The recent findings that nonhistone proteins serve as direct targets of histone acetylases have led to further mechanistic analysis of the substrate residues in transcription factor function (
81,
86). The AR conveys both
trans-repression and
trans- activation function. In the present studies, the AR acetylation site selectively regulated the AR
trans activation but not the
trans-repression functions. The sumoylation of the AR was unaffected by the mutation of the AR acetylation site in vitro. Ligand-induced conformational changes, assessed by limited protease digestion, showed a similar pattern induced by the ligand in the ARwt and the AR acetylation mutant. Intriguingly, the AR acetylation mutants showed increased N-CoR binding and reduced p300 binding compared with the wild-type AR. As p300 and N-CoR regulate ligand-dependent gene expression of other NHR, these studies suggest that the AR lysine residues may play an important role in a subset of AR functions by regulating recruitment of hormone-dependent coregulators.
The role of direct transcription factor acetylation in hormone signaling to endogenous androgen-regulated target genes was largely unknown. In the present studies, point mutation of the AR lysine residues, which was previously shown to abrogate acetylation of the full-length AR protein (
23), substantially reduced DHT-dependent activation of several androgen-responsive reporters, including the PSA promoter, the MMTV promoter, and a simple synthetic androgen response element.
PSA, an endogenous androgen-regulated target gene, is a prostate-specific kallikrein, the expression of which is used to monitor patients with prostate cancer (
24). The PSA promoter has been well characterized as an androgen-responsive gene. In the present studies, mutation of the AR acetylation site reduced the transcriptional activity of androgen-responsive reporter gene coactivation by several AR regulators (Ubc9, SRC1, TIP60). Ubc9
trans activation of the AR occurs independently of its ubiquitin-ligase function. The failure of Ubc9 to induce AR
K630A activity is consistent with previous findings that the AR hinge region, which includes the lysine motif, is required for Ubc9 binding and activation (
68). The interaction of SRC1 with the AR involves the glutamine-rich region of SRC1 and the AF-2 region of the AR. Coactivation of AR by SRC1 requires AD1 of SRC1, the same region responsible for recruitment of p300/CBP, and does not require the LXXLL motif that interacts with AF-2 (
12). Thus, failed SRC1 coactivation of the acetylation site mutants is consistent with defective p300 coactivation. TIP60 binds the AR through a region which includes the acetylation site (
15), conveys intrinsic HAT activity (
15,
90), and regulates DNA repair and apoptosis (
35). As TIP60 augmented the activity of the ligand-treated ARwt but not the AR mutant and MEKK1 augmented AR apoptosis in the presence of ligand, it will be of interest to further evaluate the role of TIP60 in AR-mediated apoptosis.
What common features shared by this subset of coactivators (SRC1, Ubc9, TIP60, and p300) might explain their reduced ligand-dependent coactivation of the AR acetylation site mutants? The bromodomains of several coactivators serve as recognition motifs providing recruitment to acetylated lysine residues (
36), and it is feasible that one or more of the bromodomain-containing coactivators (p300, P/CAF) serves as a docking module through the AR-acetylated residues for sequential recruitment of other coactivators. P/CAF, which failed to activate the acetylation site mutants (
23), is an important regulator of AR function in prostate cancer cells. P/CAF binds the AR in vivo (
73), binds p300, and contains a bromodomain that is required for AR binding. p300 is viewed as a limiting coactivator for many NR, including the AR; therefore, although the reduction in p300 binding to the AR mutants was modest, reduced recruitment of coactivators may contribute to the defective
trans activation of the AR acetylation mutants.
Transcriptional repression by N-CoR involves a multiprotein complex that includes HDAC complexes, chromatin remodeling proteins, and a transducin β-like protein that interacts with histones (
41,
59). In the present studies, the nuclear corepressor N-CoR showed proportionally more binding to the AR lysine point mutants in cultured DU145 cells. The enhanced N-CoR binding to the AR lysine point mutants may provide an important mechanistic link to the reduced activity of the AR acetylation-defective mutants. The finding that coactivator and corepressor surfaces of NR overlap substantially (
32,
66) is compatible with a dynamic model in which enzymatic modifications of the NR coordinate the sequential disengagement of corepressors followed by coactivator binding (
56). Enhanced corepressor binding of the AR acetylation-defective mutants suggests a role for acetylation in the disengagement of corepressors. Acetylation of upstream binding factor also correlates with reduced transcriptional repression by the pRB-recruited HDAC (
64). Together these studies provide evidence for a model in which acetylation disengages corepressors to sequentially recruit coactivators (
45).
Several observations in the present studies suggest that the defective transactivation of the AR acetylation mutants may relate to altered coactivator-corepressor binding and does not result from reduced expression levels or ligand binding. Firstly, expression levels of the ARwt and the AR
K630A or AR
K(632/633)A mutant proteins were similar in cultured cells, suggesting that reduced transactivation was not due to reduced expression. The AR acetylation site does not fall within the ligand-binding pocket deduced from the crystal structure (
55), the AR acetylation site mutants demonstrated wild-type ligand-induced protease sensitivity, and in vitro ligand-binding assays showed normal ligand-binding affinity at the physiological concentrations of ligand. Thus, the reduced ligand-induced transactivation of the AR acetylation mutants does not appear to be due to reduced expression or altered ligand binding. The recruitment of HDAC1/N-CoR-containing complexes to the promoters of target genes induces a repressive chromatin state through the functions of HDAC1 (
19,
50). It has been proposed that ligand-dependent activation of NHR involves both recruitment of coactivators and disengagement of corepressors (
27). The present studies of the AR are consistent with a model in which the selective defects in coactivation of the AR acetylation mutants may be due to increased binding of N-CoR regulated through the acetylation site.
The cellular phenotype regulated by direct acetylation of specific transcription factor events remains to be determined. Several studies have implicated direct transcription factor acetylation in regulating reporter gene expression (
81,
87). Thus, acetylation regulates the transcriptional activity of p53 (
28,
75), GATA-1 (
14), erythroid Kruppel-like factor (
95),
Xenopus NF-Y (
49), and the human immunodeficiency virus transactivator protein (Tat) (
42) in reporter assays. Only recently has the functional cellular phenotype governed by transcription factor acetylation been examined (
63). Acetylation site mutations of p53 were defective in repression of Ras-induced transformation, suggesting an important functional role for p53 acetylation in vivo (
63). In previous studies, the AR KXKK motif was both necessary and sufficient for acetylation by either p300 or P/CAF (
23). This motif resembles the C-terminal p53 acetylation motif and is highly conserved between NHR, suggesting an important biological function (
86). Activation of the MEKK1 pathway enhances AR activity and induces cellular apoptosis in prostate cancer cells (
2). In the present studies, AR acetylation was a critical determinant of the apoptotic response induced by MEKK1 in prostate cancer cells. Furthermore, stable cell lines expressing the AR acetylation mutants showed no enhancement of apoptosis by several agents in the presence of the ligand DHT. AR-dependent apoptosis has been observed in cultured cells and in transgenic mice in which the AR was targeted to the prostate by the probasin promoter (
80). Several agents can induce apoptosis through AR-dependent and AR-independent pathways. Ligand-dependent events correlate with AR-mediated nuclear events, as the AR is thought to be required for nuclear DHT function. Therefore, in the present studies, comparison was made between the vehicle and the ligand to examine those apoptotic events most likely regulated by the AR in the stable cell lines. It remains possible, although unlikely, that DHT may govern non-AR-dependent apoptotic events that were selectively altered by the AR acetylation site, for example, through altered expression of a paracrine growth factor. The mechanisms by which the AR acetylation site regulates cellular apoptosis remain to be further explored. The evasion of cellular apoptosis contributes to aberrant growth control during tumorigenesis in multiple settings. The identification of acetylation as a key posttranslational modification required for activation of the AR by multiple distinct coactivators suggests that these residues may form an ideal target for AR inactivation and tumor therapies.