Here we show that anterior-posterior axis does not form appropriately in β-catenin–deficient mouse embryos. Axis formation in the mutant embryos is blocked, and the prospective anterior visceral endoderm is mislocated, as judged by the expression of the markers cerberus-like and Lim1 at the distal tip. Subsequently, no mesoderm and head structures form, and markers of posterior, mesodermal differentiation like Brachyury and goosecoid, as well as markers of anterior differentiation like Hex, Hesx1, Otx2, and Engrailed1, are not expressed in the mutant embryos. Intercellular adhesion is maintained in β-catenin–deficient embryos, since plakoglobin substitutes for β-catenin. Our data implicate the signaling capacity of β-catenin, and thus the Wnt pathway, in early axis formation of mammalian embryos.
In
Xenopus, the role of β-catenin and the Wnt pathway in body axis formation and dorso-anterior specification has been well-established (
Funayama et al. 1995;
Harland and Gerhart 1997;
Heasman 1997;
Moon and Kimelman 1998). Axis formation precedes gastrulation as indicated by the enrichment of endogenous β-catenin in nuclei on the prospective dorso-anterior side of the blastula (
Schneider et al. 1996;
Larabell et al. 1997), and a block of β-catenin expression results in failure of axis development (
Heasman et al. 1994). β-Catenin is required as a signaling molecule in this process, since a fusion protein consisting of the DNA-binding domain of the transcription factor LEF-1 and the COOH-terminal transcriptional activation domain of β-catenin is sufficient to induce an additional axis in the frog (
Vleminckx et al. 1999). Also in zebrafish, signaling mediated by β-catenin and the Wnt pathway is essential for embryonic axis formation (
Nasevicius et al. 1998;
Peleari and Maischein 1998;
Sumoy et al. 1999). Our ablation of the
β-catenin gene in the mouse produced a defect in anterior-posterior axis formation at E6, i.e., earlier than gastrulation. Moreover,
goosecoid, a target gene of β-catenin–mediated signaling in
Xenopus (
Laurent et al. 1997;
Peleari and Maischein 1998;
Roeser et al. 1999), is not expressed in
β-catenin–deficient mouse embryos. Therefore, we suggest that in the mouse β-catenin is also required as a signaling molecule for anterior-posterior axis formation. Interestingly,
Engrailed2 has been also characterized as a target gene of β-catenin–mediated signaling in
Xenopus (
McGrew et al. 1999), and we found that the related gene
Engrailed1 is not expressed in β-catenin–deficient embryos. β-Catenin function at the egg cylinder stage may depend on interaction with high mobility group box transcription factors such as LEF-1 or TCF3, which are expressed at this stage (
Roose 1999). A genetic analysis of the mouse TCF3 function has not been reported; other LEF/TCF family members function during later developmental stages (
van Genderen et al. 1994;
Verbeek et al. 1995;
Korinek et al. 1998). Another mutation of the
β-catenin gene in mice was reported previously (
Haegel et al. 1995), but anterior-posterior axis formation was not examined in these mutants.
The phenotype of
β-catenin–deficient embryos is distinct from other mutant mice that display a defective anterior-posterior axis. Mutations in
Smad2,
Smad4, or
ActRIB, which block signaling of members of the transforming growth factor (TGF) β family, affect embryonic differentiation at the egg cylinder stage before gastrulation (
Gu et al. 1998;
Sirard et al. 1998;
Waldrip et al. 1998;
Weinstein et al. 1998). In the absence of
Smad2,
cerberus-like is not expressed, and the epiblast exclusively forms extraembryonic mesoderm (
Waldrip et al. 1998), indicating that Smad2 is required for the initial generation of anterior-posterior organizing centers. This phenotype is more severe than the β-catenin mutant, and suggests that signaling of members of the TGFβ/BMP family may precede or cooperate with the β-catenin–dependent pathway. In
cripto−/− embryos, the anterior-posterior axis is initially formed but mislocated, i.e., both
Hex and
cerberus-like are expressed distally, whereas
Lim1 is expressed proximally. Anterior neuroectoderm forms at the distal end of the embryo, as assessed by the expression of
Hesx1 (
Ding et al. 1998). This is a less severe phenotype than that observed in
β-catenin–deficient embryos, which also show mislocalization of anterior visceral endoderm markers but completely lack subsequent anterior or posterior differentiation.
Hex and
Hesx1 are not expressed in
β-catenin–deficient embryos, suggesting that induction of these genes may depend on β-catenin (
Zorn et al. 1999). These data indicate that β-catenin may operate earlier than or cooperate with EGF–cripto, Frl-1, and cryptic (CFC) molecules. Consistent with this, Wnt and β-catenin signaling does not rescue an
oep/cripto mutant phenotype in zebrafish (
Gritsman et al. 1999). Moreover, gene ablation has shown that
Wnt3 is essential for formation or maintenance of the primitive streak (
Liu et al. 1999).
Wnt3 is not essential for the formation of the anterior organizing center, since anterior visceral endoderm markers are localized correctly in
Wnt3-deficient embryos, but no further anterior or posterior differentiation was observed. Hypomorphic mutations of
axin, which functions as a negative regulator in the Wnt pathway by reducing β-catenin stability (
Zeng et al. 1997;
Behrens et al. 1998), and overexpression of chicken Wnt8 in the mouse cause duplication of the posterior axis, i.e., a second primitive streak (
Zeng et al. 1997;
Poepperl et al. 1997). Taken together, these data indicate that signaling by members of the Wnt pathway plays a role for at least two different steps during axis formation in the mouse: (a) for the establishment of initial anterior-posterior polarity (as detected in our
β-catenin mutants); and (b) for the formation of posterior structures such as the primitive streak (as found in the
Wnt3 mutants) (
Liu et al. 1999).
β-Catenin and
Wnt3 mutants both lack mesoderm and anterior neural ectoderm, probably due to an essential function of β-catenin in Wnt3-dependent signaling. It is not known which
Wnt genes require β-catenin during the initial formation of polarity in the mouse; several
Wnt genes are expressed during early stages of mouse embryogenesis (
Gavin et al. 1990;
McMahon et al. 1992;
Bouillet et al. 1996), and might take over important, possibly partially redundant functions. However, β-catenin–mediated signaling is not required for the general specification of all embryonic axes, since markers for the proximal-distal axis like
Oct4 and
BMP4 are unchanged in the mutant embryos.
We have shown that high contribution of
β-catenin–deficient cells to the epiblast of chimeric embryos leads to developmental arrest. In contrast, absence of β-catenin in extraembryonic tissues like the visceral endoderm allowed anterior and mesodermal differentiation. This indicates that β-catenin function is required in the embryonic ectoderm for axis formation, and that signals from the embryonic ectoderm may contribute to the patterning of the underlying endoderm. To further localize the cells that depend on β-catenin, we carried out two types of experiments. First, we used a mouse reporter strain that carries a lacZ transgene under the control of multiple LEF/TCF binding sites (
Roose 1999) (a generous gift of Dr. H. Clevers, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands). Whereas β-galactosidase activity was detected at E6.5 (
Roose 1999), we could not locate activity at E5.5 and E6.0. However, it should be noted that this promoter appears not to respond to all β-catenin–mediated signals in vivo or in cell culture. Second, we attempted to identify nuclear β-catenin at the egg cylinder stage by confocal immunofluorescence, but could not detect such a signal. Moreover, experiments with chimeric embryos that have a low contribution of
β-catenin–deficient cells show that β-catenin is not required cell-autonomously for mesodermal differentiation. This is in accordance with experiments in
Xenopus that demonstrate that
β-catenin–deficient marginal zones can be instructed by β-catenin–overexpressing animal caps to form dorsal mesoderm (
Wylie et al. 1996).
We showed that cellular adhesion of epithelial cells in the early mouse embryo is not grossly disturbed in the absence of β-catenin. Epithelia in the mutant embryos are well-developed, and the cells are connected by well-defined adherens junctions and desmosomes. Furthermore,
β-catenin–deficient cells in chimeric embryos contributed to various epithelia such as head and limb bud ectoderm. α-Catenin was found to be located along lateral cell membranes in mutant embryos, although β-catenin is normally required to connect α-catenin to classical cadherins. Instead, the protein level of plakoglobin was found to be enhanced, and plakoglobin was redistributed to adherens junctions in
β-catenin–deficient embryos. Apparently, plakoglobin can take over the function of β-catenin in cell adhesion of mutant embryos, a function which has been investigated by in vitro experiments (
Huelsken et al. 1994b). This prevents the early disintegration of epithelia due to defective adhesion that is observed at the blastocyst stage in mice mutant for the
E-cadherin or
α-catenin genes (
Larue et al. 1994;
Riethmacher et al. 1995;
Torres et al. 1997). Cell detachment from the ectodermal cell layer at E7 was reported in the previously generated mutation of the
β-catenin gene (
Haegel et al. 1995). It was not rigorously shown that this earlier mutation corresponds to a null allele. Given the structure of the used targeting vector in
Haegel et al. 1995, it is possible that an NH
2-terminally truncated β-catenin protein is produced from the mutant allele described previously, which could bind to cadherins but not to α-catenin. Such a molecule would act in a transdominant manner and disturb adhesion, in contrast to the rescue of adhesion we observe in our null-mutants. It should be noted that no β-catenin mRNA or protein is produced by both our β-cat
del or β-cat
lacZ alleles, which therefore represent null mutations of the
β-catenin gene. Thus, our data suggest that plakoglobin can substitute for the adhesive function of β-catenin at the egg cylinder stage. Apparently, plakoglobin cannot compensate for the proposed signaling function of β-catenin in axis formation. This is in accordance with previous findings in
Xenopus, which indicate that plakoglobin does not significantly participate in Wnt signaling (
Kofron et al. 1997;
Miller and Moon 1997;
Ben-Ze'ev and Geiger 1998).
The early postimplantation lethality caused by null mutations in
β-catenin precludes the analysis of its function in many tissues and events at later developmental stages that depend on Wnt signaling. A function of β-catenin in hair formation and in skin tumors such as pilomatricomas has been identified by the overexpression of an activated form of β-catenin in the skin of mice (
Gat et al. 1998). Conditional gene ablation will also allow to study functions of β-catenin at later developmental stage.