Our laboratory has characterized two alkyl hydroperoxide reductases (AhpC1 and AhpC2D) that are expressed at different stages of bacterial growth and provide essential peroxidatic functions in
L. pneumophila. Loss of AhpC1 function results in increased expression of
ahpC2D, suggesting a compensatory response to cellular oxidative stress (
30). Using an ACDC assay, we identified OxyR
Lp as a regulatory factor controlling expression of the
ahpC2D operon. OxyR
Lp bound to
ahpC2D promoter sequences but did not bind to the promoter regions of
ahpC1 or itself (autoregulation). Members of the OxyR family are well-characterized, redox-active transcriptional activators of genes associated with defense against oxidative stress. In contrast, none of the antioxidant defense genes (
sodB,
sodC,
katA,
katB, or
ahpC1 and
ahpC2D) of
L. pneumophila appear to be activated in response to oxidative stress (
4,
5,
30,
39,
43). Moreover, the expression of most of these genes, including
oxyRLp, is aligned with growth stage, increasing dramatically around mid-exponential phase and peaking in early stationary phase, consistent with the view that oxidative stress is more acute for stationary-phase bacteria (
4,
39). By demonstrating that OxyR
Lp repressed transcription from
ahpC2D, we have partly resolved the basis for the reciprocal gene expression noted between
ahpC1 and
ahpC2D. Studies are in progress to identify regulatory mechanisms associated with postexponential activation of
ahpC1 and
oxyR.
OxyR
Lp appears to be functionally different from other OxyR proteins that have been shown to function as redox-active repressors (
47,
48). Here we present several lines of evidence to suggest that OxyR
Lp may no longer function as a global regulator of antioxidant defenses: (i)
oxyRLp expression is growth stage dependent, (ii) OxyR
Lp function is apparently essential, (iii) DNA-binding properties of OxyR
Lp are not redox dependent, (iv) OxyR
Lp contains key amino acid substitutions that likely ablate disulfide-bond formation or conformational changes that are required for activation, and (v) H
2O
2 treatment did not increase
ahpC2-
gfp levels in
L. pneumophila or in an
E. coli oxyR mutant (GS077) expressing
oxyRLp. However, these findings do not exclude the possibility that OxyR
Lp retains some DNA sequence recognition for OxyR-regulated promoters of
E. coli, as indicated by complementation and EMSA studies. Our studies indicate that OxyR
Lp may be locked in an activated DNA-binding conformation (
29), independent of further activation by peroxide but sufficient to activate the antioxidant defense system of
E. coli.
In
E. coli, OxyR binds DNA as a dimer of dimers under both reducing and oxidizing conditions, yet only the latter promotes expression of its target genes (
47). Treatment of
E. coli OxyR with millimolar amounts of DTT was shown to promote the binding of OxyR to contact sites that blocked −35 sequences of OxyR-regulated promoters, whereas peroxide oxidation of OxyR led to a conformational change in the protein that contracted the DNA footprint and permitted strong induction of these promoters (
44,
46,
47). In the case of
L. pneumophila, treatment of OxyR
Lp with micromolar concentrations of H
2O
2 did not alter the footprint, which suggested either that OxyR
Lp was fully oxidized during protein purification or that DNA binding was independent of oxidation state. While millimolar concentrations of H
2O
2 indeed abolished DNA binding, the result is not considered physiologically relevant since biological activity was not recoverable by treatments with 200 mM DTT. In this regard, functional studies have shown that the redox-active thiols (C199 and C208) of OxyR
Ec spontaneously oxidize to form disulfide bonds (redox potential of −185 mV) during protein purification (
1,
50). In some organisms, such as
Deinococcus radiodurans, oxidation of a single (peroxidatic) cysteine residue of OxyR is sufficient to promote activation (
10). Thus, regardless of whether a single cysteine becomes oxidized or even a disulfide bond is formed, our studies suggest that the redox-sensing domain of OxyR
Lp no longer signals conformational changes that promote activation.
Members of the LysR family (which includes OxyR) use a ligand-binding conformational change mechanism to mediate DNA binding (
11). Mutation-based studies have identified key amino acids required for the function of OxyR. For example,
E. coli OxyR H125I and H218D mutations resulted in wild-type DNA binding but a loss of redox-mediated regulation (
11). These amino acid substitutions occur naturally in the OxyR
Lp proteins from all four strains of
L. pneumophila whose genomes have been sequenced (125 and 218) (Fig. ). While the two redox-active cysteine residues involved in OxyR activation (Cys199 and Cys208) are conserved in OxyR
Lp, there is substantial amino acid sequence divergence in the activation domain that might affect redox activity. For example, a key arginine at position 220 in OxyR
Ec (Fig. ) that is predicted to interact with catalytic cysteines and peroxide (
28) is changed to threonine in OxyR
Lp proteins. Interestingly, in the OxyR proteins of close relative
C. burnetii and in
Francisella tularensis, Arg220 is replaced by lysine, which might suggest a more traditional function in these organisms. Further comparisons revealed amino acid sequence variation within the helix-turn-helix region that might account for differences in the DNA-binding specificity noted between OxyR
Lp and OxyR
Ec in complementation experiments and EMSAs. We suggest that the loss of the redox-sensing function of OxyR
Lp has occurred naturally through specific amino acid substitutions that have been demonstrated through empirical studies to alter disulfide bond formation and conformational changes required for activation.
In contrast to other bacteria, such as F. tularensis, C. burnetii, and Streptomyces species, in which oxyR is located upstream and divergently expressed from the ahpC2D system, the oxyRLp gene is located elsewhere in the chromosome. It is conceivable that the present oxyRLp was acquired laterally, perhaps concomitantly with the deletion or loss of an ancestral upstream ortholog, perhaps a necessary event associated with the evolution of a dimorphic lifestyle.
It seems unlikely that the only function for OxyR
Lp is to repress
ahpC2D during the growth transition to stationary phase and into cyst morphogenesis. While downregulation of
ahpC2D is consistent with metabolic changes and a shift to the NADPH-thioredoxin AhpC1 system that occur during the transition to stationary phase,
ahpC2D deletion mutants are both viable and infectious (
30). Moreover, high-level
ahpC2D expression, noted with the
ahpC1 deletion mutant, also suggested that the postexponential presence of AhpC2D was not toxic. Thus, OxyR
Lp must provide other essential regulatory functions to
L. pneumophila, since this mutant could not be obtained by methods routinely used to generate mutants (
30). We used the pattern search option of the
L. pneumophila Paris and Lens genome website (
http://genolist.pasteur.fr/LegioList/) to screen for additional genes, using motif patterns deduced from comparisons with either the
E. coli or
L. pneumophila OxyR binding motif. While these motifs are relatively degenerate, binding sites were observed upstream of approximately 50 genes, including the
dps homolog, which has recently been found to prevent Fenton-mediated DNA damage by sequestering iron (
37). Others included promoters of genes encoding efflux pumps (that exclude redox-cycling compounds and organic solvents); metal ion transporters (which regulate rates of Fenton chemistry); components of the respiratory chain, such as cytochrome oxidases, DNA repair, or modification enzymes; known virulence factors, such as the zinc metalloproteinase (shown to inhibit the oxidative burst); and substrates of the Dot/Icm type IVB secretion system (SidG, SdhB, and SdeA). Finally, OxyR binding motifs were also found upstream of genes encoding numerous transcriptional regulators, like Fur, FleQ, FleN, and other members of the LysR family, suggesting that there could be cross talk with other regulatory pathways. Interestingly, unlike in
E. coli,
fur is an essential gene in
L. pneumophila (
24). Further studies will be required to dissect additional regulatory functions associated with essentiality.
Our studies predict the participation of additional regulatory elements in controlling the expression of
ahpC2D, since repression of
ahpC2D by OxyR
Lp does not fully explain the upregulation of
ahpC2D in an
ahpC1 mutant or the postexponential activation of
ahpC1 (
30). In
L. pneumophila, transition from exponential phase to stationary phase/cyst differentiation is controlled in part by postexponential regulators RpoS, LetA, and HimAB (
2,
13,
20,
22,
32,
33,
52). However, the
oxyRLp-
gfp gene expression studies of
rpoS,
letA, and
himAB mutants were indistinguishable from those of the wild type. While not directly examined, carbon storage regulator CsrA, an important repressor of stationary-phase genes during exponential phase (
13,
33), may not be involved in regulating
oxyRLp, since CsrA should have repressed postexponential expression of
oxyRLp in
letA and
rpoS mutants. Future studies will employ the ACDC strategy to capture putative regulatory factors associated with the control of
oxyRLp expression.
In summary, we have shown that OxyR
Lp represses
ahpC2D expression and that
oxyRLp is induced postexponentially. Our studies further establish that OxyR
Lp no longer functions as an oxidative response regulator in
L. pneumophila, which is consistent with previous observations that
L. pneumophila mounts no response to oxidative stress and that these bacteria are rather resistant to oxidative damage, even in phagocytic cells (
30). We propose that OxyR
Lp has been adapted from an oxidative stress response regulator to a growth stage-specific regulator of genes mediating the transition from vegetative to resilient cyst-like transmissible forms.