25-Hydroxyvitamin D3-24-hydroxylase (CYP24)
Vitamin D is synthesized in the skin upon exposure to UVB radiation. One of Vitamin D’s active metabolites, 1,25-D
3 (clinical formulation is known as calcitriol), acts as hormone, and like E and T, it binds to a nuclear receptor, the vitamin D receptor (VDR), and initiates transcription. Unlike T and E, however, 1,25-D
3 has gained attention as an anticancer agent because of its ability to inhibit proliferation, promote differentiation, and induce apoptosis in many cancer cell types including colon and prostate.
50–53 The role of 1,25-D
3 in cancer prevention is also supported by epidemiological studies that reveal a negative correlation between occurrence of certain cancers and sunlight exposure.
54–56 This connection has been particularly well documented in colon cancer where it has recently been suggested by Grant and Garland that as much as 20–30% of colorectal cancer incidences are due to insufficient exposure to sunlight.
57 Deactivation of 1,25-D3 occurs via hydroxylation at C-24 catalyzed by CYP24 ().
58 CYP24 is mainly expressed in the kidney, however, its expression has been demonstrated in other tissue types both healthy and cancerous
3, 59–63 and has been identified as a possible oncogene.
64 CYP24’s role in tumor development and initiation is further supported by its apparent over-expression in lung and colon cancer compared to the corresponding healthy tissue.
62, 63 Importantly, CYP24’s expression is inducible by treatment with 1,25-D
3.
3 This negative feedback mechanism limits the amount of 1,25-D
3 present in tumor cells, and consequently the effectiveness of 1,25-D
3 therapy. Therefore, regulation of CYP24 enzymatic activity may potentiate the anti-cancer benefits of 1,25-D
3. In addition, clinical benefits of 1,25-D
3 have been limited do to hypercalciuric and/or hypercalcemic side effects at therapeutically necessary concentrations.
51 Targeting CYP24 provides the opportunity to increase endogenous levels of 1,25-D
3, or reduce the effective dose of exogenous 1,25-D
3, a therapeutic strategy that may help overcome the deleterious side effects associated with 1,25-D
3 treatment.
Strategies to limit CYP24 action include down-regulation of the enzyme’s expression, as well as inhibition of the enzyme itself.
Genestein (), a naturally occurring isoflavonoid with anticancer properties
65, has been shown to inhibit the transcription of CYP24 as well as CYP27B1 (25-hydroxyvitamin D-1α-hydroxylase),
61, 66 which catalyzes the hydroxylation at C-1 of 25-hydroxyvitamin D
3 to 1,25-D
3.
67 Interestingly, co-treatment with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A increased inhibition of CYP24 expression while restoring expression of CYP27B1.
66 Because CYP27B1 has been shown to be expressed in cancer cells,
68, 69 this co-treatment offers a unique strategy to maximize the amount of 1,25-D
3 present in tumors by suppressing its metabolism while leaving its synthesis unhindered.
Genestein, and various synthetic derivatives, have been evaluated extensively in pre-clinical studies and have shown promising results as chemopreventative and adjuvant chemotherapies
65, 70 prompting the need for evaluation of these compounds in clinical trials.
Recently, Sundaram
et al. described the ability of the synthetic 1,25-D
3 analogue,
QW-1624F2-2 (), to inhibit the expression of CYP24.
71 QW-1624F2-2 was originally described by Posner et al. to mimic the actions of 1,25-D
3 through binding of the VDR and activation of transcription.
72 Importantly, however, it lacks the calcemic side effects of 1,25-D
3. QW-162F
2-2 seems to be as effective as 1,25-D
3 in inhibiting cell growth, inducing its effect through modulation of cell cycle and apoptotic proteins.
73 The molecule has also been shown to inhibit neuroblastoma xenografts in nude mice more effectively than the 1,25-D
3 analogue, EB1089 (1α, 25-dihydroxy-22, 24-diene-24, 26,27-trishomovitamin D
3).
74 Furthermore,
QW-1624F2-2 can inhibit the expression of CYP24 even in the presence of 1,25-D
3, and has been shown to act synergistically with 1,25-D
3 to inhibit cell proliferation.
71 These pre-clinical results are compelling, and demonstrate a need to develop
QW-1624F2-2 as a chemotherapeutic agent.
Obviously, small molecules that can bind to CYP24 and inhibit the enzyme’s activity directly may also prove to be effective treatments for some forms of cancer. Currently, the non-selective CYP inhibitor
ketoconazole () is being used as an adjuvant therapy for hormone refractory prostate cancer, mainly for its inhibition of CYP17 (discussed earlier). However, the compound has also been shown to inhibit CYP24 and act synergistically with Vitamin D
3 analogues in cell culture
75, 76 and is being tried in combination with calcitriol in a phase I clinical trial.
77 Liarozole (), a CYP inhibitor initial designed to inhibit CYP26, has also been shown to inhibit 1,25-D
3 hydroxylation and act synergistically with 1,25-D
3 in androgen independent DU-145 prostate cancer cells.
78 Unfortunately, both
liarozole and
ketoconazole are more potent inhibitors of CYP27B1 than they are of CYP24, greatly limiting their potential efficacy.
Due to these limitations, selective CYP24 inhibitors offer a therapeutic advantage, and several groups have developed compounds to this end.
76, 79–81 Schuster and colleagues have developed potent azol containing inhibitors of CYP24, and their lead compound,
VID400 (), is highly selective for CYP24 over CYP27B1 (IC
50’s of 15nM and 616nM respectively).
82 VID400 is currently undergoing pre-clinical development as an anti-proliferation agent.
79, 82, 83 A different class of CYP24 inhibitors, sulfone analogues of 1,25-D
3, have recently been developed by Posner and colleagues.
81, 84 Their lead compound, a NH phenyl sulfoximine called
MK-24(S)-S(O)(NH)Ph (
MK; ), has shown great specificity for CYP24 with an IC50 of 7.4nM, compared to CYP27B1 (IC50 = 554nM) and CYP27A1 (IC50 > 1000nM).
MK was recently shown to be effective in pre-clinical models of lung cancer, working synergistically with 1,25-D
3 to inhibit growth of the nonsmall cell lung cancer cell line 128-88T.
63ATRA Hydroxylase (CYP26)
All-trans-retinoic-acid (ATRA) is the most active biological metabolite of vitamin A. Through its interaction with nuclear retinoic acid receptors (RAR), ATRA induces cellular differentiation of epithelial cells,
85 and is being used for the treatment and prevention of several types of cancer.
86–89 However, despite ATRA’s pre-clinical efficacy and its clinical success in the treatment of acute promyelocytic leukemia,
90 the overall clinical efficacy of ATRA against human cancer has been disappointing.
91, 92 ATRA’s success seems limited by the development resistance in patients..
93 Like 1,25-D
3, this resistance seems to be due, in part, by the rapid metabolism of ATRA
in-vivo via C-4 hydroxylation ().
94, 95 This realization has inspired researches to develop new classes of drugs designed to inhibit the metabolism of ATRA. Such drugs are often termed retinoic acid metabolism blocking agents (RAMBAs).
Many CYPs have been identified that show the ability to metabolize ATRA via 4-hydroxylation including CYP2C8, CYP3A4, and CYP2C9.
96–99 However, the specificity of these enzymes for ATRA is quite low.
96–98 CYP26A1 and CYP26B1 have recently been identified as members of a new family of P450 enzymes that seem dedicated to ATRA metabolism.
10, 11 Furthermore, CYP26A1 expression has been shown to be induced upon treatment with ATRA in cancer cells,
4–9 and expression of the enzyme limits induction of apoptosis by ATRA.
5 This phenomenon appears to be implicated in clinically acquire resistance to ATRA. In addition, certain cancers including acute promyelocytic leukemia, prostate, breast and non-small lung carcinomas express CYP26A at constitutively high levels
5–7, 100–102 This has lead to a great deal of interest in the specific targeting of RAMBAs towards CYP26. However, non-specific inhibition of all enzymes involved in ATRA metabolism is an alternative strategy that hinges on the idea that non-specific metabolism of ATRA would prevent accumulation of the hormone to levels sufficient enough to induce the expression of CYP26.
Liarazole (Liazel
TM; Johnson and Johnson Pharmaceutical Research and Development; ) is the first and only RAMBA to be evaluated clinically in patients with cancer. Interestingly,
liarazole is a relatively weak inhibitor of CYP26 (IC
50 ~ 2.2–6.0μM).
103–107 Liarazole showed promise in pre-clinical models of prostate cancer
106, 108 and clinically as a second line therapy following failure of androgen deprivation.
109 However,
liarazole’s usefulness as a cancer therapy is unfortunately limited by its lack of specificity for CYP isozymes responsible for ATRA metabolism, as well as its moderate potency against CYP26 and is no longer being developed as an anti-cancer agent.
10 Follow-up compounds
R115866 and
R116010 () are far more potent and selective inhibitors of CYP26 and have shown efficacy in pre-clinical cancer models.
10 Work by our group, researchers at Allergan Sales Inc, and OSI Pharmaceuticals Inc have yielded novel compounds classified as azolyl retinoids, benzeneacetic acid derivatives, and 2,6-disubstituted napthalenes, respectively (). All of these compounds have shown strong inhibition of CYP26. Additionally, the azolyl retinoids and the 2,6 disubstituted napthalenes have shown anti-cancer properties in pre-clinical models.
10, 110, 111 In fact, one of our RAMBAs,
VN/14-1, inhibits the growth of letrozole resistant breast cancer cells more potently than parental letrozole sensitive cells.
112 These results indicate the potential usefulness of RAMBAs for hormone refractory cancers. Despite promising published pre-clinical results, no clinical trials have been undertaken to date with any RAMBA other than liarazole. However, plans are underway to advance our novel RAMBAs alone and in combination with histone deacetylase inhibitors for clinical trials in breast and prostate cancer patients. For more information on the development and utility of RAMBAs, please consult our group’s recent review on the subject (Njar et al., ref
10).