Here, we show by mapping and complementation that the genetic alteration responsible for the lupus-modifying Lmb3 locus is most likely a function-impairing nonsense Q262X mutation of the Coro1a gene on distal chromosome 7. Furthermore, we document that this mutation is an autoimmunity suppressing allele that arose spontaneously in our B6-Faslpr/Scr colony. We further show that the Coro1aLmb3 mutation reduces humoral and cellular manifestations of lupus in Faslpr mice by significantly impairing the development, migration, survival, and activation of T cells, T-dependent immune responses, and germinal center formation. These findings define the critical role of Coronin 1A in normal immune responses and autoimmunity, and identify it as a potential therapeutic target.
Coronins are actin-associated cytoskeletal proteins present in prokaryotes to eukaryotes that share an actin-binding 7-bladed β propeller, a common C-terminal extension flanking the propeller domain, a unique region that differs among Coronin members, and, in the single β propeller Coronins, such as Coronin-1A, a heptad repeat coiled-coil domain necessary for homotrimerization (
Rybakin and Clemen, 2005;
Uetrecht and Bear, 2006). They act as inhibitors of F-actin by sequestering the nucleation-promoting Arp2/3 complex in its inactive open form (
Rodal et al., 2005) and by serving as a cofactor for cofilin/Aip1-mediated F-actin disassembly (
Brieher et al., 2006). As such, Coronins play a critical role in the assembly and turnover of actin during lamellipodia formation and cell migration (
Cai et al., 2007) and are implicated in vesicular trafficking, morphogenesis, cell division, and cell survival, although some functions are species-specific. Of the seven Coronin family members found in mammals, Coronin-1A alone is expressed primarily in hematopoietic cells and has been associated in neutrophils with the NADPH oxidase complex subunit p40
phox (
Grogan et al., 1997), in macrophages with phagocytosis and lamellipodia formation (
Ferrari et al., 1999;
Yan et al., 2005), and in T cells with high expression throughout ontogeny and with localization to actin-rich regions of the immune synapse (
Nal et al., 2004). Recent characterization of
Coro1a-deficient mice, however, revealed alterations limited essentially to T cells, with T lymphopenia from reduced migration and increased apoptosis, but normal T cell development and activation (
Foger et al., 2006). More recent characterization of macrophages from Coro1a
−/− mice showed no defects in phagocytosis, motility, or membrane ruffling (
Jayachandran et al., 2007).
Consistent with the
Coro1aLmb3 mutant encoding a nonfunctional product, several T cell alterations reported with
Coro1a deficiency (
Foger et al., 2006) were also observed in MRL.B6-
Lmb3 Faslpr mice. These include defective chemokine-mediated T cell migration, enhanced spontaneous apoptosis of naïve T cells, reduced numbers of peripheral T cells, and the accumulation of F-actin in cells. Also similar to the findings in
Coro1a−/− mice, we observed fewer SP thymocytes in
Coro1aLmb3 mice that was associated with increased apoptosis of SP, but not DP thymocytes. As both SP thymocytes and naïve peripheral
Coro1aLmb3 T cells exhibit increased spontaneous apoptosis, the same pathologic process likely affects both populations. In this regard, the apoptosis in Coronin-1A deficiency was previously suggested to be secondary to a decrease in mitochondrial membrane potential caused by the increase in F-actin levels (
Foger et al., 2006). Although how this occurs is not yet defined, it was postulated that the accumulated F-actin might either sequester factors that modulate mitochondrial voltage-dependent anion channels or else boost the delivery of proapoptotic molecules to the mitochondria (
Dustin, 2006;
Foger et al., 2006). Our finding of significant loss of mitochondrial membrane potential in
Coro1aLmb3 T cells is certainly consistent with these possibilities. By contrast, the finding that B cells, which do not display increased apoptosis, also have increased cellular F-actin, suggests that either other factors are involved or that there is an alternative mechanism. One such possibility is that the apparent spontaneous apoptosis might involve T cells that are already committed to die because of inadequate survival signals
in vivo from defective migration and/or reduced TCR-mediated signaling. Indeed, chemokine-mediated migration (
Schaerli and Moser, 2005) and engagement of TCR by self-peptide/MHC complexes (
Eck et al., 2006;
Surh et al., 2006) have been shown to be required for retaining a normal T cell homeostasis.
In our study,
Coro1aLmb3 T cells also displayed impaired activation as shown
ex vivo by thymidine incorporation, cell division analysis, and IL-2 production, as well as
in vivo by the degree of lymphopenia-induced homeostatic proliferation. Furthermore, the observation that transfection of
Coro1aLmb3 CD4
+ T cells with wild-type Coronin-expressing plasmids enhanced proliferation clearly implicates
Coro1a. Additional studies demonstrated that proliferation to PMA/Ionomycin by both thymidine incorporation and cell division analysis was not reduced. This showed that
Coro1aLmb3 mutant T cells had the capacity to proliferate and suggested that the impairment involved a proximal signaling event somewhere up to and including PKC activation and Ca
2+ entry, which we identified as a reduction in peak Ca
2+ flux. That Coronins might play a role in Ca
2+ mobiliztion is supported by a recent report in macrophages implicating
Coro1a in the activation of calcineurin, a signaling protein downstream of Ca
2+ entry (
Jayachandran et al., 2007). Why
Coro1aLmb3, but not
Coro1a-deficient (
Foger et al., 2006) T cells exhibit reduced activation is not readily apparent, but there are possible explanations. One possibility is that background strain differences between the
Coro1a−/− mice (mixed 129;B6 background) and the MRL background (this study) may be responsible. Indeed, MRL-
Faslpr CD4
+ T cells have an intrinsic threshold defect in activation associated with TCR-mediated hyperproliferation (
Zielinski et al., 2005). In this case, the intrinsic hyperproliferation may be more sensitive to changes in Ca
2+ flux. Another possibility is that the difference may be related to the fact that only transgenic T cells expressing a single antigen receptor were analyzed in the
Coro1a knockout study whereas we studied polyclonal populations.
Our findings also suggest that
Coro1aLmb3 T cells have a defect in Ca
2+ flux between store-operated Ca
2+ release and opening of the CRAC channels. Recent studies (
Lewis, 2007) have shown that stored Ca
2+ release induces STIM1, a membrane Ca
2+ sensor located throughout the ER, to migrate to the junctional ER, the part of the ER located parallel and adjacent to the plasma membrane. This process is also associated with a modest increase in the amount of junctional ER. The resulting close juxtaposition of STIM1 in the ER membrane to the CRAC channels (Orai or CRACM1) in the plasma membrane leads to Ca
2+ entry at those locations by a mechanism that has yet to be defined. Thus, one possible explanation for the reduced peak Ca
2+ flux is that Coronin-1A, through its effects on actin filament mobilization, may be required for migration of STIM1 and/or formation of junctional ER. Another possibility is that the interaction of STIM1 and CRAC channels might be blocked by the
Coro1aLmb3-associated accumulation of F-actin adjacent to the plasma membrane. A third possibility is that Coronin-1A might play a direct role in the formation of functional CRAC channel complexes. Interestingly, mice deficient for
WAVE2, another actin cytoskeletal-regulatory protein, also exhibit a similar T cell defect in CRAC channel-mediated Ca
2+ entry (
Nolz et al., 2006), and mice deficient for HS1, another actin-regulatory protein that modulates F-actin at the immune synapse, also have a T cell Ca
2+ flux defect that occurs after anti-CD3-mediated crosslinking (
Gomez et al., 2006). Our findings further demonstrate the importance of actin-regulatory proteins in controlling Ca
2+ mobilization in T cells.
The
Coro1aLmb3 mutation is thus associated with three major intrinsic T cell alterations involving migration, cell survival, and activation. These contribute to the reduced numbers of SP thymocytes and peripheral T cells, the inability to form GC, and ineffective T-D antibody responses, which ultimately suppress the development of humoral and cellular manifestations of lupus. This is consistent with our T cell transfer study, which demonstrated that the
Coro1aLmb3 mutation in T cells is sufficient for suppression of autoimmunity and with the lack of obvious alterations in other hematopoietic lineages in this study and in
Coro1a knockout mice (
Foger et al., 2006). Nevertheless, to assess the possible role of non-T cell lineages on lupus susceptibility, we are currently backcrossing the
Coro1aLmb3 mutation onto the MRL-
Faslpr Tcrb−/− background to test, in T cell transfer experiments, the effect of having wild-type
Coro1a expressed in T cells alone.
That Lmb3 is caused by a lupus-suppressing mutation was certainly unexpected and illustrates the fact that genetic mapping studies do not distinguish between predisposing or suppressive alleles. Thus, it is likely that other lupus-related loci, particularly in mouse studies that involve homogeneous backgrounds, might in some instances be similarly associated with suppressive alleles. Also highlighted is the fact that, in addition to traditional predisposing genes, both disease-suppressing genes and spontaneous mutations, as was the case for CoroLmb3, are likely to be significant contributors to the repertoire of genetic variations that modulate induction, severity, and phenotypic heterogeneity of disease in individuals with lupus. Furthermore, different mutations within a single gene could in some instances lead to either increased susceptibility or disease suppression. These types of variants will complicate the identification of susceptibility genes and reduce the clinical utility of genetic associations. Nevertheless, in the case of disease-suppressing genes, such as Coro1a, their identification can provide important clues to pathogenesis and possibly therapy.
The actin cytoskeleton mobilizes molecular scaffolding essential for many crucial cellular functions and involves complex regulatory mechanisms that control and compartmentalize these activities in specific cell types. Our findings demonstrate the critical importance of actin regulation in lupus pathogenesis and further document that alteration of an actin-regulatory protein can have limited, but significant effects, on several specific functions of the immune system despite being highly expressed in all hematopoietic cell lineages. This provides strong impetus, from both the basic and clinical perspectives, to examine the precise roles of other actin cytoskeleton regulatory proteins in normal and self-reactive immune responses.