Tumor cell tolerance to hypoxia is an important determinant of the level of hypoxia which can be sustained within a given cell. This intrinsic property drives an adaptive response that results in increased cell survival during periods of heightened cellular stress and can elicit resistance to anticancer therapies. Recently, stress-tolerant cell lines were generated by means of repeated cycles of hypoxia and reoxygenation. Weinmann et al. established that hypoxia-resistant cell lines demonstrated cross-resistance to apoptosis induced by etoposide and UV irradiation (
98). Additionally, stress-tolerant tumor cell lines generated by Yao et al. were more invasive and, when injected subcutaneously into nude mice, resulted in faster-growing tumors that demonstrated increased intratumoral angiogenesis (
100).
The rapid and sustained inhibition of protein translation during hypoxic stress is thought to be one mechanism utilized by cells to promote hypoxia tolerance. The coordinated inhibition of protein translation, an energy-costly mechanism, is one energy-conserving strategy exploited by the cell when ATP levels are limited. Global translation inhibition is achieved upon activation of the ISR through the phosphorylation of eIF2α by the ER-resident kinase Perk (
51). The luminal domain of Perk is negatively regulated by the ER chaperone BiP/Grp78, which maintains Perk in its inactive state in unstressed cells (
6). During ER stress, the accumulation of unfolded proteins within the ER promotes the dissociation of BiP from the luminal domain of Perk to assist in protein folding. This dissociation results in the activation of Perk through oligomerization and
trans-autophosphorylation of the cytoplasmic kinase domain (
34). Similar to ER stress, hypoxia results in the activation of Perk and phosphorylation of eIF2α (
51), leading to the attenuation of translation initiation and the paradoxical translational induction of ATF4 (
9). ATF4 activates the induction of downstream UPR genes, including CHOP, BiP, and GADD34 (
7,
9). The mechanism of Perk activation, however, has not yet been elucidated. Activation of the ISR constitutes one arm of a larger coordinated program called the UPR. Hypoxic stress similarly results in the activation of other branches of the UPR, including the activation of another ER transmembrane protein, IRE-1 (
82). The role of hypoxic stress in the activation of the UPR has recently been thoroughly reviewed (
52).
Perk has been implicated in promoting cell survival and adaptation in response to a variety of environmental stresses, including ER stress (
31,
33) and hypoxia (
7,
9,
51). In response to hypoxic stress, Perk
−/− MEFs exhibit not only attenuated phosphorylation of eIF2α and reduced inhibition of protein synthesis but also reduced survival in vitro and in vivo. Tumors derived from cells with a compromised ISR (Perk
−/− MEFs, HT29 cells expressing dn-PerkΔC, and cells expressing an unphosphorylatable knock-in mutant, eIF2α
S51A) demonstrate reduced tumor cell viability compared to tumors with an intact ISR and result in smaller tumor growth (
7).
A growing number of studies now support the idea that mechanisms that regulate global mRNA translation can simultaneously control the translation of individual genes necessary for cell survival and adaptation during stress (
7,
9,
50). We previously demonstrated, through a collective analysis of data generated by microarray of polysome-associated mRNAs during prolonged hypoxic stress, the Perk-dependent translational regulation of ATF4, an important mediator of the ISR (
9). Similar analyses have been previously employed to identify translationally regulated genes involved in the host cell response to poliovirus infection (
48), T-cell activation (
65), VHL expression (
26), oncogenic signaling through Ras and Akt (
79) and, in a recent time course experiment, hypoxic stress (
50). The exact role that Perk plays in the progression of hypoxia tolerance, however, has not been fully elucidated. A previous microarray study identified several Perk-dependent transcriptionally induced changes in gene expression in an immortalized mouse hippocampal model for oxidative glutamatergic toxicity (
61); however, a large-scale analysis of Perk-mediated changes in translation had not been completed prior to this study. Our analysis revealed the Perk-dependent preferential translation of a wide variety of proangiogenic genes, indicating that Perk may play a fundamental role in the translational regulation of a complex process that regulates the development of hypoxia tolerance through multiple pathways. It seems unlikely that any single gene product regulated by Perk is solely responsible for the control of tumor angiogenesis in response to hypoxic stress; rather, the orchestrated expression of many complementary gene products is likely responsible. In this study, we examined how one of our validated candidates, VCIP, an α
5β
1 and α
vβ
3 integrin binding protein, is regulated at the translational level. The critical importance of VCIP gene function during angiogenesis is underscored by the observations that anti-VCIP antibodies block basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF)- and VEGF-induced capillary morphogenesis (
97) and that mouse embryos lacking the VCIP gene die between embryonic day 7 (E7) to E10.5 and demonstrate abnormal vascular development (
20). The proangiogenic growth factors, bFGF and VEGF, are capable of eliciting a strong transcriptional induction in VCIP gene expression; however, the posttranscriptional regulation of VCIP had not been previously investigated. Our data establish that hypoxic stress in the absence of exogenous growth factors can initiate a 10-fold induction in the steady-state levels of VCIP transcripts. Moreover, VCIP mRNAs demonstrated a 20-fold translational induction as determined by their increased association with polysomes following hypoxic stress, suggesting VCIP expression is regulated by both transcriptional and posttranscriptional mechanisms. The VCIP 5′UTR is unusually long (568 bp) and surprisingly highly conserved across mammalian species. Unlike ATF4, the VCIP 5′UTR did not contain multiple conserved uORFs; therefore, the mechanism utilized to maintain its preferential translation during hypoxic stress is not likely ribosome shunting or reinitiation. Instead, our data support the presence of an active IRES element within its 5′UTR, which may in part explain its preferential translation when global translation is largely inhibited. Using deletion constructs of the hVCIP 5′UTR, we were able to determine that the VCIP IRES element is present between 1 and 380 bp. Removing the bp 1 to 140 from this construct, however, abolishes any IRES activity despite our observation that the sequence between bp 1 to 140 alone does not contain any IRES activity, suggesting that this sequence is necessary to determine the optimal secondary structure of the VCIP RNA for IRES-mediated translation. Numerous studies have identified hypoxia-responsive genes that employ IRES elements to maintain their translational priority during stress; these include the platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) (
5), HIF1α (
54), VEGF (
66,
90), BiP (
62), TIE-2 (
74), and ornithine decarboxylase (
77) genes. The importance of IRES-mediated translation is revealed by the observation that mRNAs that contain IRES elements encode proteins that play important roles in cell growth, proliferation, differentiation, and the regulation of apoptosis, these being cellular programs that are often usurped by malignant cells (
40). This observation suggests that IRES-mediated translation may be an important mechanism utilized by the cell to maintain and induce gene expression in order to mediate cellular adaptation and cell viability when cells are faced with stressful microenvironments. A possible connection between eIF2α phosphorylation and IRES translation has also been proposed. The activities of cat1, PDGF2, VEGF, and c-
myc have been shown to increase either during differentiation or in response to various cellular stresses that increase the phosphorylation of eIF2α (
21,
27). The mechanism for eIF2α phosphorylation-mediated IRES expression is not clear, as the phosphorylation of eIF2α results in the inhibition of ternary complex formation, a requirement for the initiation of all cellular mRNAs, including those that are regulated by cap-independent mechanisms. Whether eIF2α phosphorylation-sensitive IRES elements require specific
trans-acting factors to mediate their translational activation during cellular stress has not been elucidated, but this requirement could help to explain their dependence on the phosphorylation of eIF2α. Alternatively, mRNAs with IRES elements may compete with other cellular mRNAs for the limited translational machinery to ensure their translational priority during times of reduced protein synthesis. Another explanation includes the possibility that eIF2α is not the only substrate of the Perk kinase and that, in fact, other molecules may be modulated by direct Perk phosphorylation. Interestingly, in response to ER stress, eIF2α
S51A cells failed to induce approximately one-third of the genes that are normally induced by ER stress (
61), suggesting Perk is capable of mediating eIF2α-independent gene regulation. Recently, the bZIP transcription factor Nrf2 was identified as a second Perk substrate (
17). In response to Perk activation, Nrf2 is phosphorylated by Perk, which promotes its dissociation from Keap1, thereby facilitating its translocation to the nucleus, where it binds and activates the transcription of antioxidant genes (
93,
94). Aberrant Nrf2 regulation may help to explain why cells experience increased oxidative stress in the absence of Perk. Whether the translational regulation of the cohort of proangiogenic genes discussed here is done predominantly by eIF2α phosphorylation or whether they represent novel targets of Perk phosphorylation remains to be investigated.
The significance of Perk's role in regulating the translation of proangiogenic genes is emphasized by our observation that a wide variety of angiogenic genes involved in different braches of the angiogenic response demonstrated increased polysome association following hypoxic stress. Included in the Q-PCR-validated candidates is a matrix metalloproteinase, MMP13. MMP-mediated extracellular matrix and basement membrane dissolution is an essential event for endothelial cell activation, migration, and capillary formation. More recent studies have implicated MMP expression in earlier steps of tumor evolution, including the stimulation of cell proliferation and modulation of angiogenesis (
23,
24). The hMMP13 gene was originally identified in breast carcinoma, and its expression has since been related to other malignancies (
25). The expression of hMMP13 has also been linked to the progression of rheumatoid arthritis in the synovial membrane, a disease that shares features with tumor invasion (
58). Remarkably, hMMP13 transcripts are translationally silenced by the interaction of its 3′UTR and the nucleocytoplasmic shuttling protein TIAR (
15); to our knowledge, however, we are the first to describe the translational induction of MMP13 during hypoxic stress. VCIP may be similarly regulated, as it has been demonstrated to contain an unusually long 3′UTR (>2 kb). We found it to contain two 15-lipoxygenase differentiation control element (15-LOX-DICE) sequences. The CU-rich 15-LOX-DICE is one of the best characterized 3′UTR control elements (
80). Translational inhibition is mediated by the formation of a binary complex between the 15-LOX-DICE and KH domain proteins hnRNP E1 and K. Minimally, two 15-LOX-DICEs are required to confer translational repression of a transcript, and two to four repetitions per transcript is average. However, as many as 31 repetitions have been identified in a single 3′UTR (quail myelin protein mRNA) (
80). In light of this observation, we are currently undertaking efforts to determine if the 3′UTR and 5′UTR of VCIP mutually regulate its posttranscriptional expression under aerobic and hypoxic conditions.
What is the physiological role for Perk in the translational regulation of these proteins in the development of hypoxia tolerance? Cells with a compromised ISR pathway demonstrate severe sensitivity to hypoxia (
51) and pharmacological agents that promote ER stress (
33). Our studies corroborated findings from Bi et al., as tumors derived from transformed Perk
−/− MEFs are smaller than their wild-type counterparts. Furthermore, we made the observation that these tumors remained pale in color and did not appear to recruit angiogenic vessels as did wild-type tumors. In a mouse model of angiogenesis where tumor cells were cocultured with AP-expressing human microdermal endothelial cells, we made the observation that the tumor microenvironment imparted by Perk
−/− cells resulted in abortive angiogenesis. Inappropriate levels of the constellation of ligands and receptors required during vessel maturation can result in the production of abnormal vessels. Maturation requires the recruitment of mural cells, the generation of an extracellular matrix, and specialization of the vessel wall for structural support (
44). Expression of PDGF-B and ligation to its receptor (PDGFR-β) are required for the recruitment of pericyte progenitor cells and the eventual onset of vessel maturation (
14,
44). The significance of PDGF-B during angiogenesis is underscored by the observation that PDGF-B-deficient mice die in utero at day E7.5 due to the inability to assemble mature vasculature in several organs (
36,
44,
56,
57,
88). Furthermore, PDGF expression has been demonstrated to decrease over the progression of vessel maturation, indicating its requirement during the onset of maturation. Similar to hypoxic stress, cellular differentiation results in the inhibition of global protein synthesis, which correlates with the phosphorylation of eIF2α. Gerlitz et al. have demonstrated that IRES-mediated translation of PDGF during differentiation is dependent on the phosphorylation of eIF2α (
27). Although we were unable to detect any changes in PDGF expression by microarray, our analysis did reveal a Perk-dependent 2.6-fold induction in the translational efficiency of its receptor, PDGFR-β, whereas its expression in Perk
−/− MEFs was undetected relative to background (data not shown). Also critical for vessel formation and stabilization are the Tie receptors (Tie1 and Tie2). As mentioned previously, Tie2 is preferentially translated by an IRES element within its 5′UTR during hypoxic stress; however, whether IRES activity is dependent on eIF2α phosphorylation has not yet been determined.
Taken together, our data support the notion that Perk serves to fine-tune the translational efficiency of a subset of proangiogenic mRNAs during the course of hypoxic stress. Importantly, the inability to signal through Perk resulted in smaller tumor growth due in part to disregulated angiogenic signals that produced nonfunctional blood vessels. We propose that the translational regulation conferred by Perk in response to acute hypoxic stress represents a critical aspect in the development of hypoxia tolerance and in tumor growth. Results from this study further support the notion that Perk remains an attractive target for novel anticancer therapies.