Our results suggest that a low level of plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D is associated with rectal cancer risk in both men and women but not colon cancer. A significant inverse association between 25-hydroxyvitamin D and colorectal cancer, especially of the distal colon and rectum has been reported (
Tangrea et al, 1997;
Feskanich et al, 2004;
Wactawski-Wende et al, 2006), whereas another prospective study showed no such association with colon cancer risk (
Braun et al, 1995).
Comparison of the ranges of 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels in the above studies is relevant. A Finnish cohort (
Tangrea et al, 1997) covered the lower and narrower range, that is 9.8 or less to more than 19.2

ng

ml
−1, as did the Women's Health Initiative Study, a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial among US women, from less than 12.4–23.4

ng

ml
−1 or more (
Wactawski-Wende et al, 2006). A Nurses' Health Study among US women (
Feskanich et al, 2004) covered a higher and wider range (14.9, the median for the lowest category to 35.3

ng

ml
−1, the median for the highest category). On the other hand, the small Washington County Study covered a higher and narrower range (less than 17.2–30.1

ng

ml
−1 or more) (
Braun et al, 1995).
Our study similarly showed no association between colon cancer and 25-hydroxyvitamin D in the higher and narrower range, that is, below 22.9–32.1

ng

ml
−1 or more in men and below 18.7–27.0

ng

ml
−1 or more in women. However, an effect of a low level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D was found for rectal cancer in our subjects. In short, populations covering the lower range of 25-hydroxyvitamin D may show a preventive effect against colorectal cancer even with a narrower variation of 25-hydroxyvitamin D. The higher range presumably shows the protective effect only if they have a sufficiently wide variation of 25-hydroxyvitamin D. Differences in our findings from the Washington County Study may be due to the different characteristics of the colon and rectum.
Differences between colon and rectum may derive from 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D receptor (Vitamin D receptor, VDR) expression. VDR also has some differences in genetic polymorphisms by ethnic group.
BsmI B and short poly A alleles, for example, are more prevalent in Caucasians than in Japanese (
Tokita et al, 1996;
Ingles et al, 1997), and may be protective against colorectal cancer (
Slatter et al, 2001). Japanese may be more vulnerable to rectal cancer due to the low prevalence of this protective VDR genotype.
The Women's Health Initiative study reported that calcium plus vitamin D supplementation did not decrease the subsequent risk of colorectal cancer over a follow-up of 7 years (
Wactawski-Wende et al, 2006). However, the supplementation might influence only the group with low plasma levels, colorectal cancer risk among the group with the lowest level of plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D being slightly, though not significantly, decreased.
It is not surprising that bioavailable vitamin D status did not correlate with dietary vitamin D intake.
Holick (2004) indicated that over 90% of the vitamin D requirement comes from casual exposure to sunlight. Of course, blood levels of 25-hydroxyvitamin D partly reflect dietary intake of vitamin D (
Nakamura et al, 2000,
2002), although our results did not show a positive correlation between dietary and plasma vitamin D levels, partly due to the low validity of the food frequency questionnaire. Spearman's correlation coefficients between dietary records and estimates from the food frequency questionnaire were 0.26 for men and 0.38 for women in Cohort I; 0.32 for men and 0.28 for women in Cohort II, assessed by volunteers from our cohorts (
Ishihara et al, 2006). In addition, skin pigmentation is one of the determinants of 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels. Oriental people show lower cutaneous synthesis of vitamin D than white people (
Matsuoka et al, 1991). In addition to sunlight, dietary intake, and skin pigmentation, season of blood sampling and subjects' body mass index may influence blood levels (
Giovannucci, 2005;
Giovannucci et al, 2006). Thus, 25-hydroxyvitamin D measurement is more appropriate way to assess entirely vitamin D status than dietary intake.
An active form of vitamin D, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, was not investigated in the present study, as its half-life in the circulation (less than 4

h) is shorter than that of 25-hydroxyvitamin D (approximately 2 weeks) and normal levels are maintained even with vitamin D deficiency and low 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels, making it unsuitable for studies of colorectal cancer risk (
Braun et al, 1995;
Tangrea et al, 1997;
Feskanich et al, 2004;
Holick, 2004).
Although blood samples were collected before cancer diagnosis, measurement errors may exist because only one blood sample for each subject was used to measure plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentrations, causing random misclassification to attenuate statistical associations. Long-term storage is recommended only at temperatures of less than −18°C (
Hunter, 1998) and our plasma storage (−80°C) satisfied this condition. Furthermore, this plasma biomarker has a seasonal variation, declining in winter and rising in summer, reflecting sunlight exposure (
Holick, 2004). In fact, our study controls' levels were slightly lower among blood samples drawn in winter (mean values from November to March; 26.3

ng

dl
−1 for men and 22.8

ng

dl
−1 for women) than those drawn at other times (mean values from April to October; 28.4

ng

dl
−1 for men and 23.5

ng

dl
−1 for women). To minimise bias, we matched date of blood collection between cases and controls (within 3 months), differing by less than 1 month among 63% of the case–control pairs, only by 1–2 months among 14% of them, and by 2–3 months among 17%. The proportion of case–control pairs where both were drawn at high-level seasons of plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D (April to October) was 72% of all pairs, so difference in timing of blood draw would minimally impact on risk estimates.
In conclusion, a low plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D level may be associated with a subsequent risk of rectal but not colon cancer.