In designing strategies to limit TSE infections and their propagation within hosts, it remains important to identify the most infectious particles and their molecular composition. For several protein aggregation diseases, such as Alzheimer's disease and other amyloidoses, recent studies suggest that instead of being pathological, the formation of large amyloid fibrils might be a protective process that sequesters more dangerous subfibrillar oligomers of the amyloidogenic peptide or protein into relatively innocuous deposits1
. Thus, efforts to disaggregate amyloid deposits might do more harm than good. Although TSE infectivity is associated with a wide range of PrPres
, little is known about the relative levels of infectivity with respect to particle size, PrP content, or other potential constituents. Furthermore, the size of the smallest infectious unit remains under dispute. Reports that sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS)-solubilized scrapie PrP monomers can be isolated as infectious units7-9
have not been confirmed10,11
. Radiation inactivation12-14
and liposome solubilization studies15
have suggested that the minimal infectious unit is between 50-150 kDa, which would correspond to 2-6 PrP molecules, but no such small oligomers have been isolated and determined to be infectious. The present study compares the scrapie infectivity and in vitro PrP-converting activity associated with particles ranging in size between the ill-defined smallest infectious unit and large amyloid fibrils, and evaluates which are the most active with respect to PrP content. An infectivity bioassay in hamsters was used to measure infectivity directly, whereas much faster in vitro PrP conversion assays were used as surrogates and supplements for the bioassay. Previous studies have shown extensive correlation between infectivity and in vitro converting activity6,16
To break down large PrPres
aggregates and create a range of smaller particles for evaluation of these activities, preparations of largely purified PrPres
were subjected to treatments with a variety of detergents and sonication. Initial results revealed that relatively small particles with high levels of converting activity were produced when SDS was used at a concentration of~1% (Supplementary Fig. S1). Subsequent analyses of the alkyl sulphate family of detergents indicated that further optimization was obtained by switching to sodium n-undecyl sulphate (SUS) treatment (Supplementary Fig. S2). SUS-treated samples were diluted so that the final SUS concentration (0.1%) was well below the critical micelle concentration, and fractionated according to size using flow field-flow fractionation (FlFFF). Particle molar mass and radius measurements were obtained through in-line light scattering and refractive index detectors. PrP molecules eluted in two major peaks, one spanning fractions 5-8 and another spanning fractions 19-27 (, filled circles). Dot-blot-based solid-phase conversion assays revealed that converting activity was first observed near fraction 10, rose to a plateau from fractions 12-18, and peaked around fraction 23 (, open circles). Data obtained from suspension-based conversion assays were consistent with these results, and confirmed that the products observed in the solid-phase conversion assays represented proteinase K-resistant PrP fragments of the expected size3
(Supplementary Fig. S3a). To assess relative infectivity levels, fraction aliquots were also quickly diluted into normal hamster brain homogenate and inoculated intracerebrally into hamsters. A marked shortening of the incubation period of disease was observed near fraction 9, indicating a substantial increase in infectivity17
, which peaked at fraction 12 and remained relatively steady throughout the rest of the elution (, red squares). Because titration of both purified PrPres
and scrapie brain homogenate stocks produced consistent incubation periods of disease with respect to levels of PrPres
(Supplementary Fig. S4a), LD50
(dose lethal to 50% of animals tested) values derived from 263K strain scrapie brain homogenates were used to estimate the levels of infectivity in the fractionated material (Supplementary Fig. S4b). This analysis indicated that the 28-day shortening of incubation period between fractions 7 and 12 corresponded to a >600-fold increase in infectivity. Given limits to the resolution of the FlFFF technique, it is likely that the low levels of infectivity and converting activity detected in fractions 5-8 actually represent the leading edge of activities associated with larger particles that peak in fractions ≤9. These results revealed a major discordance between the levels of PrP, converting activity and infectivity with respect to the size of the particles found in preparations of PrPres
Figure 1 Analysis of fractionated PrPres. a, Quantification of PrP (per 1-ml fractions) by dot immunoblotting with anti-PrP monoclonal antibody 3F4 (n ranged from 3 to 16 from four FlFFF runs), analysis of converting activity by solid-phase conversion assay ( (more ...)
Because PrP is often thought to be the major protein component of the infectious agent, the levels of converting activity and infectivity in the FlFFF fractions were divided by their total PrP content to give relative ‘specific converting activity’ (, circles; see also Supplementary Fig. S3b) and ‘specific infectivity’ values ( red squares). Both of these values peaked near fraction 12 and dropped off steeply to each side of the peak. Indeed, the early PrP-containing fraction 7 had~3,000-fold lower specific infectivity than the peak fraction 12, and the large aggregates in fraction 23 had~70-fold lower specific infectivity. This analysis revealed a tight correlation between specific infectivity and specific converting activity, and demonstrated that by far the most active particles per unit PrP peaked in fraction 12. Light scattering analyses of these particles indicated that they have apparent weight-average molar masses (MW) of several hundred kDa ( blue squares) and apparent radii in the 12-14-nm range ( green and violet squares).
summarizes the size parameters determined from four independent FlFFF experiments assessed for converting activity, and a single fractionation analysed by infectivity bioassays. The ratio (ρ) of the radius of gyration (rg
) to hydrodynamic radius (rh
) was calculated to estimate the compactness of the particles with peak specific infectivity and converting activity (fraction 12). The values (~0.90) are typical of fairly compact, spherical or ellipsoid shapes18
. By comparison, much higher ρ values were obtained for fractions 21 and 26, indicating the predominance of highly extended structures. Mean apparent values of~600 kDa (MW
) and~13.5 nm (rh
) were determined for the material in fraction 12. These values presumably represent the size of the infectious particles including any bound SUS molecules. Analyses of a set of proteins (bovine serum albumin, ferritin, thyroglobulin) in the presence or absence of SUS showed that observed MW
values could be increased by as much as 73% and 60% respectively in the presence of SUS (data not shown), suggesting that the particles in fraction 12 may have detergent-subtracted MW
values as low as~300 kDa and rh
values as low as~8.5 nm. Thus, these data indicated that the particles with the highest specific infectivity and specific converting activity were approximately 300-600 kDa, roughly spherical-to-elliptical, and 17-27 nm in diameter.
Biophysical parameters of fractionated PrPres
To assess more accurately the oligomeric state of PrP in the early fractions (<9) of the FlFFF separation, samples were subjected to PAGE without further denaturation. Protein (silver) staining () and PrP immunoblot () analyses of these gels revealed that PrP monomers and a ladder of discrete oligomers up to apparent pentamers (most visible in the immunoblot) peaked in fractions 5-8, which were extremely low in specific infectivity and specific converting activity (). However, in fractions 11-13, where the highest specific infectivity and specific converting activity were found, monomeric-to-pentameric structures were greatly reduced and larger oligomers above the 250 kDa marker predominated (). The converting activity associated with these oligomers was directly assessed by subjecting detergent-treated PrPres to PAGE as described above, and then electro-blotting the material onto a polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membrane for solid phase conversion analysis. Conversion products were only observed at the bands above the 150-250 kDa markers after SDS () or SUS (Supplementary Fig. S5c) treatments, even though the PrP content in the monomer and small oligomer bands was equivalent to, or greatly exceeded, the protein content in the higher bands (; see also Supplementary Fig. S5a, b). Thus, results obtained from PAGE-based analyses were in excellent agreement with those obtained from dot-blot-based solid-phase conversion analyses (), and revealed that infectivity and converting activity co-fractionated with structures larger than PrP pentamers, whereas PrP pentamers and smaller oligomers were devoid of converting activity.
Figure 2 PAGE analyses of detergent-treated PrPres. a, b, Samples from FlFFF fractions were subjected to PAGE on 3-8% Tris-acetate gels and analysed by either silver stain (a) or immunoblotting with anti-PrP monoclonal antibody 3F4 after transfer to PVDF (b). (more ...)
To visualize the sizes and shapes of fractionated PrPres particles, samples from representative FlFFF fractions were analysed by transmission electron microscopy (). Consistent with the high r values noted in , fraction 26 contained a preponderance of long fibrils, whereas fraction 21 contained shorter fibrils in conjunction with more amorphous material. Analysis of material from fractions 10 and 15 revealed a collection of smaller amorphous and spherical particles. Although it was unclear whether all of the amorphous/spherical particles contained PrP, the results confirmed that there were no visible fibrils in these fractions. Thus, the size and shape of the particles detected by transmission electron microscopy agreed with the light scattering measurements, indicating that the most infectious particles of PrPres were roughly spherical or ellipsoidal in nature, and~20-25 nm in diameter.
Transmission electron microscopy analyses of fractionated PrPres. Fraction numbers are indicated in the upper left of each panel. No particles were visible on control grids loaded with buffer alone. Scale bars, 100 nm.
TSE infectious units (prions) are likely to require both biochemical activity as initiators of PrP conversion and stability against degradation in the environment and the host. Whereas large PrPres
aggregates might be expected to have greater stability, smaller oligomers (4-15-mers) have been predicted to have greater converting activity and infectivity per unit mass19,20
. Our present data provide systematic evidence that although the infectivity per particle did not vary by more than approximately twofold between different sizes of infectious aggregates (see Supplementary Discussion), the most infectious units per mass of PrP, or the best apparent compromise between stability and activity, are~17-27-nm particles of~300-600 kDa. If these infectious particles are composed solely of PrP molecules averaging~21.5 kDa each (which may not be the case, see Supplementary Discussion), this would correspond to an oligomer of 14-28 PrP molecules. Interestingly, this size range is consistent with the smallest disease-associated PrP aggregates (600 kDa) observed previously21
. Our observations that the smallest stable unit with PrP converting activity is larger than a 5-mer concur with the results of a previous study that showed that SDS-generated oligomers comprising 4-6 PrP molecules with diameters of~10 nm are not infectious22
. Furthermore, we join others in failing to confirm previous reports of the generation of infectious PrP monomers in the presence of alkyl sulphate detergents7-11
. However, although we screened deliberately for conditions that generate small filterable particles with converting activity, it remains possible that other conditions can stabilize infectious particles that are smaller than PrP hexamers.
The fact that the most infectious units are much smaller than the amyloid fibrils that are often observed in TSE-infected tissues and tissue extracts reinforces concerns that incomplete attempts to destabilize PrPres
aggregates for the purposes of therapeutics or decontamination might result in unintended increases in infectivity. Consistent with this possibility, we observed that resonication (in 1% SUS) of large fibrillar PrPres
fractions from the FlFFF separation decreased the average fibril length (according to electron microscopy) and increased converting activity by several-fold (data not shown), and others have reported that sonication of PrPres
in the presence of phospholipids can increase scrapie infectivity levels15
. This is not to say that the most infectious particles are necessarily derived from in vitro fragmentation of PrPres
fibrils. Another strong possibility is that these particles are derived primarily from a distinct non-fibrillar PrP ultrastructure in TSE-infected brain tissue, such as the commonly observed amorphous membrane-associated deposits23
. Collectively, our observations support the emerging view that with protein folding/aggregation diseases, smaller subfibrillar particles may be much more pathological than larger amyloid fibrils or plaques.