In this study, we demonstrate that deletion of
Mecp2 in
Sim1-expressing neurons results in a subset of the phenotypes observed in RTT and related
MECP2 disorders. We found that
Mecp2 CKO mice recapitulated the increased body weight and abnormal stress response that are observed in mice where
Mecp2 is mutated in all neurons. This result is interesting in light of the fact that patients with RTT syndrome have also been found to exhibit an abnormal physiological response to stress (
Motil et al., 2006). Importantly, we did not recapitulate all of the phenotypes typically seen upon deletion of
Mecp2 from the entire brain such as motor coordination abnormalities and learning and memory deficits, demonstrating that the function of MeCP2 in
Sim1-expressiong neurons is likely not important for those behaviors. By removing
Mecp2 from
Sim1-expressiong neurons we also uncovered a novel role for MeCP2 in the MC4R signaling pathway that regulates food intake and in pathways important for aggression. Although aggression and hyperphagia are not typically seen in patients with classic RTT, patients with atypical RTT owing to favorable XCI or to hypomorphic
MECP2 alleles do indeed manifest aggressive behavior (personal communication, P. Huppke, Georg August University; H. Zoghbi, unpublished data) and some are overweight (
Couvert et al., 2001;
Kleefstra et al., 2002;
Zappella et al., 2001). It is possible that these phenotypes are not observed upon MeCP2 dysfunction in all neurons due to secondary changes that may mask certain primary effects of MeCP2 dysfunction. It is noteworthy that deletion of
Mecp2 from other selected brain regions such as the Purkinje cells of the cerebellum or tyrosine hydroxylase neurons does not result in similar phenotypes (Neul and Zoghbi, unpublished data), highlighting the specificity of the phenotypes observed in this study and the important role of
Mecp2 in the hypothalamus.
Mecp2 CKO mice displayed increased aggressive behavior that was apparent strictly upon changes in social situation such as exposure to either an unfamiliar or an intruder mouse. The fact that aggression is not detected in the home cage but is precipitated by the stress of unfamiliarity is interesting given that patients with autism spectrum disorders typically manifest aggression when stressed or frustrated. When interpreting the resident intruder data it is of note that the Mecp2 CKO mice were heavier than their control littermates. The intruder mice were slightly smaller than all of the mice that were tested although this difference in body weight was more pronounced in the case of the Mecp2 CKO mice because the latter are much larger than their control littermates. While it is possible that the increased body weight of the Mecp2 CKO mice may have contributed to the development of their increased aggression, the fact that the aggressive behavior was detected only in response to a smaller novel mouse and not in response to their smaller regular cage mates suggests that the increased body weight alone is not likely responsible for the aggressive phenotype.
Stress undoubtedly represents an altered physiological state; thus the finding that
Mecp2 CKO mice cannot easily adjust to a new state adds to the growing evidence suggesting that MeCP2 is important for the modulation of gene expression in response to alterations in neuronal activity owing to new physiologic states (
Chahrour and Zoghbi, 2007;
Chen et al., 2003). For example, MeCP2 is important for the neuronal activity-dependent regulation of
Bdnf (
Zhou et al., 2006). Furthermore, genes that are normally induced in response to stress such as serum glucocorticoid-inducible kinase 1 (
Sgk1) and FK506-binding protein 5 (
Fkbp5) are misregulated in the
Mecp2 null brain (
Nuber et al., 2005). Although we do not yet understand the molecular basis for the aggression phenotype seen in the
Mecp2 CKO mice, we have demonstrated that MeCP2’s function, specifically in
Sim1-expressing neurons, is critical to ensure proper social behavior in response to novel and stressful social situations.
We also found that Mecp2 CKO mice are obese based on their significantly increased body weight, close to a 100% increase in body fat content by 20 weeks of age, and an apparent resistance to leptin. Mecp2 CKO mice display normal levels of activity and basal metabolic rates but they consume more chow than control littermates. Once again, deletion of Mecp2 in Sim1-expressing neurons impairs the ability of the mouse to adapt to changing physiology; in this case Mecp2 CKO mice do not stop eating once they have ingested a sufficient number of calories demonstrating that they are unable to properly respond to satiety signals.
Hyperphagia and obesity are characteristic of mice that have disrupted MC4R signaling. MC4Rs function by integrating an agonist satiety signal from alpha-MSH (a cleavage product of POMC), and an antagonist signal provided by AgRP (
Oswal and Yeo, 2007). The essential role of MC4Rs in the control of food intake is evident based on the hyperphagia and severe obesity seen in
Mc4r −/− mice (
Huszar et al., 1997), mice that overexpress the MC4R antagonist (
Ay) (
Kesterson et al., 1997), and in humans with naturally occurring mutations in
MC4R (
Lubrano-Berthelier et al., 2006). MC4Rs are densely expressed in the PVN, an area that receives inputs from both POMC and AgRP/NPY neurons, and their function, specifically in the PVN, is essential to maintain proper control of food intake (
Balthasar et al., 2005). We demonstrate that
Mecp2 CKO mice express normal levels of
Mc4r,
Pomc1, and
Agrp but they have a small decrease in
Npy in the ARC and a profound induction of
Npy in the DMH. The finding that
Npy is decreased in the ARC is not surprising since NPY neurons in the ARC typically respond to increases in leptin by downregulating the expression of
Npy (
Stephens et al., 1995). Increased
Npy expression in the DMH, however, has been noted in a variety of rodent models that exhibit reduced function of melanocortin pathways including the agouti yellow mice (
Ay),
tubby mice, diet-induced obese mice (DIO),
Mc4r −/− mice, and WT lactating rats (
Chen et al., 2004;
Guan et al., 1998;
Kesterson et al., 1997). Importantly, increased expression of
Npy in the DMH is not associated with all models of genetic obesity, since leptin-deficient
ob/
ob mice do not display detectable levels of
Npy in the DMH (
Kesterson et al., 1997). Thus, the ectopic expression of
Npy in the DMH serves as a marker of disrupted MC4R signaling which seems to be occurring in the
Mecp2 CKO mice.
Because our data point to a disruption of MC4R signaling in the
Mecp2 CKO mice despite normal expression of upstream components of the pathway, we examined some of the downstream mediators of MC4R signaling in the PVN. Recent studies have suggested that both CRH and BDNF function as downstream effectors in the MC4R signaling pathway (
Lu et al., 2003;
Tsao et al., 2007;
Xu et al., 2003). We found decreased expression of
Crh in the PVN of the
Mecp2 CKO mice. This is interesting because MC4R agonists increase the expression of
Crh in the PVN (
Lu et al., 2003), whereas
Mc4r −/− mice have low levels of
Crh in the PVN (see discussion in (
Lu et al., 2003)), suggesting that the decreased
Crh observed in the
Mecp2 CKO mice may represent another marker of disrupted MC4R signaling.
We also found that
Bdnf expression was decreased strictly in the PVN of
Mecp2 CKO mice. Studies in neuronal cultures suggest that
Bdnf is a direct target of MeCP2, and that MeCP2 functions as a transcriptional repressor to inhibit
Bdnf transcription specifically from promoter III (
Chen et al., 2003;
Martinowich et al., 2003). These data conflict, however, with recent
in vivo evidence demonstrating that BDNF levels are low rather than high in
Mecp2 null mouse brain (
Chang et al., 2006). Our data showing that
Bdnf is decreased in neurons lacking MeCP2 is consistent with the
in vivo data. Because low levels of
Bdnf occur only in the cells where
Mecp2 has been deleted in the
Mecp2 CKO mice, it seems likely that the decreased expression is occurring as a primary result of MeCP2 deficiency. Given recent data showing that MeCP2 binds to the promoter region of many actively expressed genes (
Yasui et al., 2007), that MeCP2 can function as both an activator and a repressor of gene expression in the hypothalamus (
Chahrour et al., 2008), that
Bdnf is significantly down-regulated in
Mecp2 null mice, and that MeCP2 overexpression results in increased
BDNF III transcript levels in cultured rat neurons and in
MECP2 transgenic mice (
Chahrour et al., 2008;
Chang et al., 2006;
Klein et al., 2007), we propose that MeCP2 functions as an activator of
Bdnf transcription.
Several studies have documented the importance of BDNF in the VMH and DMH for feeding regulation (
Tsao et al., 2007;
Unger et al., 2007;
Xu et al., 2003).
Ay obese mice that have disrupted MC4R signaling have a 30–40% decrease in
Bdnf expression in the VMH but no changes were observed in the PVN, DMH or lateral hypothalamus (LH) (
Xu et al., 2003). Our data suggest a disruption in MC4R signaling, although we see decreased
Bdnf expression in the PVN, and not the VMH. This result is not surprising since we have only deleted
Mecp2 from the PVN, not the VMH, and we believe that the misregulation of
Bdnf is occurring as a direct result of the absence of MeCP2. Future studies should examine
Bdnf expression in the VMH and the PVN of
Mc4r −/− mice to determine whether decreased expression occurs in one or both nuclei. Data supporting the fact that BDNF is important specifically in the PVN has come from a recent study that demonstrated that BDNF administration into the PVN was sufficient to significantly decrease food intake and body weight in mice (
Wang et al., 2007). MC4Rs are densely expressed in the PVN and activation of these receptors leads to an acute release of BDNF in the hypothalamus which is necessary for MC4R-induced effects on appetite (
Nicholson et al., 2007). If MeCP2 is important for the activation of
Bdnf transcription, then the required release of BDNF in response to MC4R activation would likely be impaired, at least in the PVN of
Mecp2 CKO mice.
We have demonstrated that MeCP2 plays an important role in the hypothalamus, an area of the brain where neurons are constantly responding to a variety of physiological stimuli. Specifically, we have demonstrated that the loss of MeCP2 seems to disrupt the typical homeostatic responses to food intake and to novel environment and stress consistent with a role for MeCP2 in the modulation of neuronal responses to changing stimuli (
Chahrour and Zoghbi, 2007;
Chen et al., 2003;
Zhou et al., 2006). It is interesting that we found decreased expression of
Bdnf in the PVN of
Mecp2 CKO mice since conditional deletion of
Bdnf from post-mitotic neurons results in enhanced aggression, and obesity (
Koizumi et al., 2006;
Lyons et al., 1999;
Rios et al., 2001). Therefore, our data support a model where MeCP2 is required for the proper expression of
Bdnf in the PVN, and we propose that misregulation of
Bdnf expression may lead to disrupted social behavior in the form of aggression, and to hyperphagia and obesity owing to disrupted MC4R signaling.
Importantly, by using a conditional knockout strategy we were able to reproduce a subset of RTT or Mecp2 null phenotypes and to uncover novel functions of MeCP2. The many phenotypes that are seen in patients with RTT stem from MeCP2 dysfunction in neurons throughout the brain. Our study suggests that conditional deletion of Mecp2 in different cell populations or different regions of the brain will enable us to map the neuroanatomic origins of the complex behaviors and phenotypes seen in RTT and MECP2 disorders. Lastly, this study revealed that the more restrictive we are in choosing the neurons in which to delete Mecp2, the more we will learn about the function of MeCP2 in specific neurons and the neurobiological basis of certain behaviors.