In this study, we have shown that
H. ducreyi utilizes the products of the
satABCD genes to encode an ABC transporter for sialic acid uptake. Sequence comparisons with other ABC transporter systems suggest that these genes encode the PBP SatA, the integral-membrane permease protein SatB, and the ATPase SatD. These comparisons also show that the N terminus of the SatC protein contains a permease domain, while the C terminus contains an ATPase domain. How might sialic acid be transported by this novel ABC transporter? A hypothetical model for sialic acid transport in
H. ducreyi, based on the predicted protein functions, can be constructed as shown in Fig. . This model is based on the maltose transporter in
E. coli (
12). The sialic acid transporter model predicts that sialic acid is first bound to the PBP SatA. Binding of the sialic acid may increase the affinity of SatA for SatB/SatC. Binding of the SatA-sialic acid complex to SatB/SatC may decrease SatA's affinity for sialic acid. This decrease may allow the release of sialic acid, the reorientation of SatB/SatC, and the exposure of sites needed for ATP hydrolysis. After ATP hydrolysis, sialic acid is transported to the cytoplasm, and the rest of the complex returns to its original conformation.
The sialic acid transporter identified in
H. ducreyi is the first ABC transporter identified that transports sialic acid; however, sequence analysis suggests that it may be the first of many bacterial sialic acid ABC transporters yet to be identified and characterized (
67). In addition to
H. ducreyi, two other members of the
Pasteurellaceae family,
Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae and
Haemophilus somnus, may utilize an ABC transporter for sialic acid uptake. Both bacteria have proteins that are highly homologous to the
H. ducreyi SatABCD proteins. Proteins predicted from unfinished genome sequences of
A. pleuropneumoniae serovar 1 strain 4074 and
H. somnus 129PT are 86% identical (>510 amino acids) and 75% identical (>454 amino acids), respectively, to SatA from
H. ducreyi. The
H. ducreyi SatB protein is 92% identical (>317 amino acids) to a predicted protein from
A. pleuropneumoniae serovar 1 strain 4074 and 84% identical (>317 amino acids) to predicted proteins from
H. somnus 129PT and
H. somnus 2336. The
H. ducreyi SatC protein is 85% identical (>648 amino acids) to a predicted protein from
A. pleuropneumoniae serovar 1 strain 4074, 81% identical (>649 amino acids) to a predicted protein from
H. somnus 2036 and 80% identical (>649 amino acids) to a predicted protein from
H. somnus 2336. Similarly, the SatD protein is highly homologous to predicted proteins from
A. pleuropneumoniae and
H. somnus. These data strongly suggest that sialic acid is also transported by an ABC transporter in these members of the
Pasteurellaceae.
The gram-positive bacteria Corynebacterium glutamicum, Corynebacterium diphtheriae, and Streptomyces avermitilis, also have homologs of the sat genes. The satA gene of H. ducreyi has a 40% G+C content, similar to the overall G+C content of the H. ducreyi genome (38.2% G+C). In contrast, these gram-positive organisms have a high G+C content both in their respective genomes and in their satA homologs, suggesting that the sat genes were not recently passed to or acquired from each other.
Mechanisms of sialic acid transport are diverse among bacteria, even within their subfamilies. The sialic transporter in
E. coli, NanT, is a symporter of the major facilitator superfamily type of membrane transporters (
38,
67). In this type of transport, protons or metal ions are coupled to solute uptake (
67). The tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic-type of transporter has been proposed for sialic acid uptake in two members of the
Pasteurellaceae family,
Pasteurella multocida subsp.
multocida and
H. influenzae (
55,
67). The tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic transporters are predicted to have a periplasmic binding component and one membrane-spanning protein (
55,
67). The identification that
H. ducreyi, also a member of the
Pasteurellaceae family, transports sialic acid using an ABC transporter adds a third method of sialic transport. Thus, there are at least three different methods of sialic acid transport in bacteria. The finding that differences in the types of transport mechanisms used by these bacteria occur even within a family is intriguing and could represent the various needs and environments that these bacteria encounter, or alternatively, could be an example of convergent evolution.
Besides incorporation of sialic acid into LOS, lipopolysaccharide, and capsule, some bacteria are also able to utilize sialic acid as a carbon and nitrogen source (
45,
68). Studies of
E. coli have demonstrated that a number of genes are involved in the conversion of sialic acid to fructose-6-phosphate (
45,
68). After transport, the first step in the sialic acid catabolic pathway is its conversion to
N-acetylmannosamine (ManNAc) and pyruvate by the aldolase NanA (
45,
68). ManNAc is then phosphorylated by the ATP-dependent kinase NanK (
48); the product, ManNAc-6-P, is then converted to
N-acetylglucosamine-6-phosphate (GlcNAc-6-P) by the epimerase NanE (
48). Conversion of GlcNAc-6-P to glucosamine-6-phosphate (Glc-6-P) is performed by the deacetylase NagA (
45). Lastly, NagB is involved in the conversion of Glc-6-P to fructose-6-phosphate (Fru-6-P) (
45). Comparisons of the
E. coli genes involved in the sialic acid catabolism pathway to the
H. influenzae genome demonstrated that a number of potentially homologous genes were present (
66). These genes include
nanA,
nagA,
nagB,
nanK, and
nanE homologs. Mutagenesis performed on the putative
H. influenzae aldolase-encoding gene,
nanA, demonstrated that this mutant was unable to metabolize sialic acid and exhibited no detectable aldolase activity (
66). Whole-cell enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay of
H. influenzae nanA mutants, with the monoclonal antibody 3F11, demonstrated that the mutants had a dramatic increase in the level of sialylation of the LOS (
66). These data suggest that in these organisms there exists a balance between incorporation of sialic acid into LOS and the use of sialic acid as a carbon source. Sequence analyses of
H. ducreyi strain 35000HP, with the
H. influenzae sialic acid catabolic pathway genes, indicate that a region 5′ of
rfe contains putative
nanA,
nanE,
nagA, and
nagB homologs but does not seem to contain a
nanK homolog. Due to the apparent absence of a homologous
nanK in
H. ducreyi, it is currently unclear if
H. ducreyi possesses a functional sialic acid degradation pathway. Studies to discern whether this catabolic pathway is functional in
H. ducreyi are currently under way.
Since the accumulation of high levels of sialic acid in the cytoplasm have been shown to be toxic in some bacteria (
68), how might
H. ducreyi control uptake and intracellular levels of sialic acid? In this and previous studies,
H. ducreyi was grown on plates containing high levels of sialic acid (
22,
50). The presence of the sialic acid did not seem to affect the growth of the bacterium. To more quantitatively test whether the presence of high levels of sialic acid affected the growth rate of
H. ducreyi, growth curves of
H. ducreyi under low (~0.5 μM basal level in medium) (
50), medium (10 μM), and high (1 mM) sialic acid conditions were performed (
46). There were no differences in the growth rates suggesting that
H. ducreyi either regulates sialic acid uptake, degrades sialic acid, and uses it as a carbon source or that the bacteria are able to tolerate some intracellular accumulation of sialic acid. Both
E. coli and
H. influenzae seem to utilize their ability to degrade sialic acid as one mechanism of controlling the intracellular levels of sialic acid (
66,
68,
69). As noted above, it is currently unclear if
H. ducreyi is able to degrade sialic acid. Another possible mechanism for controlling sialic acid uptake may be through the PBPs. The PBPs from other bacteria have been shown to be important for controlling the amount and efficiency of solute uptake (
12,
14,
30,
31,
37,
45). Therefore, it is possible that SatA plays an important role in controlling sialic acid uptake in
H. ducreyi. One mechanism of control could be that the level of
satA expression is affected by the intracellular levels of sialic acid. When the intracellular pool of sialic acid is high, expression of
satA is downregulated; conversely, when the intracellular pool of sialic acid is low, expression of
satA is upregulated. This type of regulation has been shown to be effective for controlling intracellular pools of iron in a wide range of bacteria (reviewed in reference
18). Another possible option for
H. ducreyi to manage possible toxic levels of intracellular sialic acid is to have a relatively high tolerance for the accumulation of sialic acid. Under these conditions, the levels of SatA would not dramatically change under low or high sialic acid conditions; instead,
satA would be expressed constitutively and sialic acid uptake would not be tightly regulated. If this option is correct, it suggests that
H. ducreyi has a higher tolerance than
E. coli for the accumulation of sialic acid in the cytoplasm. The identification of the components of the
H. ducreyi sialic acid transporter should enable further investigation of the regulation of sialic acid uptake and utilization.
The role that sialylation of the LOS in
H. ducreyi plays in virulence is currently unclear. However, similar to other bacteria (
24,
58,
59),
H. ducreyi LOS plays a role in adherence to human cells (
2,
20). The exact role that LOS plays in facilitating this interaction has not yet been elucidated. Recent studies of
H. influenzae demonstrated that sialylation of the LOS played a role in biofilm formation (
23,
60). In addition, one of these studies demonstrated that these bacteria produce a biofilm containing α2,6-linked sialic acid (
23). Sialylation of LOS in
H. ducreyi could therefore play a role in adherence or possibly microcolony formation. Now that we have identified the sialic acid uptake system in
H. ducreyi as a novel ABC transporter (SatABCD), thus completing the identification of the major components of the sialic acid biosynthesis pathway, it should be possible to design experiments that will determine the role of sialic acid in the biology of this human pathogen.