|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
It is now clear that functionally specialized regulatory T (Treg) cells exist as part of the normal immune repertoire, preventing the development of pathogenic responses to both self- and intestinal antigens. Here, we report that the Treg cells that control intestinal inflammation express the same phenotype (CD25+CD45RBlowCD4+) as those that control autoimmunity. Previous studies have failed to identify how CD25+ Treg cells function in vivo. Our studies reveal that the immune-suppressive function of these cells in vivo is dependent on signaling via the negative regulator of T cell activation cytotoxic T lymphocyte–associated antigen 4 (CTLA-4), as well as secretion of the immune-suppressive cytokine transforming growth factor β. Strikingly, constitutive expression of CTLA-4 among CD4+ cells was restricted primarily to Treg cells, suggesting that CTLA-4 expression by these cells is involved in their immune-suppressive function. These findings raise the possibility that Treg cell function contributes to the immune suppression characteristic of CTLA-4 signaling. Identification of costimulatory molecules involved in the function of Treg cells may facilitate further characterization of these cells and development of new therapeutic strategies for the treatment of inflammatory diseases.
The intestine is home to a huge number of resident bacteria, estimated to be in the order 1014/g of tissue. These are a significant source of both antigens and proinflammatory molecules present in bacterial cell walls. Despite this potential immune stimulus, it is well recognized that immune responses in the intestine remain in a state of controlled inflammation 1. Recently, we have identified a phenotypically and functionally distinct population of regulatory T (Treg) cells capable of controlling intestinal inflammation, and have suggested that these cells play a pivotal role in intestinal homeostasis 2. Transfer of CD45RBhighCD4+ T cells from normal donors to SCID mice led to the development of an inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)-like syndrome characterized by extensive mononuclear cell infiltrates, epithelial cell hyperplasia, and ulceration 345. Colitis was the result of the differential expansion of Th1 cells driven by enteric bacteria, as disease could be prevented by strategies that inhibited the development of Th1 responses 6 and did not occur in T cell reconstituted mice raised under germ-free conditions 78. Importantly, cotransfer of the reciprocal CD45RBlowCD4+ subset with an inoculum of potentially pathogenic CD45RBhighCD4+ cells inhibited disease. Immune suppression was dependent on TGF-β 9 and production of IL-10 10 by T cells contained within the CD45RBlow population. These data indicate that normal mice contain a population of IL-10– and TGF-β–dependent Treg cells that control inflammatory responses in the intestine.
Subpopulations of peripheral CD4+ T cells have also been shown in several different model systems to be essential for the maintenance of tolerance to tissue-specific self-antigens 111213. Further phenotypic characterization of these Treg cells has shown that they express CD25, as transfer of CD4+ T cells depleted of the CD25+ fraction to nude mice led to the development of autoimmune gastritis 1415. Furthermore, organ-specific autoimmune disease induced by neonatal thymectomy was prevented by transfer of CD25+CD4+ T cells 16. Functional analysis of CD25+CD4+ T cells in vitro showed that this population failed to proliferate or secrete cytokines in response to polyclonal or antigen-specific stimulation, but rather inhibited the activation of normally responsive T cells 1718. Precisely how CD25+CD4+ T cells mediate immune suppression in vitro has not been elucidated, but the mechanism has been shown to be independent of IL-10 and TGF-β and to require cell to cell contact between responding and regulatory T cell populations.
Several factors are thought to influence the fate of T cells after encounter with antigen, including the strength of the signal delivered after TCR triggering, the balance of proinflammatory versus antiinflammatory cytokines present at the time of T cell encounter with antigen, and the integrated signals delivered by costimulatory molecules present on the T cell surface after interaction with their ligands on APCs (for reviews, see references 19, 20). Two well-characterized costimulatory molecules are Ig superfamily members CD28 and cytotoxic T lymphocyte–associated antigen 4 (CTLA-4), both of which interact with CD80 and CD86 present on APCs. CD28 is present on naive T cells and has been shown to be important for the development of optimal primary responses 212223. In contrast, detectable levels of CTLA-4 are induced only after T cell activation, and its ligation results in inhibition of T cell activation. Cross-linking of CTLA-4 concomitant with TCR signaling inhibits IL-2 gene expression and cell cycle progression 2425. The significance of signaling via CTLA-4 in vivo is revealed by the fact that administration of anti–CTLA-4 mAb was able to abrogate the induction of tolerance to specific antigens 26, enhance antitumor responses 27, and exacerbate autoimmune reactivity 282930. Most strikingly, CTLA-4–deficient mice developed a fatal lymphoproliferative disease and multiple organ immune pathology, highlighting the essential role that CTLA-4 plays in the normal homeostasis of the immune system 3132. Recently, cross-linking of CTLA-4 in the presence of TCR ligation has been shown to lead to TGF-β secretion by purified naive CD4+ T cells or CD4+ T cell clones 33, providing an additional mechanism through which CTLA-4 may induce immune suppression.
In this study, we have further dissected the phenotype and mechanism of action of Treg cells that control intestinal inflammation. Here, we show a primary role for CD25+CD45RBlowCD4+ cells in inhibition of colitis, and present evidence that ligation of CTLA-4 and production of TGF-β are required for their function in vivo.
Specific pathogen-free BALB/c, C57BL/6, C57BL/6.SJL.CD45 congenic, C57BL/6.RAG2−/−, and C.B-17 SCID mice were maintained in the Biomedical Services Unit at the John Radcliffe Hospital in microisolator cages with filtered air. Mice were used at 8–12 wk of age.
The following antibodies were used for cell purification: YTS169, anti–mouse CD8; TIB120, anti–mouse MHC class II (American Type Culture Collection); M1/70, anti–mouse Mac-1 (TIB128; American Type Culture Collection); RA3-6B2, anti–mouse B220 34; FITC-conjugated anti–mouse CD45RB (clone 16A; BD PharMingen); biotinylated anti–mouse CD25 (clone 7D4; BD PharMingen); CyChrome-conjugated anti–mouse CD4 (clone RM4-5; BD PharMingen); and PE-conjugated streptavidin (BD PharMingen). Peridinine chlorophyll protein (PerCP)-conjugated anti–mouse CD4 (clone RM4-5; BD PharMingen), FITC-conjugated anti–mouse CD45.2 (clone 104; BD PharMingen), and PE-conjugated anti–mouse CTLA-4 (CD152) (clone UC10-4F10-11; BD PharMingen) were used for analysis of CTLA-4 expression. For in vivo use, anti–mouse CTLA-4 (clone UC10-4F10-11) and anti–mouse TGF-β mAb (clone 1D11.16.8) were purified from hybridoma supernatant by affinity chromatography, and were shown to contain <1.0 endotoxin unit/mg of protein. Purified hamster IgG was purchased from Jackson Immunoresearch Laboratories.
CD4+ T cell subsets were isolated from spleens as described previously 3. In brief, single cell suspensions were depleted of CD8+, MHC class II+, Mac-1+, and B220+ cells by negative selection using sheep anti–rat coated Dynabeads (Dynal). The resulting CD4+-enriched cells were stained with CyChrome-conjugated anti-CD4, FITC-conjugated anti-CD45RB, biotinylated anti-CD25 mAb, and streptavidin-PE. Subpopulations of CD4+ cells were generated by three-color sorting on a FACS Vantage™ (Becton Dickinson). All populations were >98.0% pure on reanalysis.
C.B-17 SCID mice were injected intraperitoneally with sorted CD4+ T cell subpopulations in PBS. Mice received 4 × 105 CD45RBhigh CD4+ cells alone or in combination with other subpopulations. Anti–CTLA-4 mAb (200 μg) was injected intraperitoneally in PBS the day after T cell reconstitution and then on alternate days for 6 wk; mice treated with anti–TGF-β mAb received 2 mg weekly for up to 6 wk.
Colons were removed from mice 6–8 wk after T cell reconstitution and fixed in buffered 10% formalin. 6-μm paraffin-embedded sections were cut and stained with hematoxylin and eosin. Inflammation was scored in a blinded fashion on a scale of 0–4, representing no change to severe changes, as described 10.
Lymphocyte populations were prepared from spleen and mesenteric lymph nodes of normal and T cell–restored mice. Cells were stained with PerCP-conjugated anti-CD4, FITC-conjugated anti-CD45.2, and PE-conjugated anti–CTLA-4. Before staining with anti–CTLA-4 mAb, the cells were fixed with 2.0% paraformaldehyde and permeabilized using 0.5% saponin (Sigma-Aldrich). Samples were analyzed on a FACSort™ using CELLQuest™ software (Becton Dickinson).
Colitis scores were compared using Mann-Whitney or Student's t test, and differences were considered statistically significant with P < 0.05.
To further analyze the relationship between Treg cells that control responses to self-antigens and those that regulate responses driven by bacteria, CD45RBlowCD4+ T cells were sorted into CD25+ and CD25− fractions and tested for their ability to inhibit colitis induced by transfer of CD45RBhigh cells. The results clearly demonstrate that control of intestinal inflammation resided predominantly within the CD25+ fraction, as these cells significantly inhibited development of colitis and wasting disease even when transferred at a ratio of 1:8 (CD25+CD45RBlowCD4+/CD45RBhighCD4+ T cells; Table ). Indeed, colons from mice restored with a mixture of CD45RBhighCD4+ and CD25+CD45RBlowCD4+ cells exhibited no detectable pathological changes and were indistinguishable from colons from mice restored with CD45RBhighCD4+ cells and unseparated CD45RBlowCD4+ cells (Fig. 1, a–d). In contrast, CD25−CD45RBlow cells transferred incomplete protection at the highest dose and mediated no significant regulatory function at the lower dose. Despite the fact that CD25−CD45RBlow cells failed to efficiently prevent colitis, they were also not capable of transferring the disease (Table ), indicating that pathogenic effector cells were not present in this population and did not account for its lack of Treg cell function.
These findings indicate that Treg cells that control inflammatory responses in the intestine are enriched within the same phenotypic subset (CD25+CD4+) as those that inhibit T cell activation in vitro and prevent organ-specific autoimmune disease 141516. The fact that the function of the former, at least in vitro, requires a cognate interaction between responding and regulatory populations prompted us to search for cell surface molecules that may be involved in the function of Treg cells in vivo. A potential candidate was CTLA-4, which has been clearly identified as a negative regulator of T cell activation 2425. To analyze the role of CTLA-4 in the regulation of intestinal inflammation, SCID mice transferred with a mixture of CD45RBhigh and CD45RBlow cells were treated with an anti–CTLA-4 mAb or control hamster IgG. As expected, mice restored with a mixture of CD45RBhigh and CD45RBlow cells and treated with control IgG were significantly protected from both wasting disease and colitis (Fig. 1 b and Fig. 2, a and c). In contrast, mice in the anti–CTLA-4–treated group developed wasting disease with identical kinetics to mice restored with CD45RBhigh cells alone (Fig. 2, a and c). Furthermore, intestinal inflammation occurred with a similar incidence and severity in these mice and had identical characteristics to those observed in mice restored with CD45RBhigh cells alone, including epithelial cell hyperplasia, mucin cell depletion, and pronounced mononuclear cell infiltrates (Fig. 1 e and Fig. 2, a and c). Mice lacking CTLA-4 have been shown to preferentially activate Th2 responses 35; however, there was no evidence that anti–CTLA-4 therapy induced a Th2 response in the colon, as IFN-γ and TNF-α but not IL-4 or IL-10 mRNA were elevated in the colon of anti–CTLA-4–treated mice with colitis (data not shown). Importantly, anti–CTLA-4 treatment also abrogated inhibition of colitis by CD25+CD45RBlow cells, providing direct evidence that the immune-suppressive function of CD25+ Treg cells is dependent on CTLA-4 (Fig. 1 f and Fig. 2 c).
Anti–CTLA-4 treatment may act to enhance the pathogenicity of cells within the CD45RBhigh population. However, the kinetics of wasting disease (Fig. 2 b) as well as the incidence and severity of colitis induced by transfer of CD45RBhighCD4+ cells was indistinguishable in anti–CTLA-4–treated or untreated groups (Fig. 2 c). Similarly, anti–CTLA-4 treatment did not lead to the development of a pathogenic T cell population after transfer of CD45RBlowCD4+ T cells, as the majority of mice in this group failed to develop wasting disease or colitis and were not significantly different from untreated mice (Fig. 2 c). The finding that anti–CTLA-4, which inhibits the function of Treg cells, failed to reveal pathogenic cells among the CD45RBlow population further supports the idea that pathogenic effector cells are not present (at least not in a physiologically relevant number) in the antigen-experienced pool. Taken together, these data suggest that anti–CTLA-4 acts to inhibit the function of Treg cells as opposed to enhancing the pathogenicity of CD45RBhigh cells or revealing pathogenic T cells among the CD45RBlow population.
The consensus of opinion on the function of CTLA-4 is that ligation of CTLA-4 uncouples TCR ligation from the downstream signaling events that lead to full T cell activation (for a review, see reference 36). However, more recently, ligation of CTLA-4 has also been shown to induce TGF-β secretion by both naive and effector CD4+ T cells 33, suggesting that CTLA-4 may mediate positive signaling for secretion of immune-suppressive cytokines. Precisely how CTLA-4 is involved in the function of Treg cells that inhibit intestinal inflammation is not known. It may be induced on the progeny of CD45RBhighCD4+ T cells in the presence of Treg cells and serve to transmit a negative signal to these potentially pathogenic cells. Alternatively, it may be present on Treg cells themselves, providing a costimulatory signal required for these cells to mediate their effector function. To address this issue, we have analyzed the constitutive expression of CTLA-4 among splenic CD4+ T cell subsets. Previous studies have shown that although CTLA-4 functions at the cell surface, it is located primarily in endosomal vesicles, from where it has been shown to cycle continuously to and from the cell surface 3738. To measure both membrane and cytoplasmic CTLA-4 expression, antibody staining was performed on permeabilized cells. Although it has been reported that CTLA-4 is not expressed by CD4+ T cells examined directly ex vivo 3940, our studies revealed significant CTLA-4 expression among CD25+CD45RBlowCD4+ cells (46.4% ± 1.5; representative staining shown in Fig. 3 b) and lower levels on the CD25− subset (12.5% ± 0.2; Fig. 3 c). Low to undetectable levels were present among CD45RBhighCD4+ cells (Fig. 3 a). These results suggest that CTLA-4 is expressed constitutively among CD4+ T cells analyzed directly ex vivo and that this expression is restricted primarily to Treg cells. Recently, expression of CTLA-4 among CD25+CD4+ cells has been noted 41. However, the significance of this was not examined.
To investigate whether inhibition of colitis by CD25+ CD45RBlow cells led to induction of expression of CTLA-4 among the progeny of CD45RBhigh cells that expand in the immunodeficient recipients, pathogenic and regulatory T cell populations were isolated from donors congenic for CD45 allotypes and transferred to immune-deficient recipients. 4 wk after T cell reconstitution, CTLA-4 expression on the progeny of CD45RBhighCD4+ or CD25+CD45RBlow CD4+ cells present in the mesenteric lymph nodes was analyzed. In mice restored with CD45RBhigh cells alone, which would normally develop colitis, CTLA-4 was expressed on a minority of cells (6.4 ± 2.4%; representative staining shown in Fig. 3 d). The picture was similar in mice given a mixture of pathogenic and Treg cells, as under these circumstances only 7.6 ± 1.8% (representative staining shown in Fig. 3 f) of the progeny of CD45RBhighCD4+ T cells expressed CTLA-4. The fact that the progeny of CD45RBhigh cells expressed similar levels of CTLA-4 whether they were able to induce colitis (transfer of CD45RBhigh cells alone) or when they were suppressed (transfer of CD45RBhigh cells plus CD25+ cells) argues against the hypothesis that it is induced CTLA-4 expression on potentially pathogenic cells in the presence of Treg cells that accounts for the requirement for CTLA-4 in the mechanism of immune suppression. Consistent with this, CTLA-4 expression remained high (43.7% ± 7.8, Fig. 3 e) on the progeny of CD25+ cells as they exerted immune suppression in vivo, providing support for the idea that it is CTLA-4 signaling on Treg cells themselves that is crucial for their function. As the highest levels of CTLA-4 expression were restricted to Treg cells, it was possible that anti–CTLA-4 treatment selectively depleted these cells. However, using the congenic transfer system, it was possible to monitor the progeny of Treg cells in mice treated with anti–CTLA-4. Similar numbers of CD25+CD4+ cells were present in anti–CTLA-4–treated mice, indicating that the antibody did not lead to the wholesale depletion of Treg cells (data not shown).
Extensive analysis of the immune-suppressive function of CD25+ Treg cells in vitro has shown no demonstrable role for the immune-suppressive cytokine TGF-β 1718. This was somewhat at odds with our previous observations that the ability of CD45RBlow cells to inhibit colitis was absolutely dependent on TGF-β 9. It is possible that this difference may reflect a comparison of the function of CD25+ cells with unseparated CD45RBlow cells. Given that we now show that Treg cells that most efficiently inhibit colitis are also CD25+, we directly tested whether TGF-β was required for the function of these cells in vivo. As with unseparated CD45RBlow cells, administration of anti–TGF-β to mice usually protected from colitis by transfer of a mixture of CD45RBhigh and CD25+CD45RBlow cells led to abrogation of suppression and induction of severe colitis in the recipients (Fig. 4). These data indicate that in contrast to immune suppression in vitro, immune suppression in vivo was absolutely dependent on TGF-β.
Data reported herein demonstrate that bacteria-driven inflammatory responses in the intestine are regulated by the same phenotypic subset of regulatory T cells (CD25+) as control autoimmune responses to tissue-specific self-antigens 141516 and mediate inhibition of T cell activation in vitro 1718. Previous studies have failed to reveal the mechanism of action of CD25+ Treg cells, which at least in vitro are thought to act via a cognate interaction between responding and regulatory T cells. Our data identify both CTLA-4 and TGF-β as essential components of the immune-suppressive functions of CD25+CD4+ Treg cells that control intestinal inflammation. Consistent with these studies, Takahashi et al. 42 have reported that signaling via CTLA-4 is also required for immune suppression in vitro and that treatment of normal mice with anti–CTLA-4 and anti–CD25 mAbs induces autoimmune disease. The finding that CTLA-4 plays an essential role in the function of Treg cells that control immune responses towards intestinal antigens as well as tissue specific self-antigens suggests that similar functional subsets of Treg cells mediate these diverse roles, emphasizing the central role that Treg cells and CTLA-4 signaling play in the control of the immune response.
There is now overwhelming evidence that CTLA-4 can act as a negative regulator of T cell activation. Blockade of CTLA-4 by injection of anti–CTLA-4 mAbs has been shown to lead to increased T cell–mediated immunity in several model systems, including antigen-specific responses 26, tumor immunity 27, parasitic infection 43, and autoimmune disease 282930. The consensus of opinion is that CTLA-4 acts in a cell-autonomous fashion, and that its expression on potentially reactive T cells results in their inhibition. Our observation that CTLA-4 is required for the function of Treg cells in vivo describes a novel property of CTLA-4, which raises the possibility that the immune stimulatory consequences of CTLA-4 blockade may be in part due to the inhibition of the function of Treg cells. The findings that: (a) anti–CTLA-4 treatment abrogates the function of Treg cells in vivo but does not enhance the pathogenicity of CD45RBhigh cells when transferred alone; (b) CTLA-4 is constitutively expressed by a high proportion of Treg cells; and (c) potentially pathogenic T cells whose function has been suppressed in vivo express similar levels of CTLA-4 as uninhibited pathogenic T cells capable of inducing colitis support the hypothesis that it is CTLA-4 expression on Treg cells themselves that is important for their function. However, these data do not rule out the possibility that in mixtures of pathogenic and Treg cells, expression of CTLA-4 by the progeny of pathogenic T cells plays a role in the mechanism of immune suppression. The definitive answer requires transfer of T cell subsets from CTLA-4−/− mice. However, this experimental approach is confounded by the fact that these mice die at 3–4 wk with fatal immune pathology and have highly distorted T cell subsets 3132. Recently, immune pathology induced in recipients after transfer of CTLA-4−/− bone marrow was shown to be inhibited by transfer of normal bone marrow, indicating that CTLA-4−/− T cells can be inhibited by normal T cells 44. These results, taken together with our own, raise the possibility that costimulation of immune-suppressive Treg cells as opposed to negative signaling of reactive T cells accounts for some of the inhibitory effects of CTLA-4 signaling.
Both cell contact–dependent signals 171845 and secretion of immune-suppressive cytokines 91046 have been shown to be involved in the function of Treg cells. The finding that CD25+ Treg cells that control intestinal inflammation are dependent on both TGF-β and CTLA-4 suggests that a cell surface molecule that negatively regulates T cell activation and secretion of immune-suppressive cytokines may be linked and involved in the function of the same subset of Treg cells. Cross-linking of CTLA-4 in the presence of TCR-mediated signals has been shown to induce TGF-β secretion, providing one possible mechanism for the linkage 33. The explanation of why TGF-β is involved in the in vivo function of Treg cells but not in their in vitro function is not clear. Obviously, immune suppression in vitro represents a very simplified read out of the in vivo phenomenon, and it may be that in the latter, TGF-β plays an important role in limiting the expansion or homing of potentially pathogenic cells.
The results of this study identify signaling via CTLA-4 as essential for the function of Treg cells, providing a new mechanism by which ligation of CTLA-4 may induce immune suppression. Induction of Treg cells is one of the host's natural mechanisms for controlling immune responses. The finding that CTLA-4 plays a nonredundant role in the functioning of these cells will open up new avenues of investigation for the development of therapeutic strategies that seek to manipulate Treg cells.
The authors wish to thank Professor D. Mason and Professor K.J. Wood for their critical review of this manuscript. We are indebted to N. Rust for excellent technical assistance with cell sorting, S. Biddolph for processing of histological samples, and C. Hetherington and staff for care of experimental animals. We gratefully acknowledge Dr. J. Bluestone for the UC10-4F10-11 hybridoma.
S. Read and F. Powrie are funded by the Wellcome Trust. V. Malmström is funded by the Wenner Green Foundation.