The majority of recent studies investigating associations between genetic variation and cognitive performance have examined SNPs in either dysbindin or cathecol-o-methyltransferase (COMT) genes. In general, the strategy followed in these studies is to test schizophrenia patients on several cognitive measures, genotype the patients for specific SNPs and look for associations of alleles with either general or specific cognitive measures. One study, however, stands out for having used a more principled endophenotype approach. Hallmayer
et al. [
26], building on previous work [
27], dichotomized schizophrenia patients into ‘cognitively spared’ and ‘cognitive deficit’ groups using neuropsychological tests and latent variable analysis, thus defining the endophenotype of interest prior to genotyping. They then performed a genome-wide scan comparing the two patient groups, and found an association of ‘cognitive deficit’ schizophrenia (i.e., a general impairment) with a marker on chromosome 6 that had previously been associated with schizophrenia in an independent sample [
28], close to the dysbindin gene.
Two other recent studies have examined the effect of SNPs or haplotypes in the dysbindin gene on cognitive performance in schizophrenia [
29,
30]. One of these also reported associations with general impairment (estimated IQ decline [
30]) while the other reported an association with spatial working memory performance in the absence of relationships with other measures, including premorbid IQ [
29]. In the latter study, dysbindin haplotype explained 12% of the variation in working memory performance, a much larger effect than is commonly reported in studies of this type. Unfortunately, these two studies reported the effects of different SNPs/haplotypes, and so are not directly comparable. Nevertheless, it is notable that the three studies implicating this locus found an association with one or other of the most regularly identified cognitive subtypes: generalized cognitive impairment/decline and specific executive impairment.
A similar spectrum of findings pertains to COMT, an enzyme involved in the metabolism of dopamine (DA). Most studies investigating cognitive performance have focused on the
val108/158met polymorphism. Since the initial report of better executive performance on the Wisconsin Card Sort Test (WCST) in patients carrying the
met allele [
31], which results in impaired enzyme function and therefore increased DA availability in the prefrontal cortex (PFC), several studies have investigated the association of the
val108/158met polymorphism with cognitive performance in patients with schizophrenia. While some of these studies provided confirmatory evidence that the
val allele is associated with impaired performance on tests of working memory [
29,
32] and attention [
33] (in the absence of effects on general cognitive ability), another suggested an association of the
val allele with general cognitive decline [
34]. Others have been unable to replicate these findings [
35-
39], or found differential effects of the SNP on performance of the Wisconsin Card Sort Test in males and females [
40]. Interestingly, the most consistent finding in this field is that patients carrying the
met/met genotype show improved executive function following the initiation of treatment with atypical antipsychotics [
32,
41,
42].
One unanswered question about these findings is how specific the effects are to schizophrenia. The studies that contained control groups often found the same effect of
val108/158met polymorphism on cognitive performance in controls as well as in patients [
31,
40]. In addition, based on an inverted U model of DA modulation of working memory performance [
43], D2 blockade would be predicted to have the most beneficial effects in
met/met individuals, even in healthy volunteers. In summary, many studies of the COMT
val108/158met polymorphism indicate associations with impairments in specific cognitive functions, in particular those dependent on the dorsolateral PFC, such as working memory and attention. The consistency and specificity of the findings, however, remain unclear.