What does the
Ciona sequence [
2] tell us about the innovations of vertebrates, chordates, and deuterostomes? Almost 62% of
Ciona genes (9,883) have a detectable protostome homolog, and these presumably constitute an ancient core of genes common to bilaterian animals. A few hundred
Ciona genes, including phytochelatin synthase and hemocyanin, have stronger similarity to genes of protostomes than to any vertebrate gene. Either these are ancient bilaterian genes whose vertebrate orthologs have been lost or changed beyond recognition, or they were perhaps acquired by horizontal transfer from protostomes. Conversely, around 15% of
Ciona genes (2,570) lack a clear protostome homolog yet have a vertebrate counterpart. These could have arisen in the deuterostome lineage after the split from protostomes, or alternatively they could be homologs of ancient bilaterian genes that have diverged beyond detection or been lost from modern protostomes. The genome sequence of an echinoderm, an outgroup to the chordates, will help determine if these genes are ancient within the deuterostomes [
16].
Rather surprisingly, 21% of
Ciona genes (3,399) have no clear homolog in the fly, worm, pufferfish, or human genomes (under high-stringency Smith-Waterman alignment along 60% of the target protein). Although this group might include poorly modeled genes or genes that have been broken by the ends of contigs, some may also have evolved so rapidly that they have lost significant resemblance to their orthologs, or they may be genes specific to urochordates or to ascidians. Resolution of this last ambiguity would require the sequencing of a distant urochordate genome, such as that of a larvacean [
17].
What can the
Ciona sequence tell us about vertebrate innovations? It can expedite the hunt for genes that are important in the development of the embryonic tissues that are widely believed to have initiated the evolution of the vertebrates [
18]. These include neural crest and ectodermal placodes, which contribute to the paired sensory organs and head skeleton that are so apparent in vertebrates but are seemingly lacking from other chordates. If these tissues evolved after vertebrate origins, what functions do crest and placode genes have in an ascidian? Might such genes reveal the evolutionary precursors of these tissues? Many genes central to these questions have already been investigated in ascidians by targeted sequencing [
19], but the
Ciona sequencing project has detected more peripheral players. For instance, three
Ciona genes (ci0100131069, ci0100130876 and ci0100135383) appear to be homologous to vertebrate genes encoding the olfactomedm family; one vertebrate member of this family,
Noelin-1, encodes a protein that makes the neural tube competent to generate neural crest cells [
20]. Two ascidian genes (ci0100149361 and ci0100140298) are homologous to the vertebrate
HAND1 and
HAND2 genes, which are also Important In crest development [
21]. And
Ciona has two orthologs (ci0100136347 and ci0100130219) of the vertebrate
Prox1 gene, a marker of lens, otic, olfactory, and ganglia placodes [
22]. The discovery of genes with only weak homology to olfactory receptors, however, undermines the prospects of discovering an olfactory placode precursor. Nonetheless, developmental biologists will be kept busy for some time studying the expression and function of these newly revealed genes.
Adaptive immunity involving lymphocytes appears to have arisen within the vertebrates; Dehal
et al. [
2] could not find
Ciona homologs of genes involved in this system, including immunoglobulins, T-cell receptors, or major histocompatability complex (MHC) genes. Furthermore, they found that, although
Ciona has orthologs for each of the 14 proteasome genes, it lacks immunoproteasome-specific genes, suggesting that
Ciona has no specific system for presenting antigens. Nevertheless, ascidians have a potent innate immune system [
23], including possible complement genes and several lectins.