The number of receptors and their residence time on the plasma membrane are critical determinants for the response of a cell to extracellular cues. Recycling is an efficient mechanism to ensure rapid delivery of receptors to the plasma membrane and to regulate membrane dwell time. Although much examination has resulted in a detailed view of the internalization of plasma membrane receptors, the molecular mechanisms of their recycling are yet to emerge with the same clarity. Recent results have suggested a role for myosins in recycling (
Neuhaus and Soldati, 2000 
;
Lapierre et al., 2001 
), implying a role for the actin cytoskeleton in this process. Studies using drugs that depolymerize actin filaments also implicate actin at a recycling step (
Durrbach et al., 1996 
;
Cao et al., 1999 
;
Zaslaver et al., 2001 
;
Sheff et al., 2002 
;
Engqvist-Goldstein and Drubin, 2003 
). We have found that an endosome-associated protein, hrs, is part of a protein complex that includes actinin-4, BERP, and myosin Vb, designated CART. The CART complex is required for efficient recycling of Tf receptors to the plasma membrane.
The interaction of an endosome-associated protein, hrs, with actinin-4, a nonmuscle actin binding protein, was unexpected. However, the hrs/actinin-4 interaction was observed using the two-hybrid approach and confirmed by both recombinant protein binding and immunoprecipitation experiments. The interaction seems specific for actinin-4, because other actinin isoforms were not found in the yeast two-hybrid screen. Actinin-4 is a member of a protein family that contains conserved structural and functional motifs. These motifs include: an F-actin binding domain, a pleckstrin homology domain containing a phosphatidylinositol bisphosphate binding site, and two EF-hand calcium-binding domains (
Honda et al., 1998 
). Little is known about the function of actinin-4, although an actin-bundling activity is suggested by the known activity of other actinin family members (
Honda et al., 1998 
). We have observed that actinin-4 does indeed bind to filamentous actin and has bundling, but not nucleation, activity (Lotfi and Bean, unpublished observations). In macrophages, actinin-4 is transiently associated with macropinosomes before their fusion with lysosomes, as well as with phagosomes (
Araki et al., 2000 
), suggesting a role for this molecule in two mechanistically similar types of endocytic trafficking (
Racoosin and Swanson, 1993 
). Interestingly, the depletion of actinin-4 or disruption of hrs/actinin-4 interaction results in a decrease in Tf recycling with no effect on EGF recycling or degradation and no effect on internalization of either Tf or EGF. These data suggest a specific role for actinin-4 and the hrs/actinin-4 interaction in receptor recycling from the early endosome to the plasma membrane.
We considered the existence of an hrs/actinin-4/BERP/myosin V complex based on the binary interactions between hrs and actinin-4, actinin-4 and BERP (
El-Husseini et al., 2000 
), and BERP with myosin V (
El-Husseini and Vincent, 1999 
). BERP is a ring-finger containing protein that interacts with the tail domain of myosin V (
El-Husseini and Vincent, 1999 
) through its C-terminal region and interacts with actinin-4 through its N-terminal region (
El-Husseini et al., 2000 
). BERP may function as an adapter protein between actinin-4 that has bound to endosomes and myosin V because it is enriched with endosomal membranes. Many ring finger-containing proteins have ubiquitin ligase activity that would be particularly interesting because receptor sorting is thought to be regulated by this protein modification. We have examined whether BERP is self-ubiquitinated or will ubiquitinate proteins from
E. coli lysate, although we have not detected ligase activity with either potential substrate (Lotfi and Bean, unpublished observations). The CART complex most likely has an ordered assembly for its formation. Specifically, the binding of actinin-4 to hrs is required for BERP to bind and the binding of BERP to actinin-4 is required for myosin V to bind. Disruption of any of the binary interactions comprising the quaternary complex inhibits Tf recycling, as does disengaging myosin V from actin (
Lapierre et al., 2001 
). These data suggest that the CART complex is required for a specific transport step necessary for recycling to the plasma membrane.
A role for the actin cytoskeleton in endocytosis has been controversial (
Durrbach et al., 1996 
;
Riezman et al., 1997 
;
Fujimoto et al., 2000 
;
Qualmann et al., 2000 
;
Gruenberg, 2001 
;
Engqvist-Goldstein and Drubin, 2003 
). In mammalian cells, many reports describe the dependence or independence of an intact actin cytoskeleton for early endocytic events such as internalization (
Durrbach et al., 1996 
;
Cao et al., 1999 
;
Fujimoto et al., 2000 
;
Qualmann et al., 2000 
;
Gruenberg, 2001 
;
Zaslaver et al., 2001 
). However, these studies have not focused on later events such as endosome motility or recycling. Studies using drugs that depolymerize actin filaments implicate actin at a recycling step (
Durrbach et al., 1996 
;
Cao et al., 1999 
;
Zaslaver et al., 2001 
;
Sheff et al., 2002 
). Furthermore, mutations or deletions of myosin subtypes associated with early endosomes specifically alter recycling from early endosomal compartments, further suggesting a role for actin in the motility of endocytic vesicles at a recycling step (
Neuhaus and Soldati, 2000 
;
Lapierre et al., 2001 
). Our data suggest a specific role for the CART complex in endosomal motility as well as a molecular mechanism linking endosomes to actin filaments essential for a particular step in the endocytic pathway. We propose that the CART complex facilitates recycling of molecules that are internalized and recycled by a constitutive, but not a ligand-induced, mechanism.
There are three myosin V family members in mammals (
Mercer et al., 1991 
;
Zhao et al., 1996 
;
Rodriguez and Cheney, 2002 
) that have been implicated in genetic diseases and membrane trafficking (
Mooseker and Cheney, 1995 
;
Hasson and Mooseker, 1996 
;
Titus, 1997 
). A role for myosin Vb in endocytic trafficking, specifically at a recycling step (
Lapierre et al., 2001 
;
Volpicelli et al., 2002 
), has been suggested based on the ability of the myosin Vb tail domain to retard recycling of the M4 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (
Volpicelli et al., 2002 
) and the Tf receptor (
Lapierre et al., 2001 
) and to result in the accumulation of Tf in pericentriolar vesicles (but see
Provance et al., 2004 
). Overexpression of tail fragments prevents binding of the myosin to its cargo, disengaging it from actin. The model proposed for the role of myosin Va in melanosome transport (
Gross et al., 2002 
) suggests that retrograde microtubule-based transport by dynein antagonizes anterograde transport by kinesin. Myosin V contributes to anterograde transport by capturing melanosomes in the cell periphery. Similar models have been proposed for chromaffin cell exocytosis (
Rose et al., 2003 
) and for vesicle transport in neurons (
Bridgman, 1999 
). The slow recycling kinetics and the pericentriolar localization of Tf when actinin-4 is depleted or when the hrs/actinin-4, actinin-4/BERP, or BERP/myosin V interactions are disrupted are consistent with this model.
The association of endocytic organelles with cytoskeletal networks would allow guided vesicular trafficking to subsequent cellular compartments. The complementary roles played by the actin cytoskeleton and microtubule network in the endocytic pathway (
van Deurs et al., 1995 
;
Durrbach et al., 1996 
;
Maples et al., 1997 
;
Murray et al., 2000 
) suggest that endosomes contain proteins allowing for movement on both types of cytoskeletal network. Small GTPases of the rab family have been suggested to be required for endosome motility and recycling. For example, rab5a is present on endosomes, is involved in endosome-endosome fusion (
Gournier et al., 1998 
), in linking early endosomes to microtubules, and in minus-end–directed movement (
Nielsen et al., 1999 
), although rab5a has not yet been demonstrated to interact with any motor protein. Rab 4 and rab 11 are endosome-associated proteins thought to be involved in recycling (
Van Der Sluijs et al., 1991 
;
McCaffrey et al., 2001 
;
Lindsay and McCaffrey, 2002 
;
Peden et al., 2004 
) but their precise roles and which of the many possible effectors are relevant for this function remains unclear (
Nagelkerken et al., 2000 
;
Cormont et al., 2001 
;
van der Sluijs et al., 2001 
;
Lindsay et al., 2002 
;
Fouraux et al., 2004 
;
Peden et al., 2004 
). The present data suggest that hrs may link endosomes to actin through actinin-4, BERP, and myosin Vb. Thus, rab 4, 5, and 11 proteins and hrs can associate with endosomal vesicles and may be involved in sequential stages of endosomal motility/maturation. For example, rab5 may allow for microtubule-dependent trafficking of early endosomes, whereas hrs is involved in actin-based trafficking and has a specific role in recycling from the early endosome.
Our proposal for a role of hrs in endosomal recycling is consistent with data showing that inactivation of its yeast ortholog, Vps27p, results in accumulation of both recycling Golgi proteins and endocytosed proteins in a class E compartment and suggests a generalized role of this protein and other class E proteins in endosomal recycling (
Piper et al., 1995 
). The role of hrs in endosomal recycling is not inconsistent with a hypothesis suggesting that hrs or Vps27p functions in endocytic protein sorting (
Katzmann et al., 2001 
;
Bilodeau et al., 2002 
;
Lloyd et al., 2002 
) and in early endosome fusion (
Sun et al., 2003 
). These studies have suggested that hrs/Vps27p is linked with proteins required for the ubiquitination and sorting of cargo (
Katzmann et al., 2001 
;
Bilodeau et al., 2002 
) and that hrs inhibits homotypic early endosome fusion (
Sun et al., 2003 
). Hrs/Vps27p may bind ubiquitinated cargo with its UIM domain (
Bilodeau et al., 2002 
;
Polo et al., 2002 
;
Shih et al., 2002 
), which is required for its cargo sorting function because mutation of that domain blocks sorting of ubiquitinated cargo proteins (
Bilodeau et al., 2002 
;
Shih et al., 2002 
). The endosomal sorting function also has been hypothesized to require a protein complex called ESCRT I (
Katzmann et al., 2001 
). Hrs has been suggested to recruit the ESCRT 1 complex to early endosomes. The role of hrs in recruiting sorting or signaling components to the endosomal membrane likely is a function of a number of factors, including its oligomerization (
Bean et al., 1997 
) and/or competition among binding proteins (
Bean et al., 2000 
). Therefore, hrs may bind to an endosomal receptor, SNAP-25, by using its Q-SNARE domain and inhibit endosomal fusion (
Sun et al., 2003 
), whereas it is involved in cargo sorting and/or endosome motility using N-terminal VHS, FYVE, or UIM domains or via actinin-4 interactions. Thus, a sorting step might occur before, or coincident with, the inhibition of fusion. Subsequently, if endosomes destined for different cellular destinations used a diverse assortment of molecules to associate with various cytoskeletal elements, this would allow them to achieve the sorting and distinct routing required for separating receptors to be recycled from those to be degraded.
We have presented a model for the role of the CART complex and the actin cytoskeleton in endosome recycling (). Because much of hrs is cytosolic, it likely cycles on and off the early endosomal membrane (
Komada et al., 1997 
;
Tsujimoto et al., 1999 
), perhaps via binding to a protein receptor (, step 1), before binding actinin-4. Our data suggest a sequential association of complex components such that once the actinin-4 has bound hrs, BERP may bind, followed by myosin V although subcomplexes may form and unite. Association of the endosomal CART complex with actin filaments would facilitate rapid movement of the endosome back to the plasma membrane. The majority of EGF receptor would bypass this recycling step (, step 2) after ligand-induced internalization and would instead travel through the multivesicular body (MVB) en route to the lysosome for degradation. A minority of EGF receptor would recycle to the plasma membrane (from the MVB or recycling endosome) along with some Tf receptor (through the recycling endosome), in slower CART complex-independent pathways. The large number and varied function of molecules that undergo constitutive endocytosis suggests that the CART molecular interaction may be critical for many cellular functions.