To define how thermophilic cyanobacteria in microbial mats respond to fluctuating environmental parameters, we used an isolate of
Synechococcus OS-B′, one of the dominant ecotypes in the 53°C-to-63°C region of Octopus Spring microbial mats. The ability to monitor the growth of this isolate under environmentally relevant temperature conditions, coupled with the availability of the complete genome sequence, provided some of the necessary tools for this investigation, although there are many caveats associated with studies of microbes in axenic cultures. Since much is known about how cyanobacterial cells respond to HL conditions at the biochemical and gene regulation levels, we were able to monitor several key indicators of the physiological state of the cells (
7,
21). To our surprise,
Synechococcus OS-B′ did not appear to be able to cope with continuous HL irradiances (400 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1 or higher, although the surfaces of microbial mats are subject to very high irradiance during the day, with large and rapid fluctuations in light intensity associated with cloud cover. We also observed notable differences in photosynthetic function and capacity between
Synechococcus OS-B′ cells and well-studied mesophilic cyanobacteria, which are discussed in the context of cyanobacterial physiology and acclimation responses below.
Axenic cultures of
Synechococcus OS-B′ grew optimally at light fluence rates of between 75 and 130 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1 and had a doubling time of ~17 h. At 200 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1, the cells exhibited signs of HL acclimation responses, and cells grown in continuous light at an irradiance of 400 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1 stopped growing after 3 days and then died, suggesting that
Synechococcus OS-B′ is unable to tolerate long periods of HL under laboratory conditions. In contrast, mesophilic cyanobacteria, such as
Synechocystis sp. strain PCC6803 and
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC6301, grow well at light fluence rates of ~500 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1 (
20). In situ, cells at the surfaces of microbial mats are potentially exposed to light irradiances that are considerably higher than 400 μmol photons m
−2 s
−1, and thus it may have been expected that
Synechococcus OS-B′ cells would survive relatively high light irradiances. It has been speculated that cyanobacterial cells may be able to actively position themselves within the vertical light gradient of the mat to optimize light conditions for photosynthesis (
33). It has been demonstrated that in the mat there are distinct cyanobacterial populations that exhibit positive and negative phototaxis (movement toward and away from the light, respectively), suggesting that different cell populations may actively position themselves in different light environments of the mat (
33). Furthermore, it has been shown that light is rapidly attenuated as it passes through the top microbial layers of the mat, particularly in the blue and red regions of the spectrum; cells just below the surface may be shielded from high-irradiance surface light (
13,
43). The presence of other members of the microbial community, particularly the abundant filamentous bacterium
Roseiflexus sp., and the dense polysaccharide matrix of the interstices of the mat are likely to profoundly affect the in situ light environment. In contrast, the cultures grown in the laboratory were dispersed, aerated, and analyzed in mid-log phase (OD
750, <0.5), so there was reduced self-shading. Finally,
Synechococcus cells growing as axenic cultures under controlled laboratory conditions (continuous fluorescent light, bubbled with CO
2-enriched air) in the absence of other members of the microbial community may exhibit different growth responses than cells living in the stratified layers of the mat, where metabolite exchange may play an important role in photosynthetic function.
Photosynthetic organisms can acclimate to the potentially damaging consequences of the absorption of excess light energy in a number of ways, which include a marked decline in light-harvesting pigments, changes in the level and composition of photosynthetic reaction centers, the development of sinks to efficiently remove electrons from the electron transport chain, the establishment of mechanisms to eliminate ROS that might accumulate, and the ability to repair damaged cellular components. We observed many of these acclimation responses in the laboratory-based experiments conducted in this study.
We observed a striking difference in pigmentation among cells grown at different light irradiances. At light irradiances above 50 μmol photons m−2 s−1, the cells had reduced PBS and Chl a contents, while the cell size remained approximately constant, at ~10 μm by 2 μm. Bleaching was more pronounced at 200 μmol photons m−2 s−1, and cells at 400 μmol photons m−2 s−1 were bleached severely and then died. The loss of PBS reflects the reduced requirement for light-harvesting capacity as environmental light levels increase. Quantification of the abundance of transcripts encoding the polypeptides that make up the PBS was consistent with this observation. Transcripts encoding the individual PC and AP subunits, which are components of PBS rods and cores, respectively, were more abundant in cells grown in LL than in cells grown in ML and HL, but the levels of transcripts encoding Cpc polypeptides declined significantly more than did those encoding Apc polypeptides. These results suggest that at higher light irradiances, there is a reduction in the absorbance cross section of the light-harvesting antenna, reflected by a pronounced decrease in the amount of PC hexamers, while the core polypeptides may be much less reduced; the number of PBS units may not change as dramatically as the absorption cross section of the complex. Furthermore, cpcH mRNA, which encodes an LR20.5 linker polypeptide, was barely detected in cultures grown at a high irradiance. These results suggest that LR20.5 is the most distal rod linker polypeptide and the first to be lost as the rod length decreases at increasing light irradiances.
Analyses of 77-K fluorescence emission spectra following excitation of the cells at 435 nm suggested a pronounced excess of PS I relative to PS II in cells grown under LL, ML, or HL; the ratio of PS II to PS I appeared highest in LL-grown cells. These results contrast with results from studies with
Synechocystis sp. strain PCC6714 and
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942, in which there was an increase in the PS II/PS I ratio with increasing growth light irradiances (
28,
36). The number of Chl
a molecules bound to individual PS I and PS II reaction centers in
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942 (former name,
Anacystis nidulans) was reported to be 118 and 52, respectively, regardless of growth light and CO
2 conditions (
24,
29). A decrease in the PS II/PS I ratio in conjunction with a decline in Chl
a levels in HL-grown
Synechococcus OS-B′ indicates that cells acclimated to HL conditions are likely to have reduced levels of both PS I and PS II. An increased loss of PS II in HL-grown cells may be beneficial because of the potential for PS II photochemistry to generate increased oxidative damage, especially at elevated temperatures. Finally, the fluorescence emission data following excitation of cells with 620-nm light after growth at various light irradiances suggest that the cells (at least those grown in ML and HL) are capable of performing state transitions; we were not able to determine whether or not state transitions were occurring in LL-grown cells.
Carotenoids are an important group of lipid-soluble antioxidants in photosynthetic membranes (
30).
Synechococcus OS-B′ synthesizes zeaxanthin, β,β-carotene, and a myxolglycoside in which the dimethyl fucoside moiety of myxoxanthophyll (
41) is likely replaced by an anhydrohexose. Myxoxanthophyll is critical for stabilization of thylakoid membranes and the formation of the S layer in
Synechocystis sp. strain PCC6803 (
27). It also increases 1.5- and 2.5-fold after 20 and 45 h, respectively, of exposure of
Synechocystis sp. strain PCC6803 to HL (
23). In
Synechococcus OS-B′, HL triggers a >14-fold increase in the myxolglycoside/Chl
a ratio within 9 h, but the response is apparent within the first 2 h of HL, suggesting an important photoprotective function. Furthermore, myxolglycoside accumulation is likely to be a consequence of de novo synthesis, since the levels of β,β-carotene and zeaxanthin remained nearly constant or increased only slightly during the 9-h HL treatment. An increase in carotenoid synthesis during this period is also reflected by an increase in the level of the
crtP mRNA (encoding phytoene desaturase).
The development of photoinhibition due to hyperexcitation of the photosynthetic apparatus at high irradiances has been associated with a rapid turnover of the PS II reaction center polypeptide D1 (
10). Some cyanobacteria, including
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942, acclimate to UV radiation by replacing the D1:1 protein isoform with the D1:2 isoform (
5,
6,
39), while others, such as
Synechocystis sp. strain PCC6803, express only the D1:2 isoform under laboratory conditions (
26,
38). In
Synechococcus OS-B′, the levels of the transcripts for the three
psbA genes (
psbAI,
psbAII, and
psbAIII) were regulated in a light-dependent manner, similar to what has been reported for
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942 (
5). In
Synechococcus OS-B′, steady-state
psbAI transcript levels were highest in ML (threefold more abundant than those in LL and HL). One explanation for this finding might be the existence of several acclimation processes. More PS II is present in LL-acclimated cells, and with increasing growth light irradiances, elevated turnover of the D1 protein likely occurs, which causes an increase in expression of the
psbA1 gene. However, as the light irradiances are increased further, there is more demand for the phototolerant D1:2 isoform. Thus,
psbAI transcript levels decline while
psbAII/III transcript levels increase. The levels of transcripts from
psbAI and
psbAII/III appear to be controlled in a reciprocal manner with respect to light irradiance. Interestingly, light shift experiments revealed that
psbAI and
psbAII/III transcript levels measured 1 h following a shift of the cultures to HL were different from those observed in cultures maintained in HL or LL, suggesting that acclimation was not complete within this time period. Previous work with
Synechococcus sp. strain PCC7942 demonstrated rapid transient changes in
psbA transcript levels, which slowly stabilized (
22). The shift from LL to HL conditions may cause a relatively quick turnover of D1:1, and the consequences of this turnover (e.g., loss of PS II activity) may trigger transcription of the
psbAII/III genes. However, the levels of the
psbAI and
psbAII/II transcripts may begin to stabilize only as the D1:2 protein integrates into the PS II reaction center; other, longer-term processes, including the adjustment of the ratio of the photosystems (see above) and the expression of proteins that can ameliorate the effects of oxidative stress, are also likely to influence the final levels of the
psbA transcripts.
The dense polysaccharide matrix of the mat is a diffusion barrier allowing the O
2 concentration in the mat to rise well above air saturation during the day (
30). An elevated level of O
2 in the mat would likely increase photorespiration and cause a dramatic change in the cellular redox state, which in turn might stimulate the generation of ROS, resulting in photoinhibition and damage to many cellular components (
2,
26). ROS accumulation and its damaging consequences may be exacerbated by the high temperatures of the hot spring environment (
4). Cyanobacteria have evolved many strategies to cope with the potential damaging effects of excess excitation energy. Tocopherol and carotenoids (see below) are antioxidants that help to ameliorate the consequences of ROS accumulation during periods of excess excitation (
23). The level of transcript from the CYB_0605 gene, encoding tocopherol cyclase in
Synechococcus OS-B′, rises with increasing growth light irradiances. Although we did not directly measure tocopherol concentrations in the cell, these results suggest that tocopherol may accumulate in
Synechococcus OS-B′ in response to elevated irradiance. Furthermore, harmful superoxide radicals can be deactivated by superoxide dismutase (
32), and indeed, we observed an increased accumulation of
sodB mRNA in
Synechococcus OS-B′ cells grown in ML and HL. Photodamage might also be reduced by decreasing the redox poise of the cellular quinone pool. This can be achieved by promoting cyclic over linear photosynthetic electron transport and/or by using electrons generated by the splitting of water to reduce alternative electron acceptors (acceptors other than NADP), such as O
2 (to regenerate water in a water-to-water cycle). As discussed above, HL-grown cells accumulate much more PS I (involved in cyclic electron flow) than PS II. Furthermore, transcripts for at least two oxidases, namely, the cytochrome
b,
d-quinol oxidase encoded by
cydA, which transfers electrons from the PQ pool to O
2 (
3,
19), and the respiratory cytochrome
c oxidase encoded by
coxA, increase following exposure of the cyanobacterial cells to HL. These results suggest that
Synechococcus OS-B′ can adjust to HL conditions by both elevating cyclic relative to linear photosynthetic electron transport and diverting electrons from the reduced PQ pool to alternate electron sinks, such as O
2. This would be especially important for mat cyanobacteria, since high O
2 and/or low CO
2 concentrations in the polysaccharide matrix of the mat may limit photosynthetic CO
2 fixation. Promoting the flow of electrons from the PQ pool to O
2 would help to reduce electron pressure in HL, which in turn would generate a greater proportion of open PS II traps, thereby reducing photoinhibition.
Concluding remarks. Little is known about how thermophilic cyanobacteria in microbial mats respond to changes in light irradiance, O2 levels, nutrient conditions, and gradients of metabolites synthesized by other bacteria of the mat consortium. Full genome sequences and detailed analyses of the physiological capacity of individual members of the mat community, along with studies to elucidate ways in which the different organisms respond to changing environmental conditions, will greatly contribute to our understanding of the structure and dynamics of microbial consortia and the underlying regulatory processes.