Our findings demonstrate that JNK1 is critically involved in human and mouse liver cancers, while JNK2 appears to be dispensable. Elevated activity of total p-JNK was observed in 50% of characterized HCCs in this study. Epidemiological studies show that human HCC develops with HBV or HCV infection and liver steatosis and fibrosis (
1). All of these diseases are associated with chronic liver damage and inflammation, which activate stress-associated kinases, such as JNKs. Interestingly, retrospective analysis of the disease histories of the patients recruited in this study showed that JNK activities in HCC tissues are not correlated with these pathological conditions (data not shown), suggesting that there may be other stimuli responsible for enhanced JNK activity. In addition, JNK1 activities are specifically increased in these human HCC samples, implying that these stimuli may selectively activate JNK1. Although JNK1 and JNK2 are commonly regulated by upstream kinases and phosphatases, selective activation of JNK1 has been shown to be regulated in a TAK1-dependent manner by the X chromosome–linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP) (
33). Moreover, JNK1 is specifically activated in mouse osteoclast progenitors by RANKL (
34), which also activates TAK1 through the TAB2/TRAF6 pathway (
35). Therefore, we speculate that the RANKL/TAK1 pathway may deserve further investigation in human HCCs.
Our findings demonstrate that JNK1 is essential for proliferation of hepatocytes and liver cancer cells in vivo. While impaired hepatocyte proliferation is evident in
JNK1–/– mice, altered apoptosis of liver cancer cells was not observed in
JNK1–/–,
JNK2–/–, or D-JNKI1–treated mice. Interestingly, inflammation- or ROS-induced apoptosis of hepatocytes was reduced in
JNK1–/– mice and D-JNKI1–treated wild-type mice at early stages of liver carcinogenesis (refs.
4,
5, Figure C, and data not shown). It is therefore likely that the JNK1 pathway has a dual, stage-dependent function. JNK1 activation at late stages leads to excessive cell proliferation by repression of p21 and enhancement of c-Myc expression (Figure D). JNK1 probably exerts its oncogenic function on proliferation independent of c-Jun, since phosphorylation and protein levels of c-Jun were unchanged in
JNK1–/– liver tumors and c-Jun phosphorylation appears to be dispensable for liver carcinogenesis and regeneration (
2,
5,
24). On the other hand, JNK1 may enhance c-Jun–mediated cell death during liver tumor initiation (
4,
5). However, the function of c-Jun may be even more complex, since c-Jun can also mediate hepatocyte survival in TNF-α–dependent acute hepatitis (
36). Since activation of JNK is believed to be important in various chronic liver diseases, a careful characterization of the functions of JNK and its targets at specific disease stages along with a better understanding of JNK interaction with other stress-signaling pathways, such as p38 and NF-κB (
3,
5), will provide novel and important insights into the molecular links between inflammation and liver cancer (Figure D).
At the molecular level, our findings demonstrate that increased p21 expression is responsible for attenuated proliferation of
JNK1–/– cells (Figure D). Genetic inactivation of p21 in
JNK1–/– mice completely rescued impaired proliferation, indicating an important role for p21 in JNK1-dependent liver carcinogenesis. A recent study also showed that JNK inhibitor SP600125 treatment upregulated p21 levels and increased CD95-mediated G
2/M cell-cycle arrest in cultured hepatoma cells (
37). The function of p21 in suppressing liver cell proliferation has been previously shown using transgenic mice overexpressing p21 (
26). Moreover, increased p21 levels were found to cause impaired hepatocyte proliferation in mice lacking c-Jun during liver regeneration (
27). Increased p21 protein levels negatively regulate cyclin D1 expression in liver cell proliferation following partial hepatectomy (
26,
27). Reduced cyclin D1 expression was also found in
JNK1–/– liver tumors (ref.
5 and data not shown) and was proposed to be responsible for decreased cancer cell proliferation (
5). Interestingly, cyclin D1 levels were completely restored in
JNK1–/–p21–/– liver cancers, as measured by Western blot (data not shown), suggesting that cyclin D1 may be one of the mediators in controlling proliferation of
JNK1–/– cancer cells (Figure D).
Both mRNA and protein levels of p21 are upregulated in
JNK1–/– liver cancer cells. Intriguingly, JNK was shown to stabilize p21 protein through phosphorylation or deubiquitination (
38,
39). We speculate that increased p21 might be regulated at the transcriptional level. It has been well documented that p21 transcription is repressed by c-Myc in normal and cancer cells (
29–
31). Our results revealed that both c-Myc levels and binding of c-Myc protein to the p21 promoter are decreased in
JNK1–/– cells. Moreover, c-Myc knockdown increased p21 expression in human Huh7 HCC cells. Therefore, we propose that enhanced p21 expression is most likely caused by decreased c-Myc levels in both liver cancers and regenerating livers (Figure D). It is also worth noting that expression of p21 and c-Myc is unchanged in
JNK2–/– liver cancer cells, which suggests that the expression of p21 and c-Myc is specifically regulated by JNK1. We speculate that JNK1 may directly stabilize c-Myc protein levels by phosphorylation of serine 71, as shown in the previous study (
40). On the other hand, JNK1 may indirectly enhance the transcription of c-Myc mRNA through activating transcription factors of
STAT3,
NFATC1, or
AP-1 genes, such as ATF2 (
10,
41,
42).
What is the molecular explanation for the distinct functions of JNK1 and JNK2? Protein sequence analysis of JNK from different species showed that JNK2 is phylogenetically distant from JNK1 and JNK3 (Supplemental Figure 4A). Two subdomains of amino acid residues 218–230 and 363–380 differ significantly between JNK1 and JNK2 (Supplemental Figure 4B). Modeling the structures of JNK1 and JNK2 using a JNK3 crystal structure revealed that these 2 subdomains contain hydrophilic amino acid residues and are surface exposed, implying that these domains may serve specific functions, such as docking sites for substrates (Supplemental Figure 4C). Indeed, it has been shown that these 2 subdomains are responsible for distinctive features of JNK1 and JNK2, such as efficient binding of c-Jun and autophosphorylation (
43,
44). Therefore, it is possible that these subdomains might also be involved in the different binding affinities of JNK1 and JNK2 in regulating c-Myc expression.
Our results demonstrate the importance of JNK1 in human HCCs and the potential application of JNK targeting for HCC therapy. Recently, a new strategy using “cocktail” drugs targeting multiple kinases was proposed for cancer treatment (
45,
46). It is worth mentioning that abnormal activation of ERK is often observed in human HCC. It has also been shown that systemic administration of sorafenib, an inhibitor of the Raf/ERK pathway and tyrosine receptor kinases, significantly extended survival of HCC patients (
47,
48). In light of our findings, a combined inhibition of JNK and ERK activities may profoundly improve HCC therapies.