Histamine is recognized as a key factor in the pathogenesis of allergic diseases. Levocetirizine, a selective H1 antihistamine, controls seasonal allergic rhinitis symptoms in children (
34). Use of sedating H1R blockers was also associated with a decreased risk of developing multiple sclerosis (
35) and improved the quality of life of patients with chronic idiopathic urticaria (
36), suggesting a possible beneficial effect of antihistamines on the onset of some autoimmune diseases. Increased histamine in plasma and tissues is associated with disease severity in human infections with
P. falciparum and in animal models of malaria (
6–
8,
22).
Apart from the correlation with immunopathogenesis in other diseases, little is known of the role of histamine in malaria. In this study, we analyzed the influence of histamine on the course of disease in mice infected with Pb from two different strains that induce distinct pathologies. This work evaluated the hypothesis that the histamine signaling during infection with Plasmodium results in an inflammatory process that exacerbates disease by inducing immunopathology or facilitating the dissemination, adherence, and sequestration of parasites in tissues. Based on divergent approaches using H1R−/− and H2R−/− mice, antihistamine drugs, and histamine-deficient mice, we demonstrate that histamine signaling is associated with the severity of disease.
The mechanisms by which histamine contributes to disease severity and at which stage of the parasite life cycle they operate is unclear. Mice genetically deficient in H1R and H2R, as well as mice treated with H1 and H2 antihistamines, have delayed mortality as compared with similarly infected wild-type mice untreated with the antihistamines, suggesting that the production and binding of histamine to these two receptors are deleterious to the host. However, antagonizing the effects of histamine by interference only at the levels of H1R and H2R had a significant but limited effect with regard to the increase in the mean survival time, possibly because the other factors or histamine receptors, H3R and H4R, also play a role. This is unlikely, however, because imetit and JNJ7777120, H3 and H4 antihistamines known to target H3R and H4R, neither influenced parasitemia nor survival. Thioperamide, a nonselective H3/H4R inhibitor, was also tested and showed no protective effect (unpublished data). To unequivocally determine the effect of histamine on the course of infection with Plasmodium, histamine-free mice were used. HDC−/− mice infected with Pb NK65 through mosquito bites were highly resistant to malaria disease (90–100% survival up to 35 d after infection), with only 30% of the mice developing blood-stage parasites, which were ultimately cleared. These data strongly suggest that the absence of histamine either resulted in the generation of efficient effector responses against the preerythrocytic and blood stages of the parasite or limited the immunopathology associated with the disease. To expand these results to CM, HDC−/− mice were infected with parasites from Pb ANKA. Although HDC−/− mice eventually succumbed from the infection with this strain of Pb, they died at much later times than similarly infected control C57BL/6 mice and did not exhibit any signs of CM. These data implicate histamine in the progression to CM, demonstrate that the enhanced resistance of histamine-free mice is not restricted to parasites from a particular strain, and suggest that histamine signaling could lead to enhanced immunopathological responses. Importantly, results showing comparable parasitemia between groups infected with parasites from Pb ANKA do not support the possibility that the inability of histamine-free mice to develop CM resulted from a reduced parasite burden.
In an attempt to better determine at which stage of parasite development histamine mediates its adverse effects, HDC
−/− mice were also infected with
Pb ANKA
–parasitized RBCs, thus bypassing the preerythrocytic phase. Identical to what was observed after infectious mosquito bites, histamine-free mice did not develop CM and survived significantly longer than similarly infected control C57BL/6 mice. These data indicate that although histamine is produced during all stages of infection with
Plasmodium parasites (i.e., by histamine-producing MCs in the skin and in the liver during the preerythrocytic stage of parasites development, and by histamine-producing basophils in the blood where infected RBCs circulate), the pathogenic effects of histamine are likely prevailing in the latter stages of infection. However, the possibility that histamine also plays a role in the skin and/or the liver during the initial phases of the infection cannot be excluded. Indeed, during the initial phases of the infection, specifically the preerythrocytic stages of parasite development, histamine release may be triggered in the dermis when sporozoites are inoculated via mosquito bites. In this context,
Anopheles saliva induces MC degranulation (
1). During later phases of infection, particularly during the blood stage of parasite development, histamine production can be elicited from circulating basophils either via the cross-linking of parasite-specific IgE antibodies or by TCTP, a parasite-derived homologue of the histamine-releasing factor. TCTP has been found in the plasma of patients infected with
P. falciparum and was shown to trigger histamine release from basophils and IL-8 secretion from eosinophils (
37). The existence of a
Plasmodium protein that stimulates histamine release lends support to the hypothesis that histamine signaling is advantageous to the pathogen and, thus, harmful to the host. These findings could provide a rational basis for higher levels of histamine in blood and in tissues during malaria as a result of the activity of vector- or parasite-derived constituents. Our results () clearly revealed a progressive increase in histaminemia during the course of infection in C57BL/6 mice. Amplifying the host inflammatory response via histamine signaling may be a strategy developed by the parasites to create conditions advantageous for their own survival and persistence. Although the parasites from the two strains used in our study are lethal for mice, the disease courses that they elicit are quite different. Our results in HDC
−/− mice show that in the absence of histamine, the disease severity induced by both parasites was significantly attenuated. The adverse effect of histamine is highlighted by the survival induced after infection with
Pb NK65 and a delayed non-CM death from
Pb ANKA resulting from the interruption of histamine signaling. The reason that infection with
Pb ANKA remains lethal in histamine-free HDC
−/− mice is unclear. It seems plausible that even though inhibiting histamine signaling may abrogate immunopathology, it cannot stop the adverse effects of hyperparasitemia. In addition to its distinctive efficiency in producing CM in mice, the possibility exists that
Pb ANKA also elicits inflammatory mediators, other than histamine, that promote the progression of infection even in HDC
−/− mice. Indeed, analysis of several inflammatory proteins and other immune response–associated molecules, including IFN-γ, IL-6, IL-10, keratinocyte-derived chemokine (KC), monocyte chemotactic protein 1 (MCP-1), macrophage inflammatory protein 1α (MIP-1α), cytotoxic T lymphocyte–associated protein 4, and inducible co-stimulator (; and not depicted), indicates that an inflammatory response, although attenuated, was induced in HDC
−/− mice. Several studies indicate that the CM pathologies seen in mice after infection with
Pb ANKA result from the induced proinflammatory immune response. In agreement, IFN-γ, which was shown to be implicated in the pathogenesis of experimental CM (
38), reached significantly higher levels in the brain tissue and plasma of CM-sensitive C57BL/6 mice than in HDC
−/− mice (). Similarly, our results showing higher levels of IL-6 in the plasma and increased expression of IL-6 transcripts in the brain of CM-sensitive C57BL/6 than in HDC
−/− mice are also in agreement with studies showing higher production of IL-6 in response to TNF-α by endothelial cells of brain capillaries of mice genetically sensitive to CM development (
39). Our results, which diverge from murine CM experiments that suggest a protective effect for IL-10 in CM (
40) but are in accordance with observations in humans that showed an increase in IL-10 with CM as compared with mild malaria patients (
41), show a lower cerebral expression of IL-10 by HDC
−/− mice. IL-4 expression corresponds with CM in our model, in agreement with previous studies that demonstrate that deficiency in IL-4 or IL-4Rα leads to higher resistance to
Pb ANKA (
42).
Analogous to the present data that reveal the adverse effects of histamine for the host during infection with
Plasmodium, a human study demonstrated that the concentration of histamine in plasma was increased by almost fivefold in children suffering from malaria (
22). Additionally, in this study, higher levels of histamine were observed in the brains of children with severe malaria as compared to lesser disease presentations. Among the histamine-associated biological activities relevant to features predictive of severe CM in humans are increased intracerebral blood flow (
43), increased vascular and BBB permeability (
44), and edema (
45). Strikingly, the resistance of histamine-deficient mice to CM was clearly identified by a preserved BBB integrity, in contrast to the greatly increased permeability of the brain vasculature with large clusters of infected erythrocytes observed in infected C57BL/6 mice.
In the absence of histamine signaling, profound alterations of the immune response may also occur. A characteristic feature of CM is the sequestration of CD8
+ and CD4
+ T cells in the brain capillaries (
46–
48). This was confirmed by results in this study showing a 3.7- and 2.7-fold increase of CD8
+ and CD4
+ T cells, respectively, in the brain of C57BL/6 mice infected with
Pb ANKA. Such sequestration in the brain was not observed in similarly infected HDC
−/− mice (). These data suggest that the histamine produced after infection with
Pb ANKA triggers inflammation that leads to the sequestration of T cells in brain capillaries, a prominent component of CM pathogenesis. In this context, it has been reported that histamine is essential for the recruitment of antigen-specific CD4
+ and CD8
+ T cells into the site of antigen delivery and the subsequent generation of inflammatory responses (
12).
Several studies reported a crucial role of ICAM-1 in malaria pathogenesis, and notably, ICAM-1–deficient mice are protected from CM (
49). In this model, ICAM-1
−/− mice survived >15 d despite a similar level of parasitemia in wild-type and knockout mice, a phenotype that is comparable to HDC
−/− mice. Results from our study confirmed the correlation between ICAM-1 expression, both at the protein and transcript levels, and susceptibility to CM. The low levels of ICAM-1 expression in brain microvascular endothelial cells in histamine-deficient HDC
−/− mice () could represent a mechanism leading to the lack of T cell sequestration in the brain capillaries of these mice. It is interesting to note that ICAM-1
−/− and HDC
−/− mice, which express similar phenotypes, have in common a reduced synthesis of ICAM-1 molecules, suggesting a control mechanism exerted by histamine on ICAM-1 expression. Indeed, histamine has been shown to stimulate endothelial cells to express ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 (
32), and cetirizine, a H1R antagonist, has recently been shown to have antiinflammatory properties through the inhibition of leukocyte recruitment and activation, and by the reduction of ICAM-1 expression on keratinocytes (
50) and on conjunctival and nasal epithelial cells (
33). Interestingly, a reduction in ICAM-1 and VCAM-1 expression was observed in the brain tissue of infected C57BL/6 mice treated with levocetirizine (unpublished data). In one study, VCAM-1 was identified by microarray analysis as a candidate gene that discriminates between CM-resistant and -sensitive mice in a
Pb model of CM (
51). Our data do not support the assertion that elevated VCAM-1 corresponds to CM, as we observed slightly higher VCAM-1 mRNA levels in HDC
−/− mice (P < 0.05) as compared with C57BL/6 mice, suggesting an uncertain or, perhaps, protective role for this adhesion molecule in our model. In accordance with our observation of a predominant role for ICAM-1 as compared with VCAM-1 in malaria pathogenesis, infusion of anti–ICAM-1 but not anti–VCAM-1 mAb prevents cytoadherence of infected erythrocytes in a
P. yoelii model of CM (
52).
A possible dissimilarity in the magnitude and quality of the CD4 and CD8 responses elicited by infection with Pb ANKA in C56BL/6 and HDC−/− mice could account for the lack of CM in HDC−/− mice. Such differences in the magnitude of the T cell responses could be the result of a divergent ability to suppress antigen-specific T cell responses in C57BL/6 and HDC−/− mice.
Our results showing a similar effect of infection with
Plasmodium on the specific proliferative response of OT-1 and OT-2 cells in C57BL/6 and HDC
−/− mice suggest that the magnitude of T cell responses is similarly affected in C57BL/6 and HDC
−/− mice. The effect of infection on the magnitude of the
Pb-specific T cell response is currently being compared between C57BL/6 and HDC
−/− mice. Our results are consistent with previous findings showing that during an acute blood-stage malaria infection T cell responses to
Plasmodium parasites and other bystander antigens are inhibited (
53). Thus, the mechanism by which HDC
−/− mice resist CM does not appear to stem from a
Pb ANKA–induced modification of the peripheral T cell responses, though one could argue that the absence of HDC expression may alter histamine-mediated inflammatory responses that are necessary for the manifestation of some effector functions exerted by CD4
+ and CD8
+ T cell responses.
To demonstrate directly and unequivocally the implication of histamine in the pathogenesis of CM, attempts were made to revert the CM-resistant phenotype (HDC
−/−) by frequent injections of histamine into
Pb ANKA–infected mice. Such treatment failed to induce significant alterations in mortality (unpublished data). This method of repleting mice may, however, not be sufficient because of the low bioavailability and the lability of histamine (
54). Nevertheless, our results with antihistamines and genetic knockouts strongly suggest that antihistamine could have a therapeutic value in the treatment of malaria infection, particularly by reducing the likelihood of adverse complications. This is supported by the fact that antihistaminic drugs such as chlorpheniramine potentiate the anti-
Plasmodium effect of mefloquine, quinine, or pyronaridine (
55). It should be pointed out that the antihistamine drugs do not very likely exert their effect directly on the parasite. We performed an experiment in which infected erythrocytes treated with the H1R blocker levocetirizine were compared with untreated infected erythrocytes for their capacity to infect mice. No significant difference regarding survival or parasitemia was observed between the two groups of mice, suggesting that H1 antihistamine drugs exert no direct effect on the parasite (unpublished data).
The present work represents the first comprehensive study documenting the role of histamine in the development of severe pathologies during infection with Plasmodium. Although malaria vaccine development remains a central and ultimate goal, alternative chemotherapy-based approaches such as histamine receptor antagonists have the potential to be highly valuable. Such treatment could be part of an integrated control strategy and could also be a useful candidate in intermittent preventive treatment strategies that target specific high-risk groups, such as children and pregnant women. Furthermore, given the availability of antihistamines, such treatment could be implemented rapidly to alleviate the burden of malaria in endemic areas.