This study examined the associations between cord blood PAH–DNA
adducts and birth outcomes and physical growth in a Chinese population
exposed to coal-burning emissions. There was a significant association
between elevated cord blood adducts and reduced birth head circumference, and
with reduced physical growth (decreased weight at 18, 24, and 30 months
of age), after adjusting for potential confounders. These
are potentially important findings because several previous studies have
reported a correlation between reduced fetal growth and poorer cognitive
outcomes (
Chaikind and Corman 1991;
Desch et al. 1990;
Matte et al. 2001). The findings are also consistent with prior reports that PAH–DNA
cord blood adducts in Caucasian, African-American, and Dominican
newborns were significantly associated with reduced fetal growth, alone
or in combination with ETS exposure (
Perera et al. 1998,
2003).
As noted above, distance from the power plant was not a good predictor
of PAH exposure or of outcomes. The present analysis did not include dispersion
modeling to take into account meteorologic factors such as wind
speed and wind direction. Because of these factors, subjects who live
the same distance from the power plant may receive different levels
of plant emission exposure, depending on their residential coordinate
relative to the plant. This may account for the observation that the
distance measurement alone was not a good predictor of adduct level or
birth outcomes and physical development. Future analyses will use dispersion
modeling to account for the impact of meteorologic factors.
In the multiple linear regression analysis, we found that the association
between greater adduct level and decreased at-birth head circumference
and physical development was significant only among females. In males, there
was an inverse relationship between cord blood adduct level
and birth outcome/physical development, but the associations were not
significant. Although our small sample size provided insufficient power
to detect significance in the interaction term, the findings suggest
that female fetuses may be more susceptible to the toxicity of PAHs
than male fetuses. The mechanism for a possible sex difference is not
clear; however, sexual dimorphism of
P450 gene expression may lead to higher susceptibility of female fetuses to
the toxicity of PAHs compared with male fetuses. CYP1A1 and CYP1B1 are
responsible for bioactivating PAHs such that they covalently bind to
DNA to form harmful PAH–DNA adducts (
Nebert et al. 2004). According to
Finnstrom et al. (2002), the expression of CYP1B1 is significantly higher in leukocytes of women
than men, and
Lin et al. (2003) showed that CYP1A1 and CYP1B1 levels in noninduced lymphocytes were significantly
higher in female nonsmokers than in male nonsmokers. In summary, higher
levels of CYP1 have been found in females in various studies, whether
in the noninduced state or after induction by a chemical
compound, which may result in sex differences in susceptibility to the
toxic effects of PAHs and other combustion-related pollutants (
Finnstrom et al. 2002;
Iba et al. 1999;
Lin et al. 2003;
Oropeza-Hernandez et al. 2003). Our small sample size provided insufficient power to detect significance
in the interaction term for sex as an effect modifier of the association
between adduct level and birth outcomes and physical development. Future
studies with larger samples are needed to determine whether
sex is a significant effect modifier of the association between adduct
level and birth outcomes and physical development.
Maternal adduct level was neither significantly correlated with cord blood
adduct level nor significantly associated with fetal and child growth. This
suggests that the biologic dose received by the fetus, which
depends partly on its genetic profile, is more relevant than the maternal
dose to fetal and child growth. Maternal adduct level may not correlate
with the cord blood adduct level because of the different genetic
profiles of the mother and the child. Our previous study involving
Polish mothers and newborns found that
CYP1A1 polymorphisms were not associated with maternal adduct level but were
associated with umbilical WBC adduct level (
Whyatt et al. 1998).
We also found that fetal and child growth were affected differently by
PAH–DNA adduct level and duration of exposure. Higher adduct level
was significantly associated with decreased birth head circumference
and reduced weight at 18, 24, and 30 months of age, whereas longer
duration of exposure was associated with reduced birth length and shorter
height at 18, 24, and 30 months of age. In addition, although significant
associations between adduct level and fetal and child growth
were only found among females, significant associations between duration
of exposure and fetal and child growth were present among both males
and females. A possible explanation of why longer duration of exposure
is significantly associated with worse growth outcomes in both sexes, not
just among females, is that although adducts represent the amount
of exposure to BaP, duration of exposure represents the amount of exposure
to multiple harmful compounds released by the power plant, including
other PAHs, PM, and metals. As mentioned above, we were able to
attribute seasonal variation in air pollution largely to power plant
emissions, which supports the assumption that a longer period of overlap
between gestation and plant operation is a proxy for higher in utero exposure to ambient PAHs and PM2.5 and other coal-burning emissions.
This study has the advantage of being based on individual data as well
as medical record and questionnaire data. In addition, we were able to
quantitatively measure the individual biologically effective dose of
BaP through the measurement of BaP–DNA adducts. However, the study
was limited by the modest number of subjects (150) for whom data
from all relevant domains were available. Because most study subjects
were exposed to power plant emission in both the second and third trimesters, we
could not evaluate trimester-specific effects of exposure on
fetal and child growth. Another limitation was that children received
postnatal exposure to power plant emission in addition to prenatal exposure. Because
of the power needs of the Tongliang community, the power
plant was shut down later than anticipated, and subjects continued
to receive exposure to the plant emission after birth. It is therefore
not possible to separate the impact of postnatal exposure from that
of prenatal exposure on child physical development.
Results from phase 2 of the Tongliang project, which is studying a second
cohort of children who were conceived after the power plant shutdown
and did not have in utero exposure to power plant emissions, will be presented in future publications.
In conclusion, these results indicate that PAHs from coal-burning power
plants are harmful to the developing fetus and child and have implications
for energy policy and health. The Tongliang coal-burning power plant
was shut down without serious economic consequences to the city, and
the energy needs formerly met by the plant were subsequently provided
by power from the grid. Because coal-fired power plants currently
produce 75% of China’s electricity and most new plants
are being built to burn coal, results from the Tongliang study have implications
for the health of many other children in China.