In this report, we present experimental evidence suggesting that
in Dictyostelium Rap1 positively regulates phagocytosis and
negatively regulates macropinocytosis. This study represents, to our
knowledge, the first demonstration of a Ras-like family member playing
an important role in regulating phagocytosis, although Rho family
members have been demonstrated to regulate this process, and Ras has
been demonstrated to regulate pinocytosis. The biochemical function of
Rap1 appeared limited to early internalization steps in phagocytosis
and pinocytosis, because the efflux of fluid phase and the transport,
processing, and targeting of lysosomal hydrolases were unaffected by
overexpression of wild-type and mutant forms of Rap1. Finally, PLC
activity appeared to play a critical role in phagocytosis in wild-type
Ax2 cells, and Rap1 apparently acted downstream of PLC in the
DAG-activated arm of the pathway.
Cell lines overexpressing WT Rap1 or constitutively activated Rap1
phagocytosed beads two to three times faster than control Ax2 on a per
protein basis, whereas cell lines overexpressing a dominant negative
form of Rap1 (Rap1 S17N) phagocytosed beads at one-half the rate of
Ax2. This result suggests that this GTPase regulates an important step
in the signal transduction pathway that regulates internalization of
particles that enter the phagosomal pathway. A similar result was
obtained when bacteria were used instead of latex beads, suggesting
this was a physiologically relevant observation. Because the
overexpression of the Rap1 proteins was conditional and modest, we
conclude the phenotypic changes observed are not the result of an
indirect and/or nonspecific effect of Rap1 expression on other
GTPase-regulated pathways. It is interesting that overexpression of
Rap1 WT was as effective as Rap1 G12T in stimulating phagocytosis,
suggesting Rap1 is normally rate limiting in regulating this process
and that the majority of the Rap1 wild-type protein is found in the GTP
bound state.
To our knowledge, this is the first report demonstrating a role for
Rap1 in regulating phagocytosis, although others have demonstrated that
Rap1 may play a role in regulating the oxidative burst in neutrophils
during internalization of bacteria (
Maly et al., 1994 
). The
proposed role for Rap1 in neutrophils is similar to that in
Dictyostelium, namely to initiate the association of
proteins that, in neutrophils, can regulate the oxidative burst or, in
Dictyostelium, perhaps the internalization of particles.
Little is known about the biochemical mechanism(s) that regulate
particle internalization in
Dictyostelium. We report here
that the addition of inhibitors of PI 3-kinases PKA, PKG, PKC, and PTK
had no significant negative effect on phagocytosis in wild-type Ax2
cultures; similar results have recently been published for some of
these agents (
Peracino et al., 1998 
). These negative results
were observed regardless of the preincubation times and despite using
concentrations of drugs orders of magnitude higher then their reported
IC
50 values. Furthermore, Western blot analysis
indicated that treatment of cells with tyrphostins 25 and 46 reduced
the level of actin tyrosine phosphorylation by >95%, suggesting this
drug was effective in inhibiting PTK activity. However, these data do
not address the possibility of drug-resistant enzymes, belonging to the
classes listed above, that may play a role in regulating phagocytosis.
In macrophages, PTKs play an important role in regulating phagocytosis.
Opsonized bacteria that bind to Fcγ receptors trigger tyrosine
phosphorylation of the cytoplasmic tail of the receptor protein that
results in the binding of proteins containing SH2 domains
(
Crowley et al., 1997 
), and this initiates a signaling
pathway resulting in changes in the actin cytoskeleton and the
internalization of particles. This pathway has not been demonstrated to
exist in
Dictyostelium (no PTK receptors have been
discovered), and our results using PTK inhibitors suggest that this
pathway would most likely play only a minor role in regulating
phagocytosis if it existed. It has also been demonstrated that the PTK
pathway involves the activation of PI 3-kinases that, in macrophages,
have been demonstrated to play a role in the final closure of membranes
to form the internalized phagosome (
Araki et al., 1996 
). The
results of biochemical and genetic studies suggest that the
Dictyostelium PI 3-kinases DdPIK1 and DdPIK2 regulate
macropinocytosis (Rupper and Cardelli, unpublished results) but do not
appear to play a major role in regulating phagocytosis (
Buczynski
et al., 1997b 
), further suggesting that the biochemical
mechanisms regulating phagocytosis in
Dictyostelium may be
distinct from those regulating phagocytosis in macrophages.
Instead, it appears that in
Dictyostelium and perhaps in
other cells, heterotrimeric G proteins may play an essential role in
regulating phagocytosis and phagosomal maturation. In support of this,
Dictyostelium G
β(−) cells internalize
particles at only 20–25% of the rate observed for control cells
(
Peracino et al., 1998 
), and G
β subunits have
been localized to the phagosomal membranes in mammalian cells
(
Desjardins et al., 1994 
), where they may regulate
phagosome-lysosome fusion in mammalian cells (
Beron et al.,
1995 
). It has also been recently demonstrated that in a variety of
cells the G
βγ subunits, in addition to the
G
α subunits, can initiate signaling pathways by binding
to specific enzymes such as PLC (
Yan and Gautam, 1997 
) and regulating
their activity (
Zhang et al., 1996 
). Interestingly, the PLC
inhibitor U73122 repressed phagocytosis in
Dictyostelium by
>90%, whereas the chemically related but inactive analogue U73322 was
ineffective, demonstrating the specificity of action of U73122.
Additional experiments reported here support a role for PLC activity in
regulating phagocytosis in
Dictyostelium. In mammalian
cells, PLC activity results in the generation of DAG and increases in
cytosolic Ca
2+ via IP
3 action on internal
stores. Not surprisingly then, phagocytosis was also negatively
affected by the addition of calphostin C, which competes with DAG for
DAG-binding protein domains, and other drugs that altered intracellular
calcium levels. Calphostin C is a PKC inhibitor, but other specific PKC
inhibitors that interact with the active site of the enzyme did not
affect phagocytosis, suggesting that a non-PKC DAG-binding protein was
involved. While this manuscript was under review, the Bozzaro group
reported in agreement with our results that Ca
2+ and PLC
were involved in regulating phagocytosis (
Peracino et al.,
1998 
).
Phagocytosis in Rap1 G12T(+) cells, but not Rap1 WT(+) cells, was
insensitive to the presence of calphostin C, suggesting that the
calphostin C target acts upstream of Rap1 to regulate phagocytosis. The
molecular nature of this target remains to be defined, but it has
already been demonstrated that some GTPase guanine exchange
factors contain DAG-binding domains (
Cerione and Zheng, 1996 
).
This would be consistent with the calphostin C target being a Rap1 GEF
that would not be required in cells overexpressing the constitutively
active Rap1 G12T protein. We also propose that, in addition to the DAG
pathway, the Ca
2+-mediated pathway, perhaps acting in
parallel with Rap1, positively regulates phagocytosis. Interestingly,
it has recently been reported that Ca
2+ plays a role in
regulating Rap1 activity in human platelets (
Franke et al.,
1997 
). The source for the increase in cytoplasmic Ca
2+
(extracellular or intracellular stores) remains to be determined,
although the proposed mechanism of action of calmidazolium,
demonstrated here to stimulate phagocytosis, involves the induced
release of Ca
2+ from internal stores, which triggers the
influx of extracellular Ca
2+ (
Schlatterer and Schaloske,
1996 
).
Members of the Rho family of GTPases, including Cdc42, Rac, and Rho,
have been implicated in regulating phagocytosis in mammalian cells
(
Adam et al., 1996 
;
Cox et al., 1997 
;
Hackam
et al., 1997 
). We have also recently observed that a novel
Dictyostelium Rho protein, RacC, positively regulates
phagocytosis (
Seastone et al., 1998 
) and we speculate that
Rap1 could act as an upstream activator of RacC and perhaps other small
G proteins to regulate phagocytosis. G protein–coupled signal cascades
have also been proposed to function in fibroblasts and macrophages to
regulate actin cytoskeletal and gene expression changes. Figure
represents one speculative and testable
model to account for our observations.
Compared with control cells, the rates of pinocytosis were 40% lower
for Rap1 WT(+) and Rap1 G12T(+) cells, and most of this decrease
appeared to be accounted for by a major inhibition of macropinocytosis.
The decrease in macropinocytosis is intriguing because Rap1 WT(+) and
Rap1 G12T(+) cells, when attached to cell surfaces, display prominent
membrane ruffles (
Rebstein et al., 1997 
), formations that,
in other systems, have been suggested to be important in stimulating
macropinocytosis (
Araki et al., 1996 
). However, it has been
recently reported that Ras expression stimulates pinocytosis
independent of its effect on the formation of lamellipodia (
Li et
al., 1997 
), suggesting that prominent changes in the morphology of
the plasma membrane do not necessarily indicate an involvement in
internalization processes such as macropinocytosis.
The data presented here also support the hypothesis that the processes
of macropinocytosis and phagocytosis, although related in terms of
shared components such as actin, may use different proteins that
independently regulate each process. Additional published evidence
supports this hypothesis. For instance, genetic and biochemical
approaches have indicated that the proteins DdPIK1 and DdPIK2, related
to PI 3-kinases in amino acid sequence, are required for
macropinocytosis but are not involved in regulating phagocytosis
(
Buczynski et al., 1997b 
). In addition, we have recently
found that overexpression of RacC, a novel Rho-like GTPase, stimulates
phagocytosis and decreases macropinocytosis (
Seastone et
al., 1998 
). Finally, the Gβ subunit of the heterotrimeric G
protein regulates phagocytosis (
Peracino et al., 1998 
) and
not macropinocytosis (our unpublished observations).
The Rap1-mediated effects on internalization of fluid and particles
appear limited to early steps of the endosomal and phagosomal pathways,
because the efflux of fluid phase, and the synthesis, proteolytic
processing, and delivery of mature lysosomal hydrolases to lysosomes
were not altered in any of the mutant cell lines we examined. This
supports our hypothesis that Rap1 functions are specific and therefore
limited in scope. Consistent with the localization of Rap1 to the
plasma membrane, these data suggest that the effects exerted by Rap1
are limited to the internalization arm of the phagosomal pathway.
In summary, our results support an important role for the small
Mr GTPase Rap1 and both arms of the PLC pathway (DAG and
IP3) in regulating phagocytosis in
Dictyostelium. The goal of future investigations will be to
provide an insight into the biochemical mechanisms that coordinate
changes in PLC activity and Rap1 function with actin cytoskeleton
changes and activation of other effector proteins (including possibly
other G proteins) to regulate formation of the phagocytic cup.