Frequent
KRAS gene mutations at codon 12 have been reported in several cancers, including those from colonic and pancreatic tissues [
34–
37]. Previous studies have found
KRAS mutations, mainly at codon 12 in the exon 1, in 31% to 86 % of IPMNs (47% in our study) [
21–
26]. The wide variety of the reported frequencies most likely is due to the ongoing better definition of these lesions [
7,
38,
39] and might also be dependent on the sensitivity of a chosen screening methodology [
40,
41]. For this study, we chose to use the plain PCR technique with direct genomic DNA sequencing to keep possible false positive results to a minimum.
In the present study the distribution of KRAS mutation showed a single mutation in all observed cases. Multiple mutations in the same sample were not observed. KRAS mutation is an early event in the tumorigenesis of IPMN- KRAS mutation was observed in IPMN, adenoma (1/3) and its mutation frequency remains consistent as IPMN progresses (2/4 for in IPMN, borderline; 2/5 in IPMC; and 12/24 in IPMC with invasion). There was no tumor size, gender, or age bias observed associated with KRAS mutation.
Unlike pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma where
KRAS is mutated at a frequency close to 100% [
36,
37], 14–69% (53% in our study) of IPMNs do not harbor an active
KRAS mutation. This suggests that a relatively large percentage of IPMNs/IPMCs might use alternative ways other than
KRAS mutation to stimulate this Ras-Raf-MEK-ERK-MAP kinase pathway.
BRAF, a serine/threonin kinase located immediately downstream in Ras signalling, has been found frequently mutated in a variety of human malignant neoplasms [
15–
17,
19,
33,
42,
43]. Here we report a somatic
BRAF mutation out of 36 cases of IPMN/IPMC examined (2.7%). While
BRAF contributes to the tumorigenesis of IPMN, it is not a frequent event and certainly does not entirely explain the lower mutation rate of
KRAS in IPMN/IPMC than in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma.
The
BRAF mutation occurred at nucleotide 1847, a C to T change at codon 615 of the
BRAF gene, leading to an amino acid change from serine to phenylalanine (S615F). Although located at exon 15, the S615F mutation is not the previously described hot-spot mutation at exon 15 (V599E) of the
BRAF gene [
15,
16,
33]. This mutation was also found to co-exist with a G12R mutation of
KRAS in the same sample. It has been observed previously in colon and lung cancers that
BRAF mutations, other than
BRAF V599E, coexisted with
RAS mutations [
16]. The
BRAF V599E mutation seems to uncouple cells from their proliferation requirement of
RAS, and therefore mutation of
RAS was not detected in any of the tumors carrying
BRAF V599E mutation [
16].
In vitro data indicated that
BRAF V599E mutants can be further activated by mutant
RAS, whereas other
BRAF mutants remain dependent on
RAS function [
16]. A previous study on pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma revealed that the
BRAF hot-spot mutation was observed in two of nine tumors retaining wild-type copies of the
KRAS,
NRAS, and
HRAS genes, but none in 72 adenocarcinomas with
KRAS mutations within exons 11 and 15 [
44]. In contrast, another study found both
KRAS and
BRAF V599E mutations coexisting in two cases of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma [
45]. These two cases did not exhibit different clinicopathological characteristics from pancreatic cancers with
KRAS mutation alone [
45]. The novel S615F mutation observed here is also in the B-Raf activation segment [
46], but its functional effect is unknown. Cells with activating mutations in both
KRAS and
BRAF had a substantially higher B-Raf kinase activity and ERK 1/2 phosphorylation activities than those with
BRAF mutation alone [
16]. It is possible that tumors with both
BRAF and
KRAS mutations have an accelerated course in the development or progression of the tumors. Together, these observations suggest that different
BRAF mutations can have distinct transforming potential in tumorigenesis, which would be worthy of further investigations in future studies.
This is the first mutational study of BRAF in IPMN/IPMC. Although the BRAF mutation frequency in IPMN/IPMC is low compared with those observed in malignant melanoma and colon cancers, our data suggests that alteration of the Ras-Raf-MEK-ERK-MAP kinase pathway by BRAF mutation together with RAS mutation may play an important role in the tumorigenesis of IPMN/IPMC.