The role of telomerase in gallbladder carcinogenesis is at present largely unknown. Telomerase activity has so far only been analysed by the TRAP (telomeric repeat amplification protocol) assay in a few samples of gallbladder adenocarcinoma. Niiyama
et al detected telomerase activity in eight of 11 gallbladder adenocarcinomas but not in benign biliary tract lesions.
27 Itoi
et al detected telomerase activity in two of three gallbladder adenocarcinomas, whereas specimens of non-malignant biliary tissue had no detectable telomerase activity.
28 However, the TRAP assay has several potential limitations. Telomerase detection by the TRAP assay may be complicated by enzyme inhibitors, proteases, and RNAses, which may restrict the usefulness of the test and reduce its sensitivity.
29 In addition, recent studies have confirmed a close relation between hTERT mRNA expression and telomerase activity, suggesting that the assessment of hTERT gene expression could be used as an alternative to telomerase activity measurement.
30,31Itoi
et al have reported that hTERT mRNA was detected in the bile of three of four patients with gallbladder carcinoma.
32 In contrast, telomerase activity as assessed by the TRAP assay was confirmed in only one of these patients.
32 Recently, hTERT mRNA was detected preoperatively in bile from a patient with gallbladder cancer.
33 In addition, hTERT mRNA was found in the bile of a further three of eight patients with gallbladder cancer, and subsequently in the resected neoplastic tissue.
33 Interestingly, the bile samples of all four patients with benign gallbladder disease were negative for hTERT mRNA.
33To the best of our knowledge, hTERT protein has not so far been studied in gallbladder carcinogenesis. In the present study, we analysed the expression of hTERT protein in normal gallbladder mucosa, regenerative gallbladder epithelium, low and high grade gallbladder epithelial dysplasia, and gallbladder adenocarcinoma, to gain insight into the potential role of the telomerase catalytic subunit, and indirectly also of the telomerase enzyme, in gallbladder carcinogenesis.
“Our results suggest that some cell clones might already be immortal in low grade epithelial dysplasia, because the hTERT protein positive nuclei were usually seen in clusters, probably representing the expansion of a single cell clone within the dysplastic gallbladder epithelium”
We selected monoclonal antibody NCL-hTERT from several commercially available anti-hTERT antibodies because it has been tested extensively, and has been reported to be sufficiently specific for use on formalin fixed, paraffin wax embedded tissue specimens.
34 It has also been shown that hTERT immunostaining with the NCL-hTERT antibody in fixed tissues agreed with telomerase activity and hTERT mRNA expression in the corresponding non-fixed samples,
34 suggesting that hTERT protein immunohistochemistry might be used as a surrogate marker for the estimation of telomerase activity in the tissue sample. Theoretically, nuclear localisation of the hTERT protein is required to promote elongation of telomere sequences, and hTERT protein immunoreactivity was generally found within the nucleoplasm and/or nucleoli as small or larger dots.
34 Wong
et al have shown that catalytically active telomerase has a regulated intranuclear localisation that is dependent on the cell cycle stage, transformation, and DNA damage.
35 Whereas telomerase is released from sequestration at nucleolar sites into the nucleoplasm at the expected time of telomere replication in normal cell lines, there is almost a complete dissociation of telomerase from nucleoli at all stages of the cell cycle in tumour and transfected cells.
35 However, we and others have noted in a proportion of predominantly tumour cells, but also in samples of low and high grade gallbladder epithelial dysplasia, a fine granular cytoplasmic staining, either diffuse or confined to small areas, in addition to nuclear and/or nucleolar staining.
34,36 Although the exact biological significance of cytoplasmic hTERT protein staining is at present unknown, cytoplasmic hTERT immunoreactivity might reflect a failure of nuclear translocation of a variant hTERT protein, as a result of alternative splicing of hTERT mRNA, or signify a yet unknown function of hTERT protein in the cytoplasm.
34,36We mostly failed to demonstrate hTERT protein in normal and regenerative gallbladder epithelial cells. Cells with hTERT protein signals did not differ morphologically from hTERT protein negative cells. Therefore, it appears that these cells correspond to committed descendants of stem cells undergoing terminal differentiation into columnar cells. Our results suggest that the occasional presence of hTERT protein in the nuclei of normal and regenerative gallbladder epithelial cells reflects the self renewal capacity of these cells. It has already been established that stem cells and their committed descendants, such as germline cells, possess telomerase activity that stabilises their telomeres and facilitates continuing proliferation for regenerative purposes.
21,24 Telomerase activation may thus be an adaptive response to protect excessive telomere loss and may possibly help to extend the proliferative life span in highly regenerative cells.
37The concept of dysplasia of the gallbladder as a precancerous condition was suggested by histological observations showing that dysplasia appeared to lie on a histological continuum with carcinoma, and that it was more common in gallbladders containing overt carcinoma than in non-cancerous gallbladders.
5,38 According to Roa
et al, the difference in the mean ages of patients with dysplasia and early gallbladder carcinoma (tumours with infiltration into the mucosa or muscular layer) is 12 years, and the difference between those with early carcinoma and advanced carcinoma is about two years.
38We found a significantly higher number of hTERT signals for each nucleus in low grade dysplastic gallbladder epithelium than in normal and regenerative gallbladder epithelium. hTERT positive cells showed a dysplastic phenotype morphologically. Our results suggest that the significantly higher numbers of hTERT signals for each nucleus seen in low grade epithelial dysplasia than in normal and regenerative gallbladder mucosa probably reflects the re-expression of the hTERT gene as part of a multistage process of gallbladder carcinogenesis. Experimental studies have confirmed that re-expression of the hTERT gene in normal human somatic cells can reconstitute telomerase activity and extend the replicative life span of these cells beyond crisis, the last known proliferative blockade to cellular immortality.
39 Therefore, telomerase reactivation has been associated with the appearance of immortal cell populations, a crucial event in human carcinogenesis.
40 Furthermore, our results suggest that some cell clones might already be immortal in low grade epithelial dysplasia, because the hTERT protein positive nuclei were usually seen in clusters, probably representing the expansion of a single cell clone within the dysplastic gallbladder epithelium.
No direct data are available on the progression rate of high grade dysplasia/carcinoma in situ to invasive gallbladder adenocarcinoma. For comparison, high grade dysplasia in the stomach regressed in only about 5%, persisted in 14%, and progressed in most cases (81–85%).
41 The time frame between a diagnosis of severe/high grade dysplasia and the identification of invasive gastric cancer was between less than one month and 39 months.
41 Furthermore, data from the early 1960s show that carcinoma in situ of the larynx progressed to laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma in approximately 90% of cases in the subsequent six months.
42Significantly higher numbers of hTERT protein signals for each nucleus were found in high grade dysplasia/intraepithelial carcinoma and adenocarcinoma than in normal gallbladder epithelium, regenerative epithelium, and low grade dysplasia. These data suggest that, as in low grade dysplasia, significantly higher hTERT indices in high grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma are the consequence of hTERT re-expression. Namely, once telomerase reactivation has been established at a particular stage of gallbladder carcinogenesis (low grade dysplasia), it can be sustained in the subsequent stages, as we demonstrated here. Because telomerase reactivation conveys cellular immortality, cells can proliferate indefinitely, with clonal expansion and accumulation of additional genetic abnormalities, which drive the progression of epithelial changes towards gallbladder adenocarcinoma. Therefore, it is not surprising that similar numbers of hTERT signals in each nucleus are seen in high grade dysplasia/intraepithelial carcinoma and adenocarcinoma. Furthermore, these data suggest that genetic changes other than telomerase reactivation appear to be necessary for the progression of gallbladder epithelial abnormalities towards gallbladder adenocarcinoma. In agreement with our observations, downregulation of p27
Kip1 expression appears to be a late event in gallbladder carcinogenesis, associated with tumour progression and metastases.
7Take home messages- Expression of the telomerase catalytic subunit (hTERT) increased progressively with the degree of gallbladder epithelial abnormality, probably as a consequence of hTERT re-expression—an early event in the multistep process of gallbladder carcinogenesis
- Three different groups of gallbladder epithelial changes could be distinguished according to the number of hTERT signals/nucleus: (1) normal and regenerative gallbladder epithelium, (2) low grade dysplasia, and (3) high grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma
- The occasional presence of hTERT protein in normal and regenerative gallbladder mucosa probably reflects their regenerative capacity
In conclusion, our study is the first to analyse the expression of hTERT protein in normal gallbladder epithelium, different grades of gallbladder epithelial abnormalities, and gallbladder adenocarcinoma. We have shown that the number of hTERT signals in each nucleus increases progressively with the degree of epithelial abnormalities. Statistical analysis revealed three groups of gallbladder epithelial changes, which differ significantly in the number of hTERT signals for each nucleus, namely: (1) normal and regenerative gallbladder mucosa, (2) low grade dysplasia, and (3) high grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma of the gallbladder. Our results suggest that the occasional presence of hTERT protein in normal and regenerative gallbladder mucosa probably reflects its self renewal capacity—that is, regeneration. Nevertheless, significantly higher hTERT indices in dysplastic epithelium and gallbladder adenocarcinoma are probably the consequence of hTERT re-expression—an early event in the multistep process of gallbladder carcinogenesis.