p<0.0034), dermatopontin (p<0.0001), integrin alpha 6 (p<0.0002), and tissue inhibitor metalloproteinase 3 (Timp 3, p<0.0003; ). Ltbp1 is important for association of a cytokine, TGF-β with the extracellular matrix, and lower expression of Ltbp1 might result in increased TGF-β signaling (
34). Timp3 is also involved in remodeling of extracellular matrix, and decreased expression by ritonavir () would result in increased matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) activity. Indeed, ritonavir treatment of 3T3-L1 cells reversed the decrease in MMP-9 activity normally seen during adipogenesis (
35).
Lastly, gene profiling demonstrated significantly lower (p<0.0093, , ) cell death-inducing DNA fragmentation factor, alpha subunit-like effector A (Cidea) in ritonavir treated 3T3-L1 cells. This finding has not been previously reported. Cidea expression in 293T cells induced apoptosis by a caspase independent mechanism (
36), but perhaps more importantly, low Cidea expression has been shown to be related to increased basal lipolysis in both human and mouse adipocytes (
37,
38). Although free fatty acid release was not measured in these studies, we and others have previously shown increased basal free fatty acid release in 3T3-L1 adipocytes chronically treated with 10 μM ritonavir (
16) or acutely treated with nelfinavir in doses between 5-40 μM (
17).
Gene profiling in 3T3-L1 cells chronically exposed to ritonavir has revealed a unique pattern of adipocyte response that includes distinct effects on inflammatory mediators, ER and oxidative stress, and potential remodeling of extracellular matrix proteins which may predispose adipocytes to apoptosis. Future studies confirming these findings should be carried out using other protease inhibitors such as atazanavir that may have a more favorable metabolic profile.