|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Throughout most of their lives, women are at greater risk for depression than men. Hormones and neurotransmitters share common pathways and receptor sites in areas of the brain linked to mood, particularly through the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis. It has been hypothesized that women presenting with episodes of depression associated with reproductive events (i.e., premenstrual, postpartum, menopausal transition) may be particularly prone to experiencing depression, in part because of a heightened sensitivity to intense hormonal fluctuations. The menopausal transition, for example, appears to represent a window during which some women might be more vulnerable to the development of first onset or recurrent depressive symptoms and major depressive episodes. In this review, we examine the association between hormone changes and increased risk of developing depression. Some of the underlying mechanisms that may contribute to such an increased risk are discussed critically, with a special emphasis on the events occurring during the menopausal transition. Last, we explore some of the clinical and therapeutic implications of hormone-modulated depression in women.
Durant la majeure partie de leur vie, les femmes sont plus vulnérables à la dépression que les hommes. Les hormones et les neurotransmetteurs ont des voies et des récepteurs communs dans des régions du cerveau reliées à l'humeur, en particulier l'axe hypothalamus-hypophyse-gonades. On a posé en hypothèse que les femmes qui vivent des épisodes de dépression associés à des événements génésiques (c.-à-d. prémenstruels, postnataux, transition vers la ménopause) peuvent être particulièrement vulnérables à la dépression, en partie parce qu'elles sont plus sensibles aux fluctuations hormonales intenses. La transition vers la ménopause, p. ex., semble représenter une période pendant laquelle des femmes peuvent être plus vulnérables à l'apparition de symptômes dépressifs nouveaux ou répétitifs et à des épisodes dépressifs majeurs. Dans cette synthèse, nous analysons le lien entre les changements hormonaux et le risque accru d'apparition de la dépression. Nous analysons d'un œil critique certains des mécanismes sous-jacents qui peuvent contribuer à l'augmentation de ce risque et nous accordons une attention spéciale aux événements qui se produisent pendant la transition vers la ménopause. Enfin, nous explorons certaines des répercussions cliniques et thérapeutiques de la dépression d'origine hormonale chez les femmes.
Epidemiologic studies suggest that an increased risk for major depressive disorder (MDD) exists in women, compared with men1,2; such increased risk appears to become more evident after puberty and continues throughout the reproductive life cycle. The National Comorbidity Survey (NCS) found that, between the ages of 15 and 54 years, the lifetime prevalence of MDD is 12.7% for men and 21.3% for women.3 More recent NCS data corroborated these earlier findings, showing a nearly 2-fold greater lifetime risk of developing MDD in women (odds ratio [OR] 1.7, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.5–2.0).1 It has been postulated that this increased prevalence is somewhat associated with female-specific reproductive events such as perimenstrual changes, pregnancy, the postpartum period and menopause.4–6
The hypothesis that fluctuations in sex hormones marking female reproductive events could influence neurochemical pathways linked to depression is extensively supported by animal and human studies and existing clinical data (Table 1).61,62 The gonadal steroids estrogen and progesterone have been shown to affect brain regions known to be involved in the modulation of mood and behaviour. Receptor sites for these hormones have been identified in the prefrontal cortex, hippocampus, thalamus and brain stem.63,64
Other data support the association between changes in the hormone milieu and the occurrence of depressive symptoms, suggesting a potential window of vulnerability during times of hormone instability. In a community-based study, rapidly increasing levels of follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) were associated with an increased risk of experiencing depressive symptoms among menopausal women.65 The effects of hormonal interventions, however, indicate a potential window of opportunity to modulate the risk for mood symptoms by stabilizing the hormone environment. In a clinical trial of midlife (45–65 y) men and women with minor and major depression, significant improvements (p < 0.01 v. placebo) on the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale and Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) were observed in patients who received 6 weeks of dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) treatment (weeks 1–3, 90 mg/d; weeks 3–6, 450 mg/d).66 The antidepressant effect associated with DHEA treatment was not the result of ameliorating a deficiency of DHEA because no correlation between DHEA levels and therapeutic response was observed.66
Hormonal changes may also play a role in the development of somatic symptoms and may contribute to the exacerbation of medical disorders. For example, the occurrence of vasomotor symptoms (e.g., hot flashes and night sweats) during the menopausal transition and early postmenopausal years is thought to be directly associated with the hormonal fluctuations that occur during this period. These hormonal changes not only adversely affect the hypothalamic thermoregulatory centre67,68 but also contribute to dysregulation of the serotonergic and noradrenergic systems involved in mood and behaviour.5,69 Studies of premenstrual asthma70 and perimenstrual migraines71 also suggest that progesterone-and estrogen-driven modulation, respectively, play a role in the occurrence of other clinical conditions.
The hypothesis that mood changes are related to a heightened vulnerability to hormonal fluctuations experienced during reproductive life events does not, however, preclude the role of psychosocial stressors. In fact, several psychosocial factors have been associated with mood changes during puberty (e.g., sexual maturity, increased social pressures and obligations),6 premenstrual dysphoria (e.g., past trauma, lower education)72,73 and childbirth (e.g., lower income, stressful life events, medical complications).74,75 Similarly, the menopausal transition and postmenopausal years may be accompanied by health problems, inadequate social support, marital/sexual issues and other stressful events (e.g., divorce, death of a spouse, children leaving home) that could increase the risk for depression.76
In this review, we mainly focus on the available evidence linking female reproductive life events and the occurrence of depressive symptoms and disorders. A special emphasis is given to the events occurring during the menopausal transition. Last, we review some common clinical scenarios that could eventually help physicians to improve their ability both to identify patients at risk for developing mood disturbances during reproductive events and to tailor their treatment strategies for these conditions.
Different hypotheses involving the ovarian steroid hormones have been postulated to explain the occurrence of severe premenstrual symptoms. Hormone fluctuations are particularly intense in the late luteal phase of the menstrual cycle and early days of menses.5,77 Although differences in the concentrations of the ovarian steroids may underlie the occurrence of mood symptoms in this disorder, the evidence that support this hypothesis remains limited.
Within the patient population that frequently reports physical and psychological complaints during the premenstrual period, a subgroup appears to be particularly affected by dysphoric symptoms of mood lability, depressed mood, increased irritability and tension. These symptoms characterize the core of premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD).78 These symptoms generally begin to occur during the late luteal phase of the menstrual cycle (i.e., the last 7–10 d) and continue until the first few days of the subsequent follicular phase. Although restricted to a short period of time, symptoms of PMDD adversely affect psychosocial functioning and quality of life.78
PMDD occurs during periods of progesterone and estrogen instability.43 More recently, some investigators examined the concentration of ovarian steroid hormones across the menstrual cycle in women with and without PMDD, using a cross-sectional and prospective experimental design.
Across the menstrual cycle, the overall percentage of free estradiol was significantly lower, while the percentage of sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG) was significantly greater in the PMDD group when compared with control subjects. Moreover, during the luteal phase, free estradiol was significantly lower in the PMDD group when compared with control subjects. The authors speculate that high concentrations of SHBG in subjects with PMDD could limit the bioavailability of estradiol and ultimately affect mood in these individuals.79
The use of hormonal interventions for the treatment of PMDD seems intuitive; however, data supporting the efficacy of hormone-based treatments have been inconsistent,80–82 and only recently have a few controlled clinical trials demonstrated that improvements in hormonal stability (e.g., with the use of continuous oral contraceptives) could prevent or alleviate the occurrence and severity of premenstrual symptoms.83–85 Contrary to the scarce data on hormone-based interventions for PMDD, abundant evidence does support the role of changes in serotonin-mediated systems in the occurrence of premenstrual syndrome (PMS)86,87 and PMDD.88 Moreover, serotonergic antidepressants have been shown to effectively treat PMDD.89–91
Community-based studies indicate a 3%–9% prevalence of PMDD in the general population.92,93 A study of 1488 women who were prospectively followed for 48 months found a 12-month prevalence of 5.8% and a cumulative lifetime incidence of 7.4%. This same study found that women with PMDD were likely to develop psychiatric comorbidities. Rates of comorbid anxiety, affective and somatoform disorders were 47%, 30% and 28%, respectively. Only 27% of participants with PMDD had no other psychiatric diagnosis.94 In a survey of 206 women seeking treatment for PMS, 39% screened positively for a psychiatric disorder. Dysthymia and depression were most commonly comorbid with PMDD.95 Thus a most probable clinical scenario is the occurrence of premenstrual exacerbation of an underlying (sometimes undiagnosed) mood or anxiety disorder. Its recognition is a fundamental step toward the formulation of a more accurate diagnosis and effective treatment strategies.96
Prior psychiatric disorders, especially anxiety disorders, have been found to be significant risk factors for PMDD.73 In addition, a history of depression72 and posttraumatic stress disorder,94 smoking72 and nicotine dependence94 and lower educational status were also more common in patients with PMDD.72
Estrogen and progesterone levels steadily increase throughout pregnancy until just before birth, and serotonergic activity follows a corresponding pattern. Results from animal models suggest that a lower baseline level of serotonergic activity may lead to a greater risk for developing depressive symptoms during times when these neuroendocrine networks are challenged.97
It was once believed that for most women pregnancy could provide protection against psychiatric disorders. Unfortunately, accumulating evidence has demonstrated the contrary. In fact, for some women, pregnancy can be a time of elevated risk for psychiatric morbidity, particularly depressive and anxiety disorders.98,99
In a wide-ranging review of the published literature, rates of depression during the first, second and third trimesters were found to be 7.4%, 12.8% and 12.0%, respectively, suggesting a substantial risk for pregnant women, especially in the second and third trimesters.98 Notably, a recent naturalistic study conducted in patients with a history of recurrent depression who were followed throughout pregnancy found that 51% of the women who experienced a return of their MDD did so during the first trimester. The overall rate of relapse for this population was 43%.99
Women who experience a major depressive episode during pregnancy are more likely to be younger, in a lower socioeconomic stratum,74,98 not married74 and to have less education than women who do not experience such an episode.74 Cohen and colleagues99 conducted a naturalistic study in pregnant women who had been euthymic since at least 3 months before their last menstrual period but who had a history of MDD and were currently receiving or had recently received antidepressant treatment. When followed throughout pregnancy, women who discontinued their antidepressant treatment were 5 times more likely to experience a depressive relapse than those who maintained treatment (hazard ratio 5.0, 95% CI 2.8–9.1).
Clinicians and patients frequently raise concerns regarding the putative teratogenic risks of antidepressant use during pregnancy. Other concerns include the risk of the newborn developing withdrawal symptoms attributed to prenatal exposure to antidepressants and the relative increased risk for persistent pulmonary hypertension in the neonate.100,101 Conversely, evidence suggests that untreated depression has negative consequences for both mother and child. Depression in late pregnancy has been associated with poorer obstetric and neonatal outcomes, including increased risk for cesarean sections and instrumental vaginal deliveries, growth retardation and premature delivery.102,103 The impact of untreated depression during pregnancy is not limited to immediate adverse outcomes. A prospective study of depressed and nondepressed mother–child pairs found that a mother's depression during pregnancy can adversely affect a child's development of language skills and overall cognitive development. This negative impact was not associated with antidepressant use.104
Overall, most physicians and patients remain extremely reluctant to use antidepressants during pregnancy. Such reluctance could be explained, at least in part, by the existing confusion and complexity of evaluating absolute and relative risks and by the difficulty in balancing these risks for both the infant and the mother.105 As a general rule, a risk–benefit consideration must be made concerning pharmacologic treatments during pregnancy (for more details, see106–108). The severity of maternal depressive symptoms is a key factor in the decision-making process.
The postpartum period is a time of abrupt decreases in the amounts of circulating estrogen and progesterone. The relative contribution of these hormonal changes to the occurrence of depressive episodes during the postpartum period is a subject of controversy. For example, there have been some attempts to link the vulnerability of specific subgroups (e.g., patients with a diagnosis of bipolar disorder) to susceptibility genes that could predispose women to puerperal psychosis.109 Nonetheless, clinical experiments support the hypothesis that the abrupt changes in the hormonal milieu associated with the immediate postpartum period may exert a key role in the heightened risk for depression during this period.62 Bloch and colleagues62 induced a hypogonadal state in women with and without a history of postpartum depression. First, they used the gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist leuprolide acetate followed by 8 weeks of estrogen and progesterone treatment. At the end of this 8-week add-back period, both hormones were withdrawn in a double-blind manner. Sixty-three percent of the women with a history of postpartum depression and none from the comparison group developed significant depressive symptoms, suggesting that hormonal changes associated with the postpartum period may trigger a depressive episode in at-risk women. A potential window of opportunity for hormonal interventions in postpartum depression was further explored in studies demonstrating the efficacy of estrogen-based treatments for severe postpartum depression.31,110
A longitudinal study of 1558 pregnant women conducted in Sweden found a prevalence of 13% to 18% for postpartum depressive symptoms during the 6 months after delivery.111 Worldwide rates of postpartum major depression have been found to range from 4.4% to 9%.112–115 It appears that depressive symptoms before and concurrent with pregnancy are reliable predictors of postpartum mood disturbances. In a large study (n = 1622) of midpregnancy and 6-month postpartum women, the postpartum women who experienced depressive symptoms before becoming pregnant (OR 3.82, 95% CI 2.31–6.31) and during pregnancy (OR 6.78, 95% CI 4.07–11.31) had an increased risk for postpartum depressive symptoms.114 These results are supported by a longitudinal study that followed pregnant women until they were 8 months postpartum. The results showed a significant association between antenatal anxiety symptoms and postpartum depressive episodes, even after controlling for prior depressive episodes (OR 3.22, 95% CI 2.28–4.55; p < 0.001).116 Additionally, early postpartum depressive symptoms, a history of PMDD and depression related to the use of oral contraceptives have been identified as risk factors for postpartum depressive symptoms and episodes.115,117
The onset of the perimenopause or the menopausal transition is marked by the end of menstrual cycle regularity and is associated with decreases in the production of ovarian inhibiting hormones, which leads to increases in FSH and estrogen and increased activity of the hypothalamus and pituitary.63,118,119 Initially, menstrual cycles become slightly irregular in their length and/or flow. As women continue to advance toward the late perimenopausal period, menstrual cycles become increasingly irregular (i.e., occurrence of 2 or more skipped menstrual periods with gaps of more than 60 days between menstrual periods).
From a hormonal perspective, in the perimenopausal years slightly elevated but highly fluctuating FSH levels may be observed during the early follicular phase of the menstrual cycle. These levels gradually become consistently elevated into the late perimenopause and postmenopausal years, while estrogen and progesterone levels decrease and luteinizing hormone levels increase as the woman approaches menopause.119
Recent studies have examined the patterns of change in FSH and estradiol levels in different subpopulations across the menopausal transition and early postmenopausal years. Data from the Study of Women's Health Across the Nation revealed that serum concentrations of estradiol and FSH may vary by race or ethnicity. For example, Chinese and Japanese women had consistently lower (20%) estradiol concentrations when compared with women of European ethnicity, with no comparable differences seen in serum FSH concentrations. This finding suggests either a difference in the feedback regulation of the pituitary or an ethnospecific difference in pituitary sensitivity to gonadal-negative feedback.120 The same investigators revealed that FSH measures may be a better independent predictor of vasomotor symptom prevalence than serum estradiol levels: higher FSH concentrations were associated with a greater risk of reporting more frequent symptoms even among regularly cycling women, whereas estradiol concentrations did not show an independent effect. They therefore proposed that an annual serum FSH concentration of 40 IU/L could be incorporated, in conjunction with bleeding markers, into the Stages of Reproductive Aging Workshop (STRAW) paradigm for markers of the late menopausal transition.121
Figure 1 illustrates the stages of menopause based on a consensus statement developed by 27 invited professionals to the STRAW. The final menstrual period (FMP) serves as the anchor point of this staging system, which describes the components of each menopausal phase (i.e., menstrual cycle regularity, endocrine and biochemical changes, fertility, other organ system changes and uterine/ovarian anatomy).119
Clinically, symptoms such as breast tenderness, insomnia, migraines, vasomotor symptoms and dysphoria may be reported with the onset of the perimenopause. In the late perimenopausal years, women also experience significant increases in the intensity of vasomotor symptoms as estrogen levels fluctuate widely and unpredictably and menstrual cycles become increasingly irregular.119,122 Recent evidence also suggests an increased risk for developing depressive symptoms during this period even in the absence of a history of depression.76,99,123 Thus, for some women, the perimenopause and early postmenopausal years may constitute a window of vulnerability wherein the occurrence of challenging physical and emotional discomforts could result in significantly impaired functioning and poorer quality of life.124,125
Menopause begins following the FMP and is confirmed only after 12 months of amenorrhea. The postmenopausal period is divided into an early (i.e., 5 years since the FMP) and late phase and is marked by significant decreases in estrogen production, an overall state of hypogonadism, stability in the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis and elevated FSH levels.119 The decreased circulating androgen levels associated with menopause have been linked to loss of libido, fatigue and an increase in depressive symptoms.126,127 Some data suggest that the significant hormone changes and the related physical and emotional symptoms associated with menopause may differ depending on whether a woman experiences menopause naturally or through surgical means (i.e., resulting from bilateral oophorectomy).126,128 In a cross-sectional study of postmenopausal women, those experiencing menopause naturally were found to have fewer hot flashes than those with surgically induced menopausal status.129
Notably, most women have a positive attitude toward approaching menopause and proceed through the menopausal transition without experiencing significant depressive symptoms or a major depressive episode.130 However, recent epidemiologic studies suggest an increased risk for the development of psychiatric morbidity even among those who never experienced depression during the premenopausal years. In an 8-year longitudinal study of women with no history of depression (n = 224), Freeman and colleagues123 found that 50% experienced an increase in depressive symptoms (CES-D ≥ 16) during the perimenopausal transition and 26% met formal MDD diagnostic criteria as assessed with the Primary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders measure. Perimenopausal women were more than 4 times more likely (OR 4.29, 95% CI 2.39–7.72) to experience clinically significant depressive symptoms and 2.5 times more likely (OR 2.50, 95% CI 1.25–5.02) to be diagnosed with MDD than when they were premenopausal.123 Another community-based, prospective study, the Harvard Study of Moods and Cycles, also identified a 2-fold greater risk of developing significant depressive symptoms during the perimenopause in women who had never reported prior depression. Interestingly, this increased risk remained significant after adjusting for common confounding factors (e.g., cigarette smoking, socioeconomic status).72 Moreover, the risk for a new onset of depression was accentuated by the presence of significant vasomotor symptoms.99 In subjects with a lifetime history of depression, the risk of developing a depressive episode during the late perimenopause is 14 times greater than during the 31-year period preceding perimenopause, compared with a 3-fold increase in risk associated with the early perimenopause.131
As in the other reproductive life events discussed, a history of previous depressive symptoms or episodes is a significant risk factor for developing menopausal depression.65,132 Freeman and colleagues65 reported a nearly 5-fold increase in the risk of experiencing a major depressive episode during the menopausal transition in women with a history of depression. A similar increased risk was observed in data derived from the Moods and Cycles Study (Dr. Bernard Harlow, University of Minnesota, Division of Epidemiology, personal communication, December 2006). Additional risk factors included a history of severe PMS or PMDD,133 poor sleep patterns65 and hot flashes.134
Accumulating evidence suggests a link between the presence of vasomotor symptoms and the occurrence of menopause-related depression. For example, in a study of 476 women aged 40 to 60 seeking primary care treatment, perimenopausal women with depression were significantly more likely to report experiencing vasomotor symptoms than those who were perimenopausal and not suffering from depression. Perimenopausal women with vasomotor symptoms were more than 4 times more likely to meet criteria for depression (CES-D ≥ 25) than those who did not have vasomotor symptoms (4.39 95% CI 1.40–13.83).135 No significant increase in the risk for depression was noted for older premenopausal and postmenopausal women who were also experiencing hot flashes, reinforcing the concept that the perimenopausal period may represent a time of unique vulnerability.135
Androgen levels may also play some role in menopause-related depression. Barret-Connor and colleagues59 found a significant relation between decreased dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEAS) levels and depressed mood assessed with the Beck Depression Inventory. Another group of investigators found a weak inverse relation between depressive symptoms (according to CES-D scores) and DHEAS levels in women aged 42–52 years. Even after controlling for factors such as waist circumference, ethnicity and age, levels of testosterone and free androgen index levels remained inversely associated with depressed mood.52
The occurrence of a similar symptom profile (e.g., increased irritability, disturbed sleep, depressed mood, cognitive dysfunction) associated with the various reproductive life events already discussed has led some to speculate that a continuum of reproductive depressive disorders exists. It has been postulated, for instance, that the hypoestrogenism associated with each of these phases in a woman's life could lead to an increased risk for depression.4 In addition, some suggest the hypothesis of a kindling effect; women who experience a depressive episode during one reproductive phase (e.g., during the premenstrual period) could be at a greater risk for developing future depressive episodes when facing hormonally challenging situations (e.g., during the postpartum period).117,136 A preliminary study of 72 women with depression found significant correlations between premenstrual (r = 0.41; p = 0.04) and postpartum (r = 0.64; p = 0.001) depression ratings and the presence of perimenopausal depression.137 Other studies also point to the higher occurrence of lifetime depressive events related to the reproductive cycle.138 Nonetheless, larger prospective studies confirming these associations are lacking.
The major caveat of the hypoestrogenic state theory is that the hormonal milieu differs with each reproductive event, so the relation between depressed mood and reproductive hormones may not be direct. The occurrence of mood disturbances during separate reproductive events and the wide variations in hormone levels observed during such events suggest that absolute hormone levels do not cause reproductive-related mood disorders. Rather, it is the dramatic — sometimes chaotic — hormone fluctuations that contribute to the increased risk for depression. As discussed above, premenstrual depressive symptoms occur during the luteal phase and continue through the first few days of the follicular phase, when dramatic fluctuations of progesterone and estrogen levels are most prevalent.5,77 Similarly, estrogen levels in perimenopausal women fluctuate widely as menstrual cycles become increasingly erratic.119 Conversely, the late postmenopausal years, clearly marked by a constant hypoestrogenic state, are not generally characterized by an increase in depressive episodes (either first onset or reemergent).
The complexity of the interactions between hormone changes and mood is corroborated by the different responses to hormonal fluctuations observed in women going through reproductive events and by different therapeutic responses obtained after the administration of exogenous hormones. For example, the antidepressant properties of estrogen therapy appear to vary according to the population treated. Most clinical trials have shown the positive effects of estrogen treatment for depression in perimenopausal but not postmenopausal women.34,35,139 Moreover, the formulation and pathways used (e.g., transdermal estradiol as opposed to oral conjugated estrogen) may also affect estrogen's antidepressant effect, with more robust response observed with the use of transdermal estradiol34,36 and limited antidepressant response with oral preparations.140
The response to antidepressants for the management of reproductive-related mood symptoms has also been a point of some controversy. Serotonergic antidepressants are quite efficacious for the treatment of PMDD.141–143 However, the consistent efficacy of these agents in treating depression in women has been questioned, particularly with regard to women who have entered the postmenopausal years.144–146
From the therapeutic point of view, it is plausible that the use of hormonal interventions could have an impact on the presence and severity of mood symptoms when used either alone or in combination with antidepressants. Bloch and colleagues117 found a significant association between subjects' mood symptoms while taking oral contraceptives and the experiencing of postpartum depressive symptoms and episodes (p = 0.007). In the Harvard Study of Moods and Cycles, women receiving hormone therapy to ease the symptoms associated with the perimenopause were less likely to experience a severe depressive episode, compared with those who entered the perimenopause without any hormonal intervention.134 Last, some but not all depression studies suggest that estrogen-based therapies may constitute a valid treatment strategy (either as monotherapy or an augmenting tool) for the improvement of depression during menopause or for premenstrual exacerbation of depression.34–36,140,147
When the treatment of mood disorders in women is being considered, assessment of reproductive history and inquiry about menstrual history or somatic symptoms are important to the decision-making process. Incorporating appropriate questions into psychiatric assessments may improve the ability to identify women vulnerable to experiencing depressive episodes during reproductive events and to effectively manage depression in these women. For example, the decision to use long-term maintenance treatment could be affected by the recognition that a woman at midlife with a history of MDD who is currently in remission could be at an increased risk for recurrence when approaching menopause.
Given the complex overlap between menopause-related symptoms and some of the somatic and psychological complaints commonly seen in depression, the diagnostic process becomes more difficult and requires different strategies. The domino theory suggests that the sheer increase in the number of symptoms is responsible for more menopausal women meeting the criteria for MDD.148 However, depression may occur even in the absence of one or more of these symptoms. Use of more specific instruments or scales may help physicians make this delineation. For example, the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale149 has been successfully used to screen for and monitor the occurrence and severity of MDD during pregnancy and the postpartum period. Similarly, instruments such as the Greene Climacteric Scale,150 the Menopause-Specific Quality of Life Questionnaire151 and the Utian Menopause Quality of Life Score152 could be used to assess and monitor menopause-related physical and psychological symptoms, as well as to assess the impact of these symptoms on functioning and overall well-being. Clinical assessments of menopausal women presenting with symptoms of depression should determine the presence of comorbidities, explore the course of illness (i.e., chronic or recurrent) and identify triggers (i.e., reproductive events, life events, seasonal patterns) and psychosocial contributors to depression.153 Box 1 highlights some of the most common clinical scenarios seen when depression is diagnosed during the menopausal transition and also includes practical guidelines for addressing them.
Despite the mounting evidence of an association between reproductive life events and the development of depressive episodes, further research is needed to more clearly identify the driving factors of this association. A better understanding of both systemic and brain-specific biological changes experienced during different reproductive phases may provide the keys to developing better treatment options for these cases and effectively reducing the disease burden and risk for recurrence. Future research should also assess the efficacy and safety of hormonal and nonhormonal strategies to modulate the occurrence of these disturbances or to alleviate their symptoms. With regard to managing menopause-related symptoms, a particular emphasis has been put on identifying safer and more effective treatments such as selective estrogen receptor modulators and serotonergic, noradrenergic and γ-aminobutyric acid–ergic psychoactive agents. In addition, accurate and effective screening strategies and updated treatment guidelines are necessary to provide physicians and patients with the necessary tools to meet the needs of this population.
The authors thank Dennis Stancavish, MA, and Jennifer Hutcheson for their writing and editing assistance on this manuscript.
Contributors: Drs. Soares and Zitek conducted the literature review, wrote and reviewed the article and gave final approval for its publication.
Competing interests: Dr. Soares is a recipient of grant/research support from Eli Lilly, AstraZeneca, NARSAD and Physicians Services Incorporated. He is also a research consultant for GlaxoSmithKline, Wyeth, Forest, Lundbeck, Sepracor Inc. and Neurocrine. Dr. Soares is a part of the Speakers' Bureau of GlaxoSmithKline, AstraZeneca, Wyeth, Forest, Berlex and Lundbeck. Dr. Soares did not receive any direct financial compensation for writing this manuscript. Dr. Zitek is an employee of Wyeth Research.
Correspondence to: Dr. C.N. Soares, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neurosciences, McMaster University, 301 James St. S, FB#638, Hamilton ON L8P 3B6; fax 905 521-6098; csoares/at/mcmaster.ca