In eukaryotes, Pol I synthesizes large ribosomal rRNA (35S-45S depending on the species), Pol II synthesizes mRNAs and some small nuclear (sn)RNAs (e.g. U1, U2), and Pol III synthesizes mostly tRNAs and 5S rRNA, as well as U6 snRNA and few other non-protein coding transcripts (
1). Pols I, II and III all require TATA-binding protein (TBP) or a closely related protein for initiation even though some of the target genes do not contain the sequence-specific TBP-binding site, TATAAA (or closely related sequences, referred to as a TATA box or element) (
2,
3). In the absence of a TATA element, other factors bring TBP to the promoter via protein–protein interactions (reviewed in
4,
5). A second highly conserved initiation factor, TFIIB, exhibits very weak interactions with TBP in the absence of DNA, but recognizes the TBP–TATA DNA complex with substantially higher affinity (
6,
7). TFIIB and TFII
B-
related
factors (e.g. Brf1) are multifunctional proteins of central importance that interact with several other factors, help determine the start site of transcription, participate in promoter melting and select the appropriate Pol for transcription initiation (
8–
13). TFIIB is used by Pol II, Brf1 is used by Pol III for tRNA and 5S rRNA (TATA-less) genes, and a distinct protein, Brf2, is used by Pol III for human U6 and related type 3 genes that contain TATA elements (
14–
16).
The classical Pol III promoters that characterize the hundreds-to-thousands of tRNA and 5S rRNA genes in the traditionally studied eukaryotes use internal (i.e. downstream of transcription start site) promoter elements to initiate the process of transcription complex assembly. The assembly factor TFIIIC binds to the tRNA internal control elements and initiates protein–protein interactions that result in the deposition of TBP onto the TATA-less upstream DNA (
17–
20). Thus, direct association with Brf1 allows TBP to bind the upstream TATA-less DNA, even if it is comprised of only G and C residues (
16,
20,
21). In addition to the TATA-less pathway of TBP recruitment, this TBP–Brf1 arrangement can also support TFIIIC-independent transcription by Pol III,
in vitro, via direct recruitment of TBP by the TATA elements of the single U6 gene and the four TATA-containing tRNA genes (of a total of 274 tRNA genes) that can be found in the
Saccharomyces cerevisiae genome (
22–
24).
Characterization of the Pol III transcription system in the fission yeast
S.pombe has revealed, among other things, that all of its Pol III-dependent genes appear to contain upstream TATA sequences as one element of their multipartite promoters (
25–
27, reviewed in
28). Upstream TATAs were shown to be required for functional tRNA expression in
S.pombe and
in vitro, and for 5S rRNA synthesis
in vivo (
27). It is important to note for the purposes of this discussion that although a small number of TATA-containing tRNA genes from traditional organisms are known to exist, those that have been studied in great detail represent rare exceptions which in most cases characterize highly specialized tRNA genes (see discussion in
27). In contrast to this, all tRNA and 5S genes appear to contain upstream TATA elements in
S.pombe (
27). In the present study we examine the TBP-binding characteristics of SpBrf that are associated with the requirement for TATA elements in
S.pombe.
Although a prior study demonstrated that SpBrf co-purified with SpPol III and SpTFIIIC, while SpTBP did not, it did not assess the potential for interaction between TBP and Brf (
27). Because this potential would appear to be an issue of central importance to the requirement for upstream TATA elements, it was examined in detail. Here we show that SpBrf and SpTBP do not stably associate
in vitro nor are they found associated in extracts, as monitored by co-immunoprecipitation (IP), but that they can form a complex with TATA-containing DNA. The results indicate an innate insufficiency of SpBrf to bring TBP to the upstream DNA and that this represents a novel characteristic of the Pol III system in
S.pombe. While similar insufficiency would be detrimental in organisms with TATA-less Pol III genes, in
S.pombe this is balanced by the ubiquitous TATA elements that are precisely positioned upstream of the Pol III-transcribed genes in this yeast. Since a whole genome survey of
Arabidopsis thaliana also revealed TATA elements upstream of its tRNA genes, the Pol III transcription complex assembly pathway described here may be more widespread in nature than appreciated previously, and also suggests that it may represent an ancient eukaryotic Pol III transcription system.