Familial adenomatous polyposis (APC [MIM 175100]) is a colon cancer syndrome characterized by the early age onset of hundreds to thousands of adenomatous polyps in the colon and nearly 100% risk of developing colon cancer at an mean age of 39 years if the colon is not removed
1, 2, 3. Mutation carriers may also present with polyps in the upper GI tract and have an increased risk of small bowel, thyroid, brain, and other malignancies. Mutations in the
APC gene are the most common cause of this syndrome which is an autosomal-dominant condition with a prevalence estimated at 1:10,000 persons
4, 5. Extracolonic features can include osteomas, dental anomalies, cutaneous lesions, desmoids and congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelia (CHRPE). Mutations in the proximal part of the
APC gene (the first 5 exons), the distal end of the
APC gene (3′ to codon 1596) and in exon 9 of the
APC gene lead to an attenuated form of familial adenomatous polyposis (AFAP or AAPC)
3, 6–9. In contrast to FAP, AFAP is characterized by fewer colonic adenomas (clinically defined as less than 100 adenomatous polyps) which have a more proximal distribution (versus FAP, which has polyps covering the entire colon), and later age of onset
10–13. The mean age of colorectal cancer diagnosis in AFAP is reported at 51 to 58 years (15 to 20 years later than FAP) and the lifetime risk of colorectal cancer is decreased in AFAP compared to typical FAP
10–13. The molecular mechanism underlying the attenuated phenotype is not clear, but a variety of models have been proposed. In some cases, the classic FAP phenotypic may result from a dominant-negative truncating
APC mutation that interferes with the normal APC protein
14. Deletions of the entire
APC gene, however, can result in classic FAP
15 as well as AFAP
16 which argues against a dominant-negative model as a general mechanism. Somatic mutations and loss of heterozygosity have been observed in the attenuated
APC allele (as well as the normal allele) in cancer suggesting that the attenuated
APC allele retains some function that protects against the progression to cancer
17, 18. A putative alternative start site at codon 184 (exon 5) has been proposed to reinitiate protein synthesis downstream of a 5′ mutation
19. In addition, it has been suggested that
AAPC mutations in exon 9 may produce normal APC protein by alternative splicing
20, 21. Recently, a recessive form of adenomatous polyposis due to mutations in the
MYH gene was described and differentially named “
MYH-associated polyposis”
22, 23.
Clinical characterization of large AFAP families has revealed a highly variable phenotype, even in individuals with the identical genetic mutation
10–13, 24. Polyp numbers from zero to many hundreds with both extremes observed even at older ages have been reported in mutation-carriers. Upper gastrointestinal polyps, both gastric and duodenal, are often, but not always, present and extracolonic features such as osteomas, epidermoid cysts, desmoids, and cutaneous lipomas are frequently reported. We recently published the detailed phenotype of two large AFAP families (Kindred 353 and Kindred 439) with the identical
APC mutation (exon 4: c.426_427delAT)
13. This frameshift results in a downstream stop codon and a predicted truncated APC peptide of 145 amino acids. In this earlier report, initial colonoscopic evaluation of 120 individuals harboring this mutation revealed a median number of 25 colonic adenomas at a mean age of examination of 42 years. A total of 27 colorectal cancer cases at a mean age of 58 years were documented and a cumulative colorectal cancer risk of 69% by age 80 was estimated.
Founder mutations in hereditary colon cancer syndromes are commonly reported, in particular for the mismatch repair genes responsible for Lynch syndrome (
MLH1, MSH2, MSH6 and PMS2). Of note is an “American Founder Mutation” in
MSH2 that dates back to the 1700’s
25. Founder mutations in the
APC gene, however, are rare. There is a founder FAP mutation in the Spanish Balearic islands
26, founder AFAP mutations in Newfoundland
24 and the family reported here, and an ancient I1307K variant of
APC conferring a 2-fold risk of colon cancer
27.
We have long suspected that these two AFAP families originate from a common ancestor as this mutation has only been reported in families residing in North America
6. Kindred 353 is from Utah and more than 7000 descendents spanning nine generations are recorded in the Utah Population Database (UPDB). UPDB includes genealogies abstracted from the Utah Family History Library, maintained by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS or Mormon), linked to state-wide cancer records from the Utah Cancer Registry and the Cancer Data Registry of Idaho, Utah death certificates, and Utah birth certificates
28. The founding parents were born in Massachusetts and New York in the 1790’s and were part of the Mormon immigration to Utah in the 1850’s. Kindred 439 is from upstate New York and spans six generations. The founding parents were born in New York in the 1830’s. In this report, we provide genealogic and genetic evidence linking the two kindreds to a founding couple who were born in England in the 1590’s and came to America with their children around 1630. This extensive ancestry suggests that there may be many unidentified families harboring this founder mutation in North America, however, clinical recognition of this condition remains a challenge. We report that 36.6% of the mutation-positive family members have fewer than 10 colonic adenomatous polyps, and 13.3% have no family history of a first-degree relative with more than 10 adenomatous polyps. This often makes patients with AFAP difficult to distinguish clinically from patients with sporadic polyps.